Soooooooo........I got the replacement from Ontario. I was excited when I opened the box - the sheath is a new style and is infinitely better than the original. That's where the excitement stopped however, as the blade geometry is actually worse than the original two knives I returned. The edge wanders and twists, which I'm sure has a functional impact in addition to making it nearly impossible to sharpen. Extremely disappointing considering I was under the impression that this blade would be carefully QC'd before going out to me since it was my third try at a knife free of glaring defects. I have emailed customer service to inform them and will post back here when I hear back. I really hope there is a happy ending to this saga.