New to traditional knives

Good to hear. I'm looking forward to getting mine..... and opening many cold beers with the leg knife.

You're welcome, here's another.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blade

Also, some of GEC's knives have names that associate with the use. For example the Weaver Jacks, are for cutting long thin material like cloth and use a hawkbill type blade for that. I thought they were just for pruning! :D


Whoa! That's a lot of information. Thank you for the links. I enjoyed that very much.
 
I'm going to offer something of a dissenting view here....

The most important thing is being happy when you pull your knife out to use it. That's the single criteria, really, imo.

I've grown leery of pretty much all technical justifications of any sort of equipment, from camping gear to ski gear to cycling gear to knives. IMO, 99% of discussions are technical arguments that we slather over and on top of personal preferences. If you like something, no matter why you like it, you can find some technical justification for it. Might as well just stick with, "It makes me happy."

I think we tend to justify our opinions.

What's important to me is whether I like it, and a lot of things go into that, appearance, size, blade profile, scales.

I will reiterated what others have said, buy a couple of inexpensive Rough Riders in different configurations and see what you like. Avoid purchasing a lot of knives early on as your tastes and perceived needs will change. I guarantee that!
 
I am a 1 blade man through and through. I really like the looks of a multibladed knife but it terms of function they aren't for me. I find those extra blades take away comfort of the handle and aren't functional enough to make up for that loss of function. Different shaped blades may excel at certain tasks but I fin I can make any blade shape work if I need it to. For me a good ol spear or clip point is enough to get me through the day.
 
I could not get that little imperial sharp. I tried, and tried. For some reason it doesn't want to get there? Back in the drawer it goes. Delica is back in my pocket.... For now.
 
I could not get that little imperial sharp. I tried, and tried. For some reason it doesn't want to get there? Back in the drawer it goes. Delica is back in my pocket.... For now.

If you're used to the steels of benchmade and spyderco.... USE LESS PRESSURE!!! ;)
Carbon steel in those old knives is quite soft by today standards, and with diamond hones you can fold over the edge again and again without noticing, I'll recommend you to use simple media to try sharpen them.
Mateo
 
Do we justify our opinions? Sure. I do really find that some of the descriptions of the purpose of each blade helps me understand how best to employ it.

Can I use a wharncliffe to skin a buck? Sure, but it would be harder work than it should be.
Can I use a clip to cut a tarp? Sure, but a hawkbill is a little more ergonomically suited for the job.
How about a sheep foot to poke a hole in some leather? I'm sure you can if you don't hurt yourself first.
 
If you're used to the steels of benchmade and spyderco.... USE LESS PRESSURE!!! ;)
Carbon steel in those old knives is quite soft by today standards, and with diamond hones you can fold over the edge again and again without noticing, I'll recommend you to use simple media to try sharpen them.
Mateo

Great advice here.
 
If you're used to the steels of benchmade and spyderco.... USE LESS PRESSURE!!! ;)
Carbon steel in those old knives is quite soft by today standards, and with diamond hones you can fold over the edge again and again without noticing, I'll recommend you to use simple media to try sharpen them.
Mateo

I'll give that a try. Thanks for the advice.
 
I wish I had a grandfather that could have taught me.

Great post and perfectly true. In the end, it all comes down to personal taste. I've often said that knives are like ice cream. You can walk into t a 31 flavor ice cream place and 10 people will order 10 different things. One guy may like plain old vanilla while the next guy gets mint chocolate chip. It's all in what you like. And what stage your life is in. I've carried everything from a Case peanut to a large Eye-Brand sodbuster, and liked them all at that time. All depended on what I was doing. For a very large chunk of my life I carried a three blade stickman almost 4 inches in closed length. Now I'm happy with a peanut or Opinel. And more and more, I've become interested in friction folders as an edc.

Do we need multiblade knives? No, not really. It all depends on where you grew up. Being a post WW2 kid, I grew up with men who all carried some sort of two blade jack. Somebody growing up in Wyoming cattle country may lean towards a stockman, while someone from Sardinia, Spain, or rural France, may go for a simple one blade friction folder. They all do the exact same thing for the owner; cut something that needs to be cut. A cowboy cutting something, and a shepherd on the arid hills of Northern Spain, all use a knife for the same thing.

Personal preference, individual taste, all makes us who we are, and what we like. One blade, two blades, three, all the same. Myself, I have a hard time choosing between chocoalte chip and rocky road. :D

Carl.

I should point out that there's already a queue to adopt Carl! ;) :D

Welcome to The Porch! :)
 
I am a 1 blade man through and through. I really like the looks of a multibladed knife but it terms of function they aren't for me. I find those extra blades take away comfort of the handle and aren't functional enough to make up for that loss of function. Different shaped blades may excel at certain tasks but I fin I can make any blade shape work if I need it to. For me a good ol spear or clip point is enough to get me through the day.

That pretty much describes my preferences too. On top of that I like my knives to be low profile, in the sense that they can fit in my pocket without bulging or being noticable, and I like them simple and tough. Douk-Douks are my solution to that, but as mentioned above, it all comes down to your personal taste and needs.
 
2013-03-16_21-35-21_860.jpg


This is what I've got some far. That delica is sweet when I need a quick cut and put away. When I can take a second to think about what I want to use I'll dig on pocket and pull out my case. So far so good:D
 
Back
Top