New Glass Tops Steel in Strength and Toughness

Joined
Mar 27, 2010
Messages
4,995
Glass stronger and tougher than steel? A new type of damage-tolerant metallic glass, demonstrating a strength and toughness beyond that of any known material, has been developed and tested by a collaboration of researchers with the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)’s Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (Berkeley Lab)and the California Institute of Technology. What’s more, even better versions of this new glass may be on the way.

“These results mark the first use of a new strategy for metallic glass fabrication and we believe we can use it to make glass that will be even stronger and more tough,” says Robert Ritchie, a materials scientist who led the Berkeley contribution to the research.

The new metallic glass is a microalloy featuring palladium, a metal with a high “bulk-to-shear” stiffness ratio that counteracts the intrinsic brittleness of glassy materials.

“Because of the high bulk-to-shear modulus ratio of palladium-containing material, the energy needed to form shear bands is much lower than the energy required to turn these shear bands into cracks,” Ritchie says. “The result is that glass undergoes extensive plasticity in response to stress, allowing it to bend rather than crack.”

Ritchie, who holds joint appointments with Berkeley Lab’s Materials Sciences Division and the University of California (UC) Berkeley’s Materials Science and Engineering Department, is one of the co-authors of a paper describing this research published in the journal Nature Materials under the title “A Damage-Tolerant Glass.”

Co-authoring the Nature Materials paper were Marios Demetriou (who actually made the new glass), Maximilien Launey, Glenn Garrett, Joseph Schramm, Douglas Hofmann and William Johnson of Caltech, one of the pioneers in the field of metallic glass fabrication.
Robert Ritchie holds joint appointments with Berkeley Lab and UC Berkeley (Photo by Roy Kaltschmidt, Berkeley Lab Public Affairs)

Robert Ritchie holds joint appointments with Berkeley Lab and UC Berkeley (Photo by Roy Kaltschmidt, Berkeley Lab Public Affairs)

Glassy materials have a non-crystalline, amorphous structure that make them inherently strong but invariably brittle. Whereas the crystalline structure of metals can provide microstructural obstacles (inclusions, grain boundaries, etc.,) that inhibit cracks from propagating, there’s nothing in the amorphous structure of a glass to stop crack propagation. The problem is especially acute in metallic glasses, where single shear bands can form and extend throughout the material leading to catastrophic failures at vanishingly small strains.

In earlier work, the Berkeley-Caltech collaboration fabricated a metallic glass, dubbed “DH3,” in which the propagation of cracks was blocked by the introduction of a second, crystalline phase of the metal. This crystalline phase, which took the form of dendritic patterns permeating the amorphous structure of the glass, erected microstructural barriers to prevent an opened crack from spreading. In this new work, the collaboration has produced a pure glass material whose unique chemical composition acts to promote extensive plasticity through the formation of multiple shear bands before the bands turn into cracks.

“Our game now is to try and extend this approach of inducing extensive plasticity prior to fracture to other metallic glasses through changes in composition,” Ritchie says. “The addition of the palladium provides our amorphous material with an unusual capacity for extensive plastic shielding ahead of an opening crack. This promotes a fracture toughness comparable to those of the toughest materials known. The rare combination of toughness and strength, or damage tolerance, extends beyond the benchmark ranges established by the toughest and strongest materials known.”

The initial samples of the new metallic glass were microalloys of palladium with phosphorous, silicon and germanium that yielded glass rods approximately one millimeter in diameter. Adding silver to the mix enabled the Cal Tech researchers to expand the thickness of the glass rods to six millimeters. The size of the metallic glass is limited by the need to rapidly cool or “quench” the liquid metals for the final amorphous structure.

“The rule of thumb is that to make a metallic glass we need to have at least five elements so that when we quench the material, it doesn’t know what crystal structure to form and defaults to amorphous,” Ritchie says.

The new metallic glass was fabricated by co-author Demetriou at Caltech in the laboratory of co-author Johnson. Characterization and testing was done at Berkeley Lab by Ritchie’s group.

“Traditionally strength and toughness have been mutually exclusive properties in materials, which makes these new metallic glasses so intellectually exciting,” Ritchie says. “We’re bucking the trend here and pushing the envelope of the damage tolerance that’s accessible to a structural metal.”

The characterization and testing research at Berkeley Lab was funded by DOE’s Office of Science. The fabrication work at Caltech was funded by the National Science Foundation.

Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory is a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) national laboratory managed by the University of California for the DOE Office of Science. Berkeley Lab provides solutions to the world’s most urgent scientific challenges including sustainable energy, climate change, human health, and a better understanding of matter and force in the universe. It is a world leader in improving our lives through team science, advanced computing, and innovative technology. Visit our at www.lbl.gov

Additional Information

For more information on the research of Robert Ritchie, visit the Website at http://www.lbl.gov/ritchie/

For more information on the research of William Johnson visit the Website at http://www.its.caltech.edu/~vitreloy/index.htm

http://newscenter.lbl.gov/news-releases/2011/01/10/new-glass-tops-steel/
 
Hmm.. that is interesting but even if it has strength and toughness, it says nothing about hardness right..?
 
If it's anything like regular glass, it's harder than any steel that I've heard of.

You are not understanding the technology. It is not a forgone conclusion that the hardness is greater than that of standard steel alloys.

This is not "glass" as in silica. It is "metallic glass". It's talking about the state of the matter rather than the composition of the matter. "glass state" vs. "crystalline state". For that matter, in the article you cited, the primary element in the alloy was palladium, a metal.

Wiki is sometimes suspect, but there is an article which explains more completely:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amorphous_metal

An amorphous metal is a metallic material with a disordered atomic-scale structure. In contrast to most metals, which are crystalline and therefore have a highly ordered arrangement of atoms, amorphous alloys are non-crystalline. Materials in which such a disordered structure is produced directly from the liquid state during cooling are called "glasses", and so amorphous metals are commonly referred to as "metallic glasses" or "glassy metals". However, there are several ways
 
You are not understanding the technology. It is not a forgone conclusion that the hardness is greater than that of standard steel alloys.

This is not "glass" as in silica. It is "metallic glass". It's talking about the state of the matter rather than the composition of the matter. "glass state" vs. "crystalline state". For that matter, in the article you cited, the primary element in the alloy was palladium, a metal.

Wiki is sometimes suspect, but there is an article which explains more completely:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amorphous_metal

Sorry, I just read what the OP posted which didn't make that clear, I didn't follow the links. I didn't cite any article.
 
I've known about this stuff for years now, and it's been around for decades. They've just only recently been perfecting its production in large quantities and fixed its shattering problems. It'll be interesting to see where things go with it, but things seem to have been slow so far. LiquidMetal is a company that specializes in it.
 
Proof that Star Trek 4 actually happened!

Sorry, I couldn't resist.
Looks neat, unfortunately until the stuff is produced in quantity and knife manufacturers can get their hands on it we'll just have to put it on the same shelf as Nitinol (A material I still have high hopes for, and is probably more practical).
 
Sounds like a pain to sharpen. But I'm still waiting on a folder with a diamond edge:thumbup:.
 
Transparent aluminum............
scottyMS2804_468x591.jpg
 
Who's to say they didn't invent the stuff?
 
If they can quench a 6 mm rod fast enough, they ought to be able to quench a 3 mm flat bar.

How strong is this stuff compared to tempered 1095 steel? The question of hardness is also interesting. Palladium is really expensive, and silver is no bargain, either. Nevertheless, a toughened glassy blade material is fascinating to consider.
 
all new possibilities are interesting but i remember the big splash about ceramic blades. ceramic certainly did'nt change the way the earth turned.
dennis
 
They say strong and tough, but that is only 2 of the material attributes a knife needs. It also needs to be hard and preferably abrasion resistant. Even if the edge is super hard, if the material wears down too quickly it will be relegated to the same category as stuff like 12C27 at a high hardness. Great for thin edges, not so great on cardboard.
 
all new possibilities are interesting but i remember the big splash about ceramic blades. ceramic certainly did'nt change the way the earth turned.
dennis
^^^This.

Sometimes it's good to stay with what you're familiar with, as Dozier might tell you:rolleyes:.

Still, I wonder what's particularly unsatisfying about powder metal steels with extremely high vanadium content. I assume the idea behind using glass and ceramic as a knife blade is all about the high hardness and edge retention. I wouldn't advise anything more difficult to sharpen than S90V unless they start selling the Wicked Edge knife sharpener(with complete set of stones) for $100.
 
Here's the abstract.

Excerpts from the article (Being within my rights to reproduce small sections of this article, even though it has not yet been published, according to the Fair Use Doctrine found in Chapter 1 Section 107 of U.S. Copyright Law):

Chemical composition of their glass: Pd79Ag3.5P6Si9.5Ge2

An interesting property of the material:

"More interestingly, the rising R-curve (Fig. 3b) indicates that the glass toughens as a crack extends: an attribute of ductile crystalline metals not previously thought possible for an amorphous material."


There's also a figure in the article, which I don't have permission to reproduce, that shows the yield strength versus fracture toughness of a whole slew of materials (metallic glasses, engineering polymers, engineering metals, engineering ceramics, metallic glass composites, and silicates) including this materials category. This particular glass in that figure (represented by a star) is shown to be comparable to the toughest engineering steel (low-carbon steel- very tough) yet a yield strength in the upper 1/3 of engineering steels.

More information about the tensile strength:

"A glass-transition temperature of 613 K is observed in the thermal scan. Using ultrasonic measurements, the bulk and shear moduli were measured to be 172 GPa and 31 GPa, respectively, with a Poisson ratio of ~0.42. A representative loading curve obtained for a bulk specimen loaded quasi-statically in tension is presented in Fig. 2a, with corresponding micrographs of the fracture surface in Fig. 2b. The tensile loading response seems to depart from linear elasticity and, on yielding, several slip events are evident (see the inset in Fig. 2a). The stress of 1,490 MPa marking the first slip event is taken to represent the material plastic yield strength.."

Which, using the tensile strength as an estimate of hardness is ~45.5 Rc (using this online tool).

Last words in the article:

"As shown in the map, the toughness-versus-strength data for the present glass lie outside the benchmarks established by the strongest and toughest steels. In summary, the present results demonstrate that the combination of toughness and strength (that is, the level of damage tolerance) potentially accessible to amorphous materials extends beyond the traditional limiting ranges towards levels previously inaccessible to any material."


I'm not sure by what they mean by "lies beyond the benchmarks" as the glass they synthesized in the article lies well inside the strength benchmarks for steel. I'm guessing they're talking about the combination of strength and toughness being outside the benchmarks, which it truly is. Their diagram also indicates the potential for such glasses with strengths outside any engineering steel while retaining the toughness of the strongest engineering steel. Alternatively, it also indicates the potential for matching the strength of the strongest engineering steel while retaining a toughness laying in the upper 1/3 of the steel range, or around the toughest titanium alloy (I came to this conclusion by extrapolating their estimate).

Damn interesting!
 
Back
Top