New Hogstrom Dagger

I know, it should've been "asymetrical" there and not "un"....was in a rush when writing - I have more ego in getting this type of stuff right than anything else ;)

Out to a stand up comedy gig...my first and should be fun - yiehhaaa! :-)
 
Okay. I see your point and really by adding these two photos, I retract the comment about the "afterthought". The photo in the OP doesn't show the fit into the guard and when I see these I see a much more integral element.

DSC_0007_2.jpg


DSC_0011_8.jpg


However, I see the others' asymmetry as more coherent design than this one. In those, the asymmetry extends beyond one element in the knife. The grind will be balanced in the guard, or the habaki or something else. This gives a more unified sense to me.
This example though is purely symmetrical except for the ring alone and in that isolation, it seems a less balanced asymmetry.

Maybe your "balanced" asymmetry had become too symmetrical for you. :p
 
Haha...perhaps you're right :)....the asymmetry in my head is becoming symmetrical and predictable....yikes, scary thought ;)

Well, I appreciate your opinions - nice to get someone else's view on the whole thing
 
Thanks for answering my questions and providing the additional photos. I like this piece even more now that I can see the detailing around the ring. :thumbup:
 
Holy smokes that is an awesome knife. Screw symmetry (Steven) ;) I like seeing twists on a classic and common pattern
 
cnas122 said:
Holy smokes that is an awesome knife. Screw symmetry (Steven) ;) I like seeing twists on a classic and common pattern
Click to expand...

Cambpell,

Thanks again for breakfast at Blade......:)........

Screw symmetry on a dagger.....are you completely insane?

Screw what makers have been trying to accomplish for centuries on the whim of a standup comedian/knifemaker from Sweden?

Whatever, dude....perhaps you should stick to what you know, and imo, if Anders made a slipjoint, it would bind, have a cant to one side and wobble front to back....you would probably find that a refreshing change from the constrictions of the norm.:D

Best Regards,

STeven Garsson
 
I like this knife. The blade is spectacular and I like the overall handle configuration but I'm not partial to the bronze.....I probably would have chosen sterling silver and Damascus if it were mine, with some light engraving.
 
Last edited:
Stevie, Stevie, Stevie...think about how much fun it would be walking around twirling that dagger on your pointer finger like an old Colt 45
 
cnas122 said:
Stevie, Stevie, Stevie...think about how much fun it would be walking around twirling that dagger on your pointer finger like an old Colt 45
Click to expand...

I need no ring to twirl a dagger like an old .45, amigo!

Best Regards,

STeven Garsson
 
SharpByCoop said:
We'll get a chance to inspect this one again soon. Like many acquired tastes, I suspect it will grow on you.
Click to expand...
After handling this in-person I'll stick with my prediction above.

orig.jpg


This knife is substantial. Disregard how 'asymmetrical' it should be visually, holding it with your forefinger in that ring, it feels secure and even guarded. A knife is first and foremost supposed to be able to be used, right?

It a magnificent piece and I didn't find the ring as out-of-place as others may find. We all know: You can't please everyone.

The materials and that notable hamon are just great. A rich knife.

Coop
 
SharpByCoop said:
After handling this in-person I'll stick with my prediction above.

This knife is substantial. Disregard how 'asymmetrical' it should be visually, holding it with your forefinger in that ring, it feels secure and even guarded. A knife is first and foremost supposed to be able to be used, right?

It a magnificent piece and I didn't find the ring as out-of-place as others may find. We all know: You can't please everyone.

The materials and that notable hamon are just great. A rich knife.

Coop
Click to expand...

Nice pic.

Would you buy it?...Probably one of the most important questions.

IF it didn't have the ring, and used something like a nice burl for the handle....I'd buy it....Anders prices aren't bargain basement either.

Best Regards,

STeven Garsson
 
Awesome everything, but those rings were pretty much only used in some Italian and Spanish Renaissance daggers, I'm assuming to help contol thrusts into small chinks in plate armor. I agree, it detracts from an otherwise amazing knife. What a hamon!
 
Dang that looks good! :)

I LOVE LOVE LOVE how Anders did the ivory... so cool.

STeven brings up the million dollar question though!

As a maker it's warm and fuzzy for me to like it and think it's awesome... but I won't be buying any knives anytime soon... so my money is NOT where my mouth is in such cases. ;) :o :).

Coop... just like Don said... that photo sure is easy to look at!!! :thumbup: :cool:


<<<<<<<<<< Warm and fuzzy or not---- Anders, your work is outstanding!!! :D >>>>>>>>>>
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top