Recommendation? New Knife Time

Mister Coffee said:
Agree. I get why anyone would want to own a Randall knife. They are beautiful, and they have history, and that's the sort of stuff that brings guys like us to forums like this. But I'm done with buying for the sake of collecting, and there are better knives to buy for the sake of using. The steel of the 1940s might be just dandy, but there have been developments in metallurgy since then. I don't rely on no 1940s car, and I don't need to rely on no 1940s steel (of some undisclosed kind). And, as for history, that's why I married my wife. She's got a ton of history. But let's not get into that.
Click to expand...
That's kind of where my feelings are with them. I've always seen them as such historical pieces that I just wanted to appreciate them and have a piece of knife history. Everything I have I use, but something about them just makes it seem harder to think of. But like I said that could change, who knows.
 
eveled said:
Ironically when I ordered my first, I could only justify the price by committing myself to use it.

Also like I said they go up every year, the wait is not going away, so even if you use a Randall you won’t lose money on it. I’ve sold a few and never lost a penny. I never charged more than the current list price.

I appreciate the compliment, I enjoy them and they are my only vise. I used to spend more in bars than I spend on my knives. The two Stag ones were presents for getting my 2 plumbing licenses so they are extra special to me.

I hope you take the plunge and order 1.

Best wishes Ed
Click to expand...
I really like the use shown on your blades. It makes them look even more beautiful in my opinion. You've definitely given me food for thought and I really do want to have a few of their knives so I may be putting a deposit down sooner than later. Don't worry about that! I really enjoyed seeing yours. And im glad to hear you picked up knives and got out of the bars (as much) lol glad to have you here Ed.
 
DMG said:
I sold my K2 years ago and haven’t been able to find another.

OP, if you don’t have a GB2 or Hogue Ritter, you should look at them.
Click to expand...
Aw shoot! I hope you find another one soon! I'm in the same boat with the Spyderco Southard. I sold one years ago and I've been dying to have one back lately. It's a sad thing trying to correct a mistake like that lol. I've never handled either of those, but I am a fan. I might check them out again here soon
 
  • Like
Reactions: DMG
RyanSean97 said:
I know I said I was kind of lost, but here is a list of knives that I have gone back to multiple times recently, some out of stock and some not:
(Folding)
-Spyderco Subvert (High Interest)
-Giantmouse Sonoma (Also High)
-Reate Tribute
-Kansept Knives Reverie
-Peña Knives Mula
-Berg Blades Iron Wolf
-ZT 0560/0561
-Spyderco Southard
-MBK Old Guard
-TRM Atom
-WE Knives Miscreant
-Spyderco Native Chief
-Spyderco Shaman
-Spyderco Amalgam
-Benchmade Crooked River

(Fixed)
-CPK DEK1
-Burnley Knives Huck
-White River Hunter
-White River Sendero
-Rainier Fastpak

Like I said these are just pieces that I've been oggling for whatever amount of time, no necessary trend or style in mind.
Click to expand...

I almost recommended the Giantmouse Sonoma too. FYI, Voxnae has promised a deep carry clip option as there are no 3rd party designs that will fit. A prototype was developed but sent back for changes. Voxnae messaged me (only because I asked) that it was still coming. That was about three or four weeks ago.
 
I have been on a similar search and have found that like everything else we are all different and have different needs/view etc. That being said I learned that while I really enjoy some of the nicer more expensive knives I really cant bring myself to really use them therefor I prefer having something I dont mind getting dirty. This has lead me on a search for a knife first and a tool second. If you find your self in the same boat I would consider taking a look at the DPX knives! Also a big fan of my little Dozier, its a great fixed blade that just needs to be used! Good luck on your search.
 
Mako109 said:
I almost recommended the Giantmouse Sonoma too. FYI, Voxnae has promised a deep carry clip option as there are no 3rd party designs that will fit. A prototype was developed but sent back for changes. Voxnae messaged me (only because I asked) that it was still coming. That was about three or four weeks ago.
Click to expand...
I love the design of that knife and it's super classy and clean looking to me. I can see that as a beautiful edc knife. It's just a little pricey, but at this point I'm kind of ignoring it. I've been hearing things about some kind of pocket clip being worked out and im excited to see that. It might be one I push towards soon.
 
4TheLoveofSteel said:
I have been on a similar search and have found that like everything else we are all different and have different needs/view etc. That being said I learned that while I really enjoy some of the nicer more expensive knives I really cant bring myself to really use them therefor I prefer having something I dont mind getting dirty. This has lead me on a search for a knife first and a tool second. If you find your self in the same boat I would consider taking a look at the DPX knives! Also a big fan of my little Dozier, its a great fixed blade that just needs to be used! Good luck on your search.
Click to expand...
It's a crazy thing right? I usually have so many that I want and can't choose for that reason. This time I can't choose because I don't know which one stands out more. I never thought I'd say that because honestly I don't even have that many pieces in my collection yet, it's still growing. DPX has come and gone in my mind for years. They seem like they can take a beating but their designs have never grabbed me. I'd use one if I had it but I'd have to look into them more to see if I get attracted to one.
 
Mister Coffee said:
Randall "full tang" or stick tang? You be the $440 judge.
Click to expand...

I have no skin in the game, randall is pretty open about their design, it is a stick tang, but fairly beefy nonetheless
construction9.jpg


having said that, my fixed edc is a full tang simple design in 14c28n, which I really really like as a low cost, tough, stainless steel
 
RyanSean97 said:
It's a crazy thing right? I usually have so many that I want and can't choose for that reason. This time I can't choose because I don't know which one stands out more. I never thought I'd say that because honestly I don't even have that many pieces in my collection yet, it's still growing. DPX has come and gone in my mind for years. They seem like they can take a beating but their designs have never grabbed me. I'd use one if I had it but I'd have to look into them more to see if I get attracted to one.
Click to expand...
Maybe one reason I like the DPX, the design is not my favorite either but I appreciate the function so it results in not carrying when I beat them up...in fact they start to look better:)
 
GB940Rookie said:
I believe everyone should try this. Spyderco Bradley 2.
0NSa3a0.jpg


For a fixed suggestion, look at the Bradford knives.
Click to expand...
I see a lot of people that have the GB in their collection and for some reason it has always seemed a little "plain" to me. Which is ironic given that I am a fan of traditional or simple knives as well lol I actually had no realization that it was in M4 this whole time which is super cool. I do enjoy the aesthetics of it, I may have to pick one of these guys up in the near future and make it a mainstay in the rotation.

I came very close to pulling the trigger on a Bradford Guardian 3 last night, but it just seemed too small for me. That might not be the case but to be safe I think I might go with the 4 instead. Do you or anyone else have experience with Bradford Knives? I know they are very loved and hold up to a lot of use with no issues so they are on my fixed blade list for sure.
 
hhmoore said:
I decided on a delica
View attachment 1553419
but, since you like bigger knives, you could get an endura or police as your starting point; and dress it up the way you want
Click to expand...
I like those scales! I actually started with an Endura many years ago and carried it exclusively everywhere, including work. It's got some serious love and wear on it now and I love it. I'd love to get one in a sprint run one day.
 
RyanSean97 said:
I see a lot of people that have the GB in their collection and for some reason it has always seemed a little "plain" to me. Which is ironic given that I am a fan of traditional or simple knives as well lol I actually had no realization that it was in M4 this whole time which is super cool. I do enjoy the aesthetics of it, I may have to pick one of these guys up in the near future and make it a mainstay in the rotation.

I came very close to pulling the trigger on a Bradford Guardian 3 last night, but it just seemed too small for me. That might not be the case but to be safe I think I might go with the 4 instead. Do you or anyone else have experience with Bradford Knives? I know they are very loved and hold up to a lot of use with no issues so they are on my fixed blade list for sure.
Click to expand...

Yes the M4 is a terrific steel and the blade shape of the GB2 is hard to beat.

I don’t own any Bradfords yet, but the 3 has been calling my name for some time now. I think it would make a great EDC blade. Also been looking at the White River Backpacker Pro for the same reason.
 
Mister Coffee said:
Randall "full tang" or stick tang? You be the $440 judge.
Click to expand...

Don’t forget Randall’s are forged not made by stock removal. It makes a difference. There is 1 picture of a broken Randall model 1 tang on the entire internet.

The Randall model 1 is a fighting knife. It is quick and lively. It’s hard to explain, but you can feel it when you pick it up.

If it had a full tang it would be more clunky IMHO.

To each his own, but the forged stick tang is an advantage not a liability.
 
GB940Rookie said:
Yes the M4 is a terrific steel and the blade shape of the GB2 is hard to beat.

I don’t own any Bradfords yet, but the 3 has been calling my name for some time now. I think it would make a great EDC blade. Also been looking at the White River Backpacker Pro for the same reason.
Click to expand...
I've heard amazing things about M4, and I do love the blade shape and handle design of the GB2.

I might end up getting a 3 and a 4 lol See which one I prefer. I own a White River Backpacker Pro and you should most definitely get one. It is an amazing little edc fixed blade for the money. I want to get one of thier custom Caper versions with the pinned handles one day. The design, materials, size, everything is in a perfect little package. My next knife from them is either going to be the Sendero or the Hunter model. Such great knives and their attention to detail is bar none.
 
eveled said:
Don’t forget Randall’s are forged not made by stock removal. It makes a difference. There is 1 picture of a broken Randall model 1 tang on the entire internet.

The Randall model 1 is a fighting knife. It is quick and lively. It’s hard to explain, but you can feel it when you pick it up.

If it had a full tang it would be more clunky IMHO.

To each his own, but the forged stick tang is an advantage not a liability.
Click to expand...
I know this wasn't directed towards me, but I have never doubted the structure and the durability of a Randall knife ever. In my mind they have always been made to the highest level of craftsmanship possible, and I would be happy to support them. I am currently deciding on possible model configurations now lol That is a challenge on its own.
 
Take your time it’s a big decision, but I believe you have an option to change your order once.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top