Need some help making a decision

Joined
Jul 16, 2007
Messages
1,794
So I finally decided to switch from keeping my normal day/overnight pack loaded up to a more permanent evacuation bag. The problem as it stands, is that I tend to want to use every knife I own, including the numerous fixed blades that I have acquired over the years. So herein lies the problem. I don't know which blade I want to pack away. Right now, I have the bag packed up with a Mora 510, a Glock Knife, a Byrd Wings, and a Swiss Army WorkChamp. It's the glock knife that bothers me in this scenario. It is up to the tasks of being "tough" but that edge, I just know it won't hold well if it needs to be used. I "think" I need to suck it up and duplicate a knife I already have and trust, such as a Onatrio Pilots knife or an additional Kabar style. Something I can toss in there, trust, and have enough familiarity with to know it will complete my needed tasks. Here are my choices, and wherein your advice.
Marine Combat - probably going to be a kraton from Ontario or Kabar, as those are less expensive.
Pilots survival - speaks for itself - I have seen factory seconds that were dirt cheap - how do those hold up.
Buck 119 - I actually don't have one currently, but it was the fixed blade I learned on.
BM Rant DPT - probably at the upper level of what I want to spend, and maybe too much for a duplicate? Not sure.
This may seem crazy, I don't know - feel free to tell me I am thinking about it too much.
 
My suggestion, which isn't on your list, would be a Becker BK-2. It's tough as nails, and inexpensive, too.
 
Too expensive for the bag, and it is also a knife I want, and would use - this needs to go in the bag and stay there, hopefully never to see the light of day.
 
Too expensive for the bag, and it is also a knife I want, and would use - this needs to go in the bag and stay there, hopefully never to see the light of day.

Well, I got a BK-2 for only $65 (including shipping), so it's not terribly expensive to have in your bob. My second choice, which is on your list, would be the pilot's survival knife. You're right: they're dirt cheap some places, and I think they're really underrated for what you want to use it for. They're not pretty, but they're functional as all get out.
 
Yes, they are. It was my first choice for the bag because I have one, have used it or another like it for years. Problem is, it is one of the knives I take into the woods regularly, and I want something I can put away and not get the urge to go grab it and use it. I think ultimately it will be the kabar or pilots survival.
 
Hey Smash, If it's a knife you like and want to use, get 2 of them. One for your kit and one to use every day. Thay way you know your kit knife and are comfortable with it. If the BK2 is to expencive for you, check out the HI forum and Yangdu's Deals of the day. You can sometimes snag two JKM-1's or Kumar Karda's for around $30 each. They make great camp/kit knives.

Heber
 
Back
Top