I like both knives very, very much. The bright steel is nice because it really shows off the texture and steel itself. It did not take long for it to start patinating itself, though. It has dulled slightly and is definitely not the plain steel anymore. It has a bit of surface oxidation that, in about 25 years, will probably look like my Seraph! ;-) Anyway, the full patina is really nice, too. Strangely enough, it has a distinct smell to it. It may be the Cordovan leather sheath, though. Anyway, the dark patina lightens a bit with use, and scratches in the blade will show as bare steel, just like if you scratched a piece of color anodized aluminum. LIttle rust spots sprout up fairly readily on the bright steel, although I'm seeing some on the Seraph that weren't there yesterday, too. The A-2 needs to be cared for with a lot of love, but the knives are great! If I was paying the price for one of these knives, I would go with the full patina. It has so much character! Of the two knives themselves,
I prefer the Scaetha, with the 3" handle and Wharncliffe blade. Whatever your choice is, I guarantee you'll be happy. Amazing how fast that thing rusted from a little sweat soaking into my pocket...must go and destroy rust now! Thanks for the compliments and feel free to ask more questions!
------------------
My Custom Kydex Sheath page
http://www.geocities.com/CollegePark/Lab/1298/knifehome.html
Palmer College of Chiropractic
On Two Wheels