Boy, what a can of worms you just opened up.
Picking a handgun for protection is very personal choice; complicated by your own daily habits, environment, and shooting skills.
Those of you who know me know that I've collected, carried, shot
alot of handguns--easily 100 or more different styles, sizes, and calibers. I am a 1911 fan too, and love shooting and gunsmithing them.
That being said, my vote is for the
Glock 26 (9mm) or 27 (.40S&W), or their slightly larger siblings the
Glock 19 (9mm) or 23 (.40S&W).
What do I carry/use for personal protection? In a word--
Glock. Glock 26 for CCW, Glock 17 or 23 for home, Glock 20 for the backcountry. (Oddly enough, I do not own any .45-caliber Glocks--probably cause I have so damn many 1911's already.)
Why? Because I've done enough shooting to know I shoot Glocks well
under stress. Have I fumbled over a 1911-safety under the stress of competition--heck yes. Have I fumbled over a Glock safety--never, there is none. See my point? Additionally, Glocks are
reliable as hell, more accurate than you are, unbelievably durable & corrosion-resistant, lightweight, and relatively inexpensive--a very tough combination to beat.
Do I like to shoot handguns other than Glock? You betcha. Will I occasionally carry or use other handguns for protection? Sure, variety is the spice of life.
But when the adrenaline dumps, my first preferrence is Glock.
BTW,
click here to read a thread entitled
"Recommend Handgun?" over at
USN.