New Hunter

Kevin Jones said:
It's quite amazing how many knifemakers have taken up engraving in the last few years. Some have become pretty dang good at it.
Click to expand...

Kevin, I've noticed the same thing. But what I have also noticed is that, while most have the technical competence to engrave, some lack the eye of the real engraver, in design, technique, skill and implementation.

I've seen where patterns don't quite work, where patterns on the fittings don't seem quite right, are unbalanced, etc. I'm sure you know what I mean because you have a really keen eye for it.

I think some makers want to learn engraving perhaps too quickly and don't have "the eye". Perhaps they are thinking it's "the next step".

I laud the makers who have become accomplished engravers. Jerry Fisk is a super example - his skill level always increases over time and his engraving ALWAYS fits his knives.

But the last thing one wants to see on a maker's knife is mediocrity in the maker's engraving. It can ruin the knife.

Best,

Bob

EDIT: As I thought more about this, I realized it takes an even MORE exceptional eye to be able to mate the right engraving with damascus patterns. That has got to be an artform in itself. Back to Jerry - he sure has that one down!

Josh - this knife is a beauty. And the engraving reminds me of a familiar pattern that Buster used alot in the early days. I think Julie said it was one of the first things he taught her to engrave. Always loved that pattern.
 
Last edited:
According to Spark you had to buy some kind of membership to list knives or tell people a knife was for sale on your website.

Did that change?

Kevin, what is going on here?
 
Hey, Les, there's a couple more nits behind you......might as well pick them too, huh?;)

Paul
 
HI Paul,

Not a "nit". This directly from a PM from Spark:

I'll deal with (name removed) and the others who are reported, and you can help by pointing out where these people are getting over on honest folks like yourself. You concern yourself with being in compliance. Together it'll get done. I have no interest in letting anyone slide.
Click to expand...

Note...I am also a Gold Member.

I cannot sell knives even in the for sale forum

from that same email:

but if you don't get with the program your access will be restricted. As it is, you are not allowed to mention your site or your business on this site with this membership level.
Click to expand...

He was referring to have a "dealer" level membership.

So as you can see Paul, it is not a "nit".

Josh is clearly in violation of the rules of this forum (as pointed out by Spark).

So instead of telling me I am picking a nit. How about explaining to me how it is ok for Josh to post up a photo and say it is for sale....and no one else is supposed to do that.

It is admirable that you are coming to the rescue of your friend. But next time you want to take a shot at me....you should know what you are talking about.

As in this case....according to Spark....you do not.
 
"Hi", Les

If you think you are going to drag me into a long drawn out s**t slinging contest with you, you are dead wrong.

I am just as aware of the new rules as you are. What I'm not aware of yet is just how to go about switching my Platinum to knifemaker, etc, etc. the cost is the same so I'm paid up for a little over a year yet.

Having explained that, I don't think it's my job to attempt to call out a fellow member on a public forum over something like that. If you really feel like you are doing Spark a tremendous favor then why not contact Josh via PM or email.

Now if you really want the last word, take it to email PM or phone. All My contact information is listed below....very easy to find.

Paul
 
HI Paul,

Spark specifically asked me to point out those who violate the rules (re read my post).

I wasn't talking about your membership.

I was referring to Josh's Gold Membership (Same as mine). Which means according to spark that neither he (as a maker) nor I (as a dealer) have enough privileges to openly promote/sell our business's.

Not a shit slinging contest. But apparently you are not as familiar with the rules as you would like to think.

If I am wrong and I (and you) are free to promote our business, website and post items for sale on this forum. With out the correct level of membership. Im sure Spark will correct me.
 
Hi guys. Thanks so much for all the compliments. I really appreciate it. I had a hard time deciding whether I should call it a "Small Bowie" or "Fancy Hunter". The size made it hard for me to decide. What do you think?

To answer a couple questions... the frame is mild steel and treated it with a rust brown solution. It is very similar to gun bluing. Just a different chemical.

Kevin, I have debated on doing my own engraving. At this time I think there are too many other challenges I'd like to pursue in knives that will make me a better maker. Instead I think for the time being I will use pros. I am going to be calling Brian Hochstrat soon to do a really cool bowie. In the past Steve Dunn has done some great work for me. Since I'm only 29 I guess I have some time to take on the engraving later.

Les, I was really just trying to display a photo of the knife and wasn't trying to break any rules. Didn't know of the rule to be honest. In the end the knife sold last night after I sent and email to my client list. I'm glad you're keeping a close eye on me. Makes me chuckle!

Thanks guys.
 
Josh,

Spark asked me to point out those who were violating the rules.

Im sure you knew that you can't post a picture and then tell people to go to your website where it is forsale.

The fact that this is not a "For Sale" forum should have been your clue.

Remember, Ignorance of the law (or rule in this case) is no excuse.

To be honest a fellow forumite pointed it out to me.

So this thread has become a teaching point.

That lesson being...this is not a for sale forum...it is the custom knife forum.

I just realized why Paul jumped to your defense...he made the sheath.

And Paul said he knew the rules. So I guess he should have let you know you were violating Spark's rules.
 
I just realized Kevin was not the one with the question about engraving but it was you Marcel. Sorry about that.

Thanks again to you all.
 
Cool knife. I particularly like how the handle looks. And the blade is real nice. I personally am not as into the guard, but love love everything else.
 
All your work blows me away, Josh !
A totally awesome Hunter/Sheath package.

Doug
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top