New to traditionals

I started out with 2nd hand Buck slipjoints and lockbacks (the 505 still might be my FAVORITE sub 3" "change pocket knife")

I have about a dozen Rough Riders. The older ones are kind of hit and miss, but of the 3 newer productions, my Splitback whittler is solid, and the f/f, walk & talk, and sharpness from factory in my razor trapper and small cotton sampler rival many of the Cases I own.

I love my Cases too. Only wish they would bring back some of there older patterns and offer more options in CV.

I just started getting into GECs I'm the past month or so. They have a cult like following, so I'm probably going to get crucified for criticizing them. I own 5 so far, and 2 of them are AMAZING... The other 3 are still really good knives, but for the price they command, I expected more. Granted one was a factory 2nd, but all 3 have jigged bone covers that are chipped somewhere and catch in my pocket. 2 Of them have relatively weak backsprings, by GEC standards that is. And all 3 seemed to be so tight at the bolsters that they catch and chafe the tang some point in its travel, particularly right before returning to the closed position. Don't get me wrong, they are all 3 perfectly functional and fine usersb but for 2x+ the price of a Case, I expect noticeably better f/f than a Case. It could just be my luck that I have 3 not exceptional specimens though.
 
I started out with 2nd hand Buck slipjoints and lockbacks (the 505 still might be my FAVORITE sub 3" "change pocket knife")

The 505 is my favorite "change pocket knife" as well. I'm glad you mentioned Buck in this thread.
 
I sorta ended up here looking for that one knife and have acquired.....well, don’t ask:rolleyes: There are a lot of good people here with some amazing knives, experience and advice. Not sure where you live but if you locate a decent sized knife show that would be a great place to start. To me a knife is like a car, I may like the looks but really can’t say for sure until I can get my hands on it and use it a bit.

Good luck and welcome!
 
I always ,usually,tell'em to figure out if you have fingernails or not. Most all slipjoints have nail nicks of some type. If you do not have fingernails you can't really use them.
So then you may want to find a style of knife that is " pinchable" ( you're able to pinch/grasp ) blade and get it open.
The knife won't be much good to you,if you can't get it open.

If you have good strong fingernails you have more choices in the slipjoint world.
 
The internet is your friend. Just start browsing, and then search when you have a question. Just turn your mind loose and discover.

I have to smile at the younger set. I go back to when today's traditional was your common knife. Nothing wrong with the other knives today, whatever works for you, or appeals to you. But I have to smile because I've been enjoying the traditional for many years and they still appeal to me.
 
Welcome. Please take your time, read, cogitate. If you don't, you'll end up with stashes of un-carried blades like most of us.
 
Welcome to the Porch. I'm one of the newer guys here, because I've only just discovered Blade Forums (And the internet:)) in the last few years. I think you'll find everyone around here very helpful. Browse the threads & you'll find a lot of information. Pretty soon you'll have a "must have" list. I think you'll also find that we here on the porch are always happy to help you spend your money.
 
Besides the slipjoints, there are some nice traditional fixed blade pocket knives, such as this little Bark River Bravo Micro. It's only around 4¾" long and is designed for pocket carry.

bocote.jpg
 
I second that there still good old ones about. I'm going after the challenge this weekend! This is for sure an addicting hobby! Barley back into traditionals 3-4 months, and hoping to score a 100 year old knife. I've made the deal, going to meet this weekend, I really hope its as good as it looks! Fun hobby imho.
Edit:
2zjjlfo.jpg

The pattern I'm trying to get is identical to the 2cd from the left
 
Last edited:
I second that there still good old ones about. I'm going after the challenge this weekend! This is for sure an addicting hobby! Barley back into traditionals 3-4 months, and hoping to score a 100 year old knife. I've made the deal, going to meet this weekend, I really hope its as good as it looks! Fun hobby imho.
Edit:
2zjjlfo.jpg

The pattern I'm trying to get is identical to the 2cd from the left
Good luck! I hope that you get it, and it’s all that you hoped it would be. We’ll be looking forward to seeing some pics. -Lance
 
Cool thread with great info. I have been into traditional knives for less than a year but I still haven’t ventured beyond Buck and Case. Mainly due to availability, price and simplicity of patterns.

Honestly, the whole GEC/Northwoods/Northfield/Tidioute thing has always confused me. The great clarifying links and info posted in this thread may end up costing me mucho dinero. :eek:
 
Back
Top