- Joined
- Feb 17, 2016
- Messages
- 1,527
I have a 16 amp oven and was wandering if I need a certain type of ramp and soak pid for this?
The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is available! Price is $250 ea (shipped within CONUS).
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/
Do I need a pid that has manual operation and ramp soak operation or is ramp and soak version enough? D2, 01, 1095, ATS 34, 154CM, 440-C is what I will mostly use.
The unit I purchased from Auberins will Ramp/Soak and has manual operation. The ramp/soak are merely programmable capabilities of the unit.
Manual ops are ok for simple steels, but ramp/soak is necessary for your stainless heat treats. You have a mixed bag of steels so for a couple bucks more the ramp/soak is your best buy.
All I've read states you just auto tune for the lowest temp you intend to use. This in the manual for my PID.Don't forget also that you have to tune the controller PID loops for each temperature range you want to use. The Automation direct controller I use has 4 different PID loops that I have tuned in for different temperatures. The reason being is the PID loop for 400ºc, 800ºc and 1100ºc will be much much different form eachother. That way you will be ensured that you won't over-run or under-run the set temp. Hope that make sense.
All I've read states you just auto tune for the lowest temp you intend to use. This in the manual for my PID.
I have not found this to be the case with my set up. I believe the documentation I have says to autotune to the lowest temp you intend to use because overshoot is way more likely at low temps. At 1950°F my oven creeps up to temp. Like 1 degree every 5-6 seconds or so.The problem with this can be to get to say 400ºc is a walk in the park for the oven and the controller will start pulsing the power to the elements very early to avoid over-run and pulse the elements for very short periods to avoid under-run. At 1100ºc the power needs to stay on longer and start pulsing much closer to the set point. If it starts pulsing too early it will take a long time to reach the final set point and when the set point is reached will need to pulse the power on for longer to avoid under-run once the setpoint is reached.
This has been my experience anyway and I will only get a few degrees over and under-run. for each temp I ran a PID cycle tune from cold.
Happy Grinding