Newbie to traditional

Joined
Oct 8, 2008
Messages
25
Hello everyone I want to buy a traditional folder and I want to use it for a long time. I am use to Spyderco and Benchmade but have grown tired of the tactical side of knives. What is considered the Benchmade of traditional knives. I want the best brand and what type would you recommended to edc and to hand down to my boy? Thanks guys.
 
Welcome :)

Traditional patterns run a wide range of sizes, blade designs, blade count for differeent needs. Its not as easy as just asking for the 'best' knife or 'best' brand out their. First we will need some details, for what you plan to use the knife for? Then we can assit you in narrowing it down given your specific needs and desires.
 
Last edited:
My budget is up to $100. I will use it as a EDC to replace my spyderco delica and Benchmade 710. Im thinking of a lock blade traditional but rather your opinion. And I need a good brand that will last a while.
 
I would be comfortable recomending a Queen gunstock as a starting knife.

I have had them in both amber bone and stag, and have been very happy with them.

40acsb.jpg
 
As far as lockblades. I favor the Case Copperlock at times and consider it to be a very stout knife. Though now discontinued they can still be had on ebay for a good price. There is also the Buck 112 or 110. Kershaw makes a gentleman's folder that is great for EDC. It comes with a pocket sheath, 3" blade, lockback, Micarta scales.

Here's some links to some that may interest you:
http://www.knivesplus.com/BU-112-Buck.HTML
http://www.knivesplus.com/queenknifeqn-3lacsb.html
http://www.knivesplus.com/kershawknifegentlemans-ke-19932.html
http://www.knivesplus.com/case-knife-copperlock-ca-790.html
 
Like you, I just got interested in traditional knives, after buying a slew of Spyderco, and Benchmade. I'm having a very nice time buying "Case" brand knives at the local hardware store. So far the "Trapper", and "Stockman" lines appeal most to me, and seem very useful. Trappers have longer blades, if you are an outdoorsman. Stockman seems a little more urban EDC, IMO. Carbon (CV) blades are a neat switch, and I prefer the "Amber Bone" scales.
 
I'm with you. I am getting a bit tired of tactical knives and I feel traditionals have more soul to them. I've had a Case CV amber bone medium stockman for a while now. It is a great EDC blade. Try out a carbon steel blade you will love it I'm sure!
 
My budget is up to $100. I will use it as a EDC to replace my spyderco delica and Benchmade 710. Im thinking of a lock blade traditional but rather your opinion. And I need a good brand that will last a while.

Good John, that gives us a baseline then.

You cant go wrong the a time tested Buck lockback. The 110 and the 112 might, or might not be a good choice, and if not, then take a look at their 500series of lockbacks like the 501 which runs about 3 3/4 inches closed.

Or here are a few..

000_1170.jpg


A Queen Copperlock

000_1168.jpg


A Case Copperlock

000_1126.jpg


Case Swinguard
 
Thanks for the replies. I have an interesting question. Do they make a traditional knife with a lock blade along with a standard slip blade if that makes sense? Do you like the D2 on that queen because i like the way that one looks?
 
If you are new to traditional knives this is the place to be these guys are awesome and you will learn alot. My slip joint collection doubled in a week. I started with a trapper and a sodbuster jr and now I am up to 4 and thats in the week I have been here, its great and these guys are a wealth of knowledge.
 
.. Do they make a traditional knife with a lock blade along with a standard slip blade if that makes sense?

What do you mean, standard slip blade?


Also, bear in mind that the Queen Gunstock w/D-2 Ed posted is not a locking folder.
 
...
Do you like the D2 on that queen because i like the way that one looks?

I, personally, am in love with Queen's D2 and just bought my son a Queen Canoe in that same Amber Carved Bone Stag and am awaiting a Cattle King for myself.

I've been carrying a Gunstock like the one Ed T showed except that mine is the older Carved Bone Stag (check the "What trad. knife..." thread for a bunch of pics of it) and I have been extremely happy with every aspect of this knife...

You can see a bunch of them here (note that some are 1095 while most are D2)... http://www.collectorknives.net/other.html#Queen
 
I started out just like you earlier this year. The turning point for me was when I bought my first Case Sodbuster... Then I was hooked. So simple, So functional! You can pick up a Stainless Steel Sodie at Lowes for around $17.00. Just a thought.... Have fun!!!
DSC03814.jpg
 
Welcome to traditional pocket knives, john.

You've picked a field that has almost unlimited possabilities for a great edc. The nice thing about a traditional, is that you may not have a locking blade, but you can pick a knife with two blades like a simple barlow, a three blade stockman, or even a four blade congress. A traditional pocket knife packs alot of versitility into a small pocket size package. Most have a history going back to days when a knife really was used more on a day to day basis than now, so they had to be totally functionable. Form following function. A lot of traditional pocket knives were designed for a particular trade. A frieght wagon driver or horse drawn cab driver may carry a harness jack, while a cowboy would of course be drawn to the cattle knife, then later the stockman. Then there's the sodbusters and single blade barlows of the farmer and laborer, the sunfish of the construction worker of old, and the electrictions knife and sailors knife for those occupations as well.

And then there's the peanut. But that's another story.

There's so many patterns that if you become bored with one, there's 20 others to choose from.

Before you make a purchase, find out if there are any knife collector clubs in your area. If you can lay your hands on a copy of Knife World, theres a club listing by state in the back. Collectors are wonderfull people willing to show you the different patterns, and at a knife show you can handle, feel, and look at your hearts content at them. This will give you some experiance in picking what knife you may find fits you best. Sometimes it's not the one you think. Sometimes you don't know till your hand wraps around it.

It may also depend on you usual mode of dress, (what kind of pants worn) and occupation or trade. White collar/blue collar. City dweller or rural farm.

Anyways, welcome to traditionals.
 
Same thing happened to me. I sold all but one Spyderco (large Manix) on eBay and switched to slipjoints about four years ago. Much happier with the handle and steel selection and fine folks on this site.

Great Eastern Cutlery is making some of the best production traditional knives available. They make mostly slipjoints and some linerlock models. All fall into the traditional category. Most of the bone models are in the $70 - $100 range.

http://www.greateasterncutlery.net/

Links to their vendors http://www.greateasterncutlery.net/links.html
 
ok well here is what i am thinking. you have a 100 dollar budget and want excellent quality. the first thing that jumps to my mind over both queen and GEC is Schatt & Morgan. Their F&F is outstanding and the knives are gorgeous ones that will last a looooooooong time. now i know its not a locking blade, but if your truly going traditional locks arent needed, the spring do just fine. their File & Wire set it the first that comes to mind for me, especially the English Jack - File & Wire #12.

http://www.cumberlandknifeworks.com...ategory_id=47&option=com_virtuemart&Itemid=28

this exemplifies traditional to its best IMO. more then one blade, great natural scales, blades that are thin enough to cut, yet still are longer like your tactical ones you own. and a great steel to use, even if its not carbon.

If you decided that you do want carbon steel blades, but more then one knife for your collection then i whole hartedly support and suggest like the others here that you take serious looks at the big 3; Queen, Case, and GEC. Good luck in finding your blade of choice and welcome to the fold:D
 
Back
Top