Re: budo
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by DannyinJapan
Bujinkan Budo Taijutsu
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Looked it up on the web, looks like a cool system of Budo from different Ko-Ryus not one of those goofy mail-order ninja dudes
alf
__________________
Actually I think you should research a bit further.
Koryu is a very narrow community! And many of us know each other. Mr Hatsumi's credentials have been accepted by some and roundly rejected by others. You may be surprised at just who-considers-what "a goofy Ninja dude."
Anyway, this is not to discredit skills but just their origins. Mr. Hatsumi and Mr. Tanamura both claim to teach a myriad of Koryu (including supposed Ninja arts)through their orginizations (Bujinkan and Genbukan repsectively) Which in and of itself is highly controversial as the Japanese Koryu community does not recognize any school as a "Ninja" school. As such there is much debate and lack of recognition by many in the Koryu community.
Again, as I am sure this will fall on deaf ears.
_This has nothing to do with skill or lack thereof. Just origins._
Were you to venture out and bring these names up in casual converstaion during Koryu enbu-you may not get the response you expect.And were you to visit martial arts forums such E-budo and Swordforum as well as the few closed and private Koryu forums, their names have been a source of grand debate for years...Recommended research may begin there as you can read responses from Menkyo (not menky(u) Danny) Kaidens, and various inka holders from legitimate Koryu regarding this topic of the Bujinkan and Genbukan.
There are respectible men -and some good martial artists -in these organizations who get along with the detractors and can debate the topic without angst, anger, or ire. We're brothers in the disagreement due to...............sweat. In fact E-budo is owned by a Genbukan member who has himself participated in the grand Ninja Debate.
Anyway enough with the preamble, Congrats Danny on the study and time in. I would be a little more cautious about how or what you say-on the web -your choice or call though-not mine.
Here is an example. Most of those reading don't know squat about Koryu and are not involved- then....... surprises come from unknown areas! As in the arts- you just never know.
Would Hatsumi Sensei appreciate you calling him the "Finest martial artist in the world" in a public forum with other Koryu people reading it. Koryu people are usually much more circumspect about such things in public-even among the students of those who have sterling reputations and are considered by the Japanese Koryu community themselves to be among the best in the world-there is an understanding of who's who and most of these people prefer NOT being a strong presence on the internet.
Anyway I am sure you know of the controversy, but who cares-as I said sweat is sweat. Its what we can or cannot do with what we have been given.
cheers
Dan