New Jersey Governor Christie Vetoes Two Draconian Bills!

Critter

Platinum Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2003
Messages
1,787
[Post in General approved by Spark]

Two draconian bills that would have dramatically harmed knifemakers and knife owners were vetoed by New Jersey Governor Chris Christie on January 19. The two closely related bills, S3146/A3773 and S3416/A4808, would have outlawed, with extraordinarily tough civil and felony criminal penalties, mere possession or transportation via New Jersey of parts or products from over 1,200 species of threatened and endangered species. Elephant, stingray, gator, mollusks (mother of pearl) and many other species whose parts have traditionally been used by knifemakers would have been included, putting makers and collectors in legal jeopardy. Knife Rights worked tirelessly for months to lead the opposition to these bills with our good friends at the Elephant Protection Association and with support from a number of hunting organizations.

While testimony and position papers were provided at legislative hearings, resulting in the bills being amended down from over 12,000 species to 1,200 species (as reported late last year), there was never any question that these still appalling bills would pass the Democratic controlled New Jersey legislature where freedom and common sense go to die. Our only hope for defeating these bills was that Governor Christie would recognize them for the terrible bills they were, both for New Jersey and its citizens, and for the country as a whole. Our legislative lobbying efforts set the stage for Governor Christie's veto, with most Republican legislators voting "no" or abstaining.

Knife Rights is also grateful to numerous friends and organization leaders from around the country who participated in the effort to defeat these outrageous and draconian measures. As a result of the team effort, New Jersey will not become the poster child for the nation's most radical anti-hunting advocates who would have dealt a serious blow to law-abiding knifemakers and knife owners as collateral damage.

Click here to read our position papers opposing S3146/A3773 and S3416/A4808.
 
S3146/A3773 is definitely overreaching with the provision "any species proposed for endangered list", but calling an anti endangered species bill draconian is a big leap. The two options for saving endangered species are a full paramilitary force patrolling african grasslands and the ocean or disincentivizing possession and trade in ivory/ray skin/etc. It needs a smaller scope, but it is necessary.
 
I WOULD call a law draconian if it AUTOMATICALLY made a lawbreaker out of a person simply for POSSESSING A LEGAL PRODUCT. Omit knives from the scenario.

IF I were to live in NJ (SBCIH) then had this law been signed, I would automatically be a lawbreaker simply because my piano, made nearly 100 years ago and was inherited from my grandmother, happens to have a ivory keys. And to make a lawbreaker out of someone simply passing through NJ while enroute to some place else while moving? What would be next? Where are your papers and travel permits? Would a moving van need to have a fully documented inspection form "gestamped" as correct for the legal transportation of my household goods through the "Democratic Republic of New Jersey" by the NJ State Possession Police?

Yes, I agree that threatened and endangered species represent a huge environmental problem BUT bad legislation in a good cause is still bad legislation. And no law in the US is going to have a single iota of effect on what some poacher does in Africa. From what I have read in real studies, not emotional puff pieces, is that almost all current illegal ivory is going to east Asian countries such as China, Viet Nam, Thailand and Cambodia.
 
I'm not saying that we don't need to protect and respect our flora and fauna but 12k animal species is ridiculous. 1200 is marginally better.

Let's recognize this legislation for what it really was intended to be: an anti-hunting bill. The people who drafted it could give two you-know-whats about endangered species.

Make killing the animals illegal, then the tool that kills them is targeted and so on. The knives used for processing them become moot because material needed to make them is no longer available. Such is the anti American democrat/liberal mentality.

That's all this was. Kudos to Gov. Christie for seeing this for sham it is.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top