Recommendation? New knife for my kids daycare teacher...

Joined
Jul 27, 2015
Messages
4,666
Yup. that's right. One of the teachers at my kid's daycare carries a knife daily, as she is only part time in the classroom and the other half of the day, she is doing food prep in the kitchen. She's not cutting up the actual food (they have a full time cook for that) but she is opening crates and boxes, shrink wrap, cans and such.

She and i have discussed it before, because I NEVER see her without a knife clipped into her pocket. I finally got a look at her knife today. It's an old beat up worn out turd. Looks to me like maybe an old Ozark Trail, though it has no markings on the blade.
It's a slim flipper with thumb studs and a liner lock. The lock slides all the way over, and the blade has terrible rock side to side and up/down. She says she wants a new knife. She's good to my kids, so I told her it would be my gift. She's not a "knife knut." To her it's a tool. And it will be used, and used in relatively light duty work but with enough frequency that it will get serious wear. Probably as her only knife until it dies and is replaced. I'm thinking though that with a better quality knife, it'll hold up much longer than the one sue uses now.

Realistically, here's what I'd like to go for:
Price- $20-30ish.
Size- nothing huge.
Appearance- Not a huge concern.
Blade shape/grind- thin enough to cut cardboard well, since thats a big part of thing knife's job. I'm thinking a robust tip will help since she may be prying a little but i don't know for sure how she uses the knife tip.
Steel- Something that can hold up to real use in an EDC. Will not be babied.
Lock- She's comfortable with frame locks and liner locks. I havent discussed other locks with her, but since her's is a liner lock, she's good with that, and when she checked out my ZT0450 today, the frame lock came as second nature to her.
Opening- Knife has to be one hand open/close. Thumb studs, flipper, or sypdie hole would all be fine.


My top contenders at the moment are:
Ruike P801
Ontario Rat2
Kershaw Link

Alternatively, I have a Spyderco Tenacious that I could gift her that has seen very little use and would likely fit this role very well and survive with that kind of use for years if not decades.

Thoughts?
 
Yup. that's right. One of the teachers at my kid's daycare carries a knife daily, as she is only part time in the classroom and the other half of the day, she is doing food prep in the kitchen. She's not cutting up the actual food (they have a full time cook for that) but she is opening crates and boxes, shrink wrap, cans and such.

She and i have discussed it before, because I NEVER see her without a knife clipped into her pocket. I finally got a look at her knife today. It's an old beat up worn out turd. Looks to me like maybe an old Ozark Trail, though it has no markings on the blade.
It's a slim flipper with thumb studs and a liner lock. The lock slides all the way over, and the blade has terrible rock side to side and up/down. She says she wants a new knife. She's good to my kids, so I told her it would be my gift. She's not a "knife knut." To her it's a tool. And it will be used, and used in relatively light duty work but with enough frequency that it will get serious wear. Probably as her only knife until it dies and is replaced. I'm thinking though that with a better quality knife, it'll hold up much longer than the one sue uses now.

Realistically, here's what I'd like to go for:
Price- $20-30ish.
Size- nothing huge.
Appearance- Not a huge concern.
Blade shape/grind- thin enough to cut cardboard well, since thats a big part of thing knife's job. I'm thinking a robust tip will help since she may be prying a little but i don't know for sure how she uses the knife tip.
Steel- Something that can hold up to real use in an EDC. Will not be babied.
Lock- She's comfortable with frame locks and liner locks. I havent discussed other locks with her, but since her's is a liner lock, she's good with that, and when she checked out my ZT0450 today, the frame lock came as second nature to her.
Opening- Knife has to be one hand open/close. Thumb studs, flipper, or sypdie hole would all be fine.


My top contenders at the moment are:
Ruike P801
Ontario Rat2
Kershaw Link

Alternatively, I have a Spyderco Tenacious that I could gift her that has seen very little use and would likely fit this role very well and survive with that kind of use for years if not decades.

Thoughts?

1/2 way thru your post I had already thought either link or dividend
I like them both
image.jpg
 
Why not a fixed blade? Does it have to be attached to her all day? I am thinking a Mora, or Buck.
 
A fixed blade may be overkill. I'm in line with the ones above me, Tenacious. Liner lock, quality is still really high, and I'm sure I'm not the only one who's abused their Tenacious(mines still ticking along just fine). It's as solid as any of my other Spyderco's.

Bonus - It's already in your possession! And she may even be more thankful that you're willing to part with one of your own knives on her behalf. That's a true gift.
 
If it is not limited to modern locked folders, I can't think of anything better than a simple SAK, which is also the most people-friendly and appropriate choice given the environment (daycare). Otherwise, some kind of Kershaw or Ontario Rat 2. Definitely want to keep the length of the blade to be short.
 
My first thought was a SAK, maybe the Recruit or Tinker.
For scissors, (which in that environment will come in quite handy) a Huntsman or whatever model it is just below the Huntsman that has the scissors but no saw.
 
I think for 20-30 bucks you can't really get a decent steel IMO.
I don't like the 14c28n, crmov types especially if you're not into sharpening, which it would seem she probably isn't.
OP you might need to up the budget to 40- 50 for the Rat II in d2 like others have said or a steel will cutjack.
Spyderco chicago or ladybug come to mind.
 
Just give her your 0450

Oh you... you funny guy you...
She's good people, but I ain't THAT generous!

My first thought was a SAK, maybe the Recruit or Tinker.
For scissors, (which in that environment will come in quite handy) a Huntsman or whatever model it is just below the Huntsman that has the scissors but no saw.

Nope. I agree that they are super handy and I am NEVER without a SAK (today it's the 0450 and Vic Pioneer combo in my pocket), but she wants OHO/OHC.


No fixed blade. I think she is most comfortable with a pocket clip modern folder with liner or frame lock... It's what she's used to and I'm not one to tell her otherwise. It's a gift for her so i want to go with what she wants. Otherwise I'd think something like a Spyderco Byrd Meadowlark in G10 would be a very nice option. But it's a backlock so that kills that idea.

OK I think I'm going to clean up my Tenacious (no real wear on it, just adhesive from cutting packing tape) and put one hell of an edge on it and give it to her tomorrow. It'll go a long way.
 
Oh you... you funny guy you...
She's good people, but I ain't THAT generous!



Nope. I agree that they are super handy and I am NEVER without a SAK (today it's the 0450 and Vic Pioneer combo in my pocket), but she wants OHO/OHC.


No fixed blade. I think she is most comfortable with a pocket clip modern folder with liner or frame lock... It's what she's used to and I'm not one to tell her otherwise. It's a gift for her so i want to go with what she wants. Otherwise I'd think something like a Spyderco Byrd Meadowlark in G10 would be a very nice option. But it's a backlock so that kills that idea.

OK I think I'm going to clean up my Tenacious (no real wear on it, just adhesive from cutting packing tape) and put one hell of an edge on it and give it to her tomorrow. It'll go a long way.

Solid gift. It sounds like the tenacious will be a considerable upgrade!
 
FRom your choices: rat 2 d2 (dividend if she’s fine with spring assists)

More practical than cool: foldable box cutter (my vote for the gerber eab lite)

More cool than practical (for her): CRKT drifter

Happy medium (-ish): CRKT Squid/ Pilar
 
Personally, I don't think a quality knife last very long in heavy use unless you are diligent in sharpening it. If she sharpens her own knives, then the door swings open to possibilities. If not, you might as well go with a box cutter. They are work horses, blades are inexpensive, and easily replaced for someone who doesn't sharpen their knives.
 
Back
Top