I guess it depends most on where you're at and what you're doing. I too thought synthetics were the way to go. In some cases they may be better than natural fibers. Sometimes all you really need is an umbrella and bandana.
I remember reaching for a coffee pot and have the bail score a line across the fingers of my brand new Capilene gloves. Melted them I mean. Not to mention how quick and ember can go through an ultralight shell garment. That's my main concern, they melt too easily. Still, I have one.
I usually wear a wool vest. I've come to like the Filson's quite a bit. Their cotton surveyor's vest is nice when it's warmer. Also the guide sweater and whipcord pants. That old auction site is where I got most of this stuff. Good stuff I think. The only thing bad is if you hate that 1930's look, not ultralight.
For me gussetted crotch on
mountain khaki or similar pushes them way ahead of carhardt heavy duck. those are everyday kinda pants for me though, and carhadts just didnt seem to last as long as I expected. If its too warm and dry for wool pants I like nylon hiking pants(they all fit different, personally and having a vest, I like pants to just be pants without a lot of extra pockets) and I also use Icebreaker "everyday" socks; pretty much everyday. For me they outlast Smartwool .
My loyalty to Patagonia though, has served me well. After being prompted by the local backwoods shop guy, i returned a jacket that may have been 15 yr old for repair/credit/ see what they could do. Most of the damage likely occurred in the first few years; later I was still carrying it stuffed in my vehicle (still a good windbreaker) I think it was $105 new. They gave me one hundred dollar credit. seemed fair.
When the economy is good; There can be lots of this same kinda stuff "clothing stuff" at thrift stores. Consignment shops better especially when times are a bit leaner. You'll never know what you will find, huh? I always look for cashmere sweaters. I've found enough to use as undershirts all winter long. these are also great if you have kids. If you wash and dry one they get small. really lucky for whomever they may fit. Thick, extra warm and soft as any. so I get them as big as I can find and try to shrink to fit. I also get the right size as they are cheap enough and it is not so easy to get and keep one shrunk just right
