Only One Maker?

Joss, I'm going to reconsider. :foot:

I would go with Don Hanson as I love his folders and I could also throw one of those big crazy hamon, beautiful ivory handled fighters in from time to time.
 
Though I don't own a Fuegen knife, I do have one on order. I think Russ is an exceptional knifemaker, and believe that he will one day be one of the best, but I do not consider him at this point in his career to be as skilled as Larry Fuegen. This is not meant as an insult to Russ, as there are very few makers that I consider to be as good as Larry.
 
It would be nice to see more displays, one-maker focused, at Blade, for instance.

To me, this would be far more Interesting than seeing the Buck display for the 10th time.. but, it is a mystery to me how this sort of thing works, waiting for display tables, And why many of the same displays seem to be repeated yearly.. seems like a new variety of one-maker, custom displays might be a welcome change. I don't think there would be a shortage of collectors to show off primo stuff.
David


anyone have any thoughts about this?
David
 
To me, this would be far more Interesting than seeing the Buck display for the 10th time.. but, it is a mystery to me how this sort of thing works, waiting for display tables, And why many of the same displays seem to be repeated yearly.. seems like a new variety of one-maker, custom displays might be a welcome change. I don't think there would be a shortage of collectors to show off primo stuff.
David

anyone have any thoughts about this?
David

David, the CKCA is on a waiting list for a spot at the Blade Show and among other things we plan on showcasing collectors knives there. We also plan on kicking off a membership drive.
 
Buddy, I would have liked to have gotten that email. I have a guess is why I did not get it about that time. The sword that I was referring to at the time was going to have 2 pounds of gold and 1000 diamonds rubies and saffries on it all going toward a theme. I was going to work with a stone setter and art designer on that piece. The reason I removed it from the websiite was that once we got futher into it he at that time wanted to start slipping some CZ's in amongst the diamonds as he said, "mixed in with the diamonds they will never know." That concluded our work and friendship.

So, I am working on this newer different design without him and by myself except for the handle material. No knifemaker gets into the required handle material for this piece so I must go outside our normal boundries. I am shooting for publicity outside our normal venues to help make more people aware that we are out there. Its quite unique.

Kevin was right, my emails are still not able to send or recieve so if any of you are trying to contact me please be patient. If not fixed by next week I will be having a new email address with a new host.

Buddy, you have a good memory on you. Enjoyed our conversation at Reno and look forward to input from you down the road.
 
The maker I would choose for fix blade would be Mr Jerry Fisk. The folder maker I would choose would be Tony Bose. I know I can only choose one, so what ;)
 
Joss, I'm going to reconsider. :foot:

I would go with Don Hanson as I love his folders and I could also throw one of those big crazy hamon, beautiful ivory handled fighters in from time to time.

4 out of 5 doctors 1 dentist and 1 Chef Say "A Steady Diet Of Don leads to a longer healthier more vibrant and fulfilling Life" ;)
 
Yep Don's consistence, he does folders, autos, fixed-blades, longblades, working knives ALL equally well.
 
With 50K I would have to pick a maker that could do it ALL. From sword to tactical folder, as I would need some serious variety to stay interested. I don't know too many who could achieve that. Probably Bailey Bradshaw. Matt Diskin too I would imagine. I would try and get at least 20 pieces out of that wad o'cash too.
 
I think Riad is right on, Don H. is just what the doctor ordered.

2bladedoc04.jpg


A steady diet of Don's work over time helps keep my LDL's down, my HDL's up and my blood pressure steady. :D He would be my choice.


- Joe
 
Unfortunately for me, I have been largely unexposed to any of the top bladesmiths' work in person. However, I do tend to surf around a lot and look at pictures of knives, (which is really not good enough- sorry Coop:)). I've said it before and I'll say it again, I am a neophyte knife guy, with limited experience, who doesn't really know enough about knives. (Thanks, meager income:().

With all that being said, my choice would be Burt Foster. I can think of no other bladesmith who I'd part with that amount of cash with. He's such a nice guy and an honest man as well- principled. I think he would deserve such a sweet payday, a lot more than I would. In fact, I'd give him a 10% gratuity in this scenario:thumbup:

Basically, the decision for me would have to do with how much I like the guy I'm dealing with, as what kinds of sweet blades I would get out of the deal. However, any picture of a Foster blade always stops me in my tracks. So utilitarian and elemental in design are the tools he creates, they speak to me on almost a primordial level.

I already said I can't afford handmade knives, much less production ones, but I'm still saving up for my first Foster blade anyway, and after some communication back and forth with him, I whole heartedly am stoked on my choice to allow myself the indulgence of one of his fine blades.
 
With 50K I would have to pick a maker that could do it ALL. From sword to tactical folder, as I would need some serious variety to stay interested.

This is the same thing that came to my mind. Even if I am still interested in that maker's work after getting about a dozen of basically the same kind of knife, well, what if I have the desire to obtain a sword, and still have a pile of cash invested with a maker who doesn't do them? Etc. Heck, with that kind of funding, I'd probably want two of everything- one to use and a really fancy one to put away. So I'd want a guy with a huge range of skills, so I could get all my needs (and potential future needs/wants) covered.
 
4 out of 5 doctors 1 dentist and 1 Chef Say "A Steady Diet Of Don leads to a longer healthier more vibrant and fulfilling Life" ;)
With good health, good teeth and good food. I should be able to make more knives :eek:

Kevin, Joe, Riad, Thank you very much!!!
 
I would choose Michael Walker, concentrating on his Zipper folders, because they are my favorite knives that I can't afford otherwise.
 
I have a very unique twist on this. I'd invest all my money in Scott Ickes. Nobody knows me yet, but with that kind of money, I'd be able to devote myself to learning what I need to bring my level up to the point that collectors would recognize and want to own an "Ickes" knife. I'm a very stubborn person and when I want to learn how to do something well, I don't quit until I get it right.

For every knife that I made for myself, I'd invest some of the money in a new skill that will enhance my abilities in the future. The goal wouldn't be to make money or get rich, but to get better and better and better.

If I remember the rules correctly, this thread isn't about best maker or favorite maker. It's about whose knives you'd purchase.

I know....a really odd and weird take on this thread...but it is original. In addition, just think about the great price I'd get, since I'm setting the market price for my knives!!!

I'm not really a collector and only own one custom knife by a maker other than my own.

This one by Robert Mayo is the lone knife in my collection. Can you really call a one knife collection a collection?
 

Attachments

  • Robert Mayo 2.jpg
    Robert Mayo 2.jpg
    44.3 KB · Views: 7
I have a very unique twist on this. I'd invest all my money in Scott Ickes. Nobody knows me yet, but with that kind of money, I'd be able to devote myself to learning what I need to bring my level up to the point that collectors would recognize and want to own an "Ickes" knife. I'm a very stubborn person and when I want to learn how to do something well, I don't quit until I get it right.

For every knife that I made for myself, I'd invest some of the money in a new skill that will enhance my abilities in the future. The goal wouldn't be to make money or get rich, but to get better and better and better.

If I remember the rules correctly, this thread isn't about best maker or favorite maker. It's about whose knives you'd purchase.

I know....a really odd and weird take on this thread...but it is original. In addition, just think about the great price I'd get, since I'm setting the market price for my knives!!!

I'm not really a collector and only own one custom knife by a maker other than my own.

This one by Robert Mayo is the lone knife in my collection. Can you really call a one knife collection a collection?

I think you have a winning plan there Scott. :thumbup: ;)
 
Of course my choice is easy,

Don Hanson, nobody does both folders and forged bowies so well IMO.
 
I would choose Michael Walker, concentrating on his Zipper folders, because they are my favorite knives that I can't afford otherwise.

Ordering direct from Michael might be quite un-realistic..... Trying on the
after-market you might need an additional 10k to get two Zippers!!

All the best,
David Darom (ddd)
 
Ordering direct from Michael might be quite un-realistic..... Trying on the
after-market you might need an additional 10k to get two Zippers!!

All the best,
David Darom (ddd)

LOL, you are right, but I think someone mentioned earlier that for the purposes of this thread, availability would not be an issue. Though with the current aftermarket prices of Zippers, I'd probably have to settle for one Zipper and a couple of Bladelocks with the $50K. Still probably the direction I would go in as these are my favorite knives that I can't currently afford.
 
Back
Top