I have 3 and none of them came razor sharp. Decent, but not to my standard anyway. That said, none of them were rough, just not sharp enough for my taste. And like has been said, they sharpen up so easy, I really enjoy sharpening my Opinels. The carbon in particular, with a medium grit paper(I convex on a mouse pad and sand paper set up) you can watch the burr build up in a couple passes. They are just a joy to sharpen if you enjoy that type of thing.
So if they come a little less than perfect, I'm ok with it. Never had one come with a real rough edge but if it cleans up well and performs to expectations, I wouldn't have a problem with it personally.
If you expect a perfect edge out of the box or really good edge retention like the heavy hitters of the knife world, they may not be your cup o tea, but they are real nice cutters for the price and generally a real pleasant knife to carry and use. I try to remember the price point and worry about the overall use of the knife. I can forgive alot on delivery if the over all product does me right and an Opinel hasn't failed to yet. YMMV.
Syn