Picking your favorite

Joined
Oct 25, 2019
Messages
62
Like I posted before , I'm fairly new to the hobby . I go back and forth on what knife to carry and even in buying I might see a knife that interests me on looks or the action it has but I keep on going back to the same little knife , the Hogue A01 Microswitch , the only thing I changed was the pocket clip. I just received the Case Kickstart Mid - Hunter , also a nice pocket knife but to me it's to pretty to carry and beat the heck out of it with regular use . Is this hobby about buying knives to just look at.

I started out years ago using a Buck , great work knife , never babied it . Still looks in great shape , this Case knife just looks like a knife to look at , I'm afraid to scratch it up . Do you buy knives to collect and not use , or do you use all the knives you buy . Feeling guilty I guess .

Chris
 
Well there are certainly some higher-end knives that I think look really nice, I will always carry and use a knife I buy. I might not hard use all of them, but they all will see some sort of action.
 
I collect some knives, and have some pretty ones to look at, there are plenty of how people approach this hobby,
The hard users
The beat the crap out
The ones that normal EDC office
Collectors
Collectors/ Users
Buscrafters / Survival
But to me, I collect what I want from 70$ to 1500$ plus, I wish I could use mine more often, but office desk job no outdoor guy, its light EDC use, but I like all of them, as of now, my favorite is the Holt Specter, have another one in the mail so I can dedicate one to use (I normally buy two of a knife I really like), there really is no explanation why we do this, but I enjoy the heck out of it, some people cant see why some others have knives they dont use, the its a tool type, but to each his own.
 
Don't dishonor the knife by not using it.

I got myself a Camillus OVB Fisk Bowie knife back in the day. I thought the same as you, that it was just too pretty to scratch up.

Ran into Jerry Fisk himself one night in BFC Chat and told him I got one. I'll never forget what ol' @fisk said...

"They were built to work, Vel.... Go forth!"

Well, I'm happy to say that it is a joy to carry and use. And I think the knife is happier being used as well.
 
It kills me to just keep a knife put up in a box. I’ve pretty well pigeon holed myself into my favorite brand, Crk. If a knife is too pretty or nice for me to use I can’t keep it. I get the most enjoyment out of using them. Like others said I may not hard use every one of them but they’ll get some carry and action. Light duty things like opening things around the house or cutting up boxes around the house. Most of mine are used for my daily job and get worked pretty good. I completely understand people collecting higher end knives and keeping them put up as collector pieces or limited editions. Just for me personally I have to carry and use them. That’s my enjoyment. The first scratch still stings on every one of them tho
 
it's simple for me, tools are meant to be used... so use them, otherwise it's a waste

or, put another way, why spend big $ for high end steel & mats - then only look at it?
if you only wanted to look at it, the 3cr13 junk would do just as well hanging on a wall, and cost 1/10th the amount
 
This thread need more pics !

Spyderco K2
Work knife through thick and thin, I love this knife.
F9128CC8-8426-4CC0-BECA-CC182391E05C.jpeg
Spyderco Nirvana
Kind of my show knife. I really appreciate what all went in to designing and manufacturing this knife.
B59E28E1-DDDC-482D-87E3-EDB103EBAD3D.jpeg
Bose/Case Tribal Spear
Screams class IMO, and I love the way it makes me feel when I’m walking around with it in my pocket.
10A96D10-06DF-41C2-8BA9-D1A6C0D612BC.jpeg
Dan Graves Damascus Fighter
Beautiful knife that feels so Right in my hand.
AA39CADC-912B-43D8-8130-0F44D7035031.jpeg
Himalayan Imports Khukuri
It’s an absolute beast and I have so much respect for the company and their story.
A212714B-F5D3-4F5A-904E-082889281F76.jpeg
 
When all is said and done the Spyderco Military, Manix 2 and the Hinderer XM-18 (preferably Bowie). I use all my knives, but these are the three I don't want to be without. Everything else is cream on the cake.
 
I’m pushing 50 years old, stated for perspective.

Was a Boy Scout in the 70’s, owned a standard Boy Scout knife then but no longer have it. Bought a Buck 110 at Target back in the early 80’s (Twin Cities, Mn.). Carried that for a couple of years, but it’s gone, can’t remember why. I have 3 brothers, may have had something to do with that.

Through my teens and 20’s always carried a SAK (Victorinox). Didn’t discover “new” knives until my late 20’s. First knife not a SAK was a CRKT, didn’t know what Benchmade was and the CRKT was 1/2 the price, $50 vs. $100, I think the Benchmade was a Leopard model. Couldn’t justify the price. I wish I had bought it now, but that’s neither here nor there.

Hit my 30’s and discovered SOG, then ZT. Carried a ZT 0350 for a couple of years. Discovered Blade Forums around 2010 and was introduced to the great world of knives, outside of what I already knew. At that point, I had always carried a pocket knife, but hadn’t been yet introduced to how widespread the knife world/culture really was.

I tell you that to tell you this.....I bought and used knives, then bought and collected knives, and then over time, I discovered that the knives that I owned that I chose to keep but didn’t use (“safe queens”) I quickly lost interest in. I came to the conclusion that if I didn’t use it or was afraid to use it because it was too “valuable”, I didn’t bond with it or the personal value I had invested in that knife eventually decreased to the point that I either traded or sold them to further explore other knives.

At this point, my collection fluctuates between 5-10 folders. I carry and use them all. I have 2-3 that I don’t carry because I don’t love them but I’m too lazy to move them on, at least for the time being. The knives that I do have and use are by many, considered to be valuable. Curtiss F3 (M390-rare), Koenig Arius (204P-rare), Ritter Grip (M390, not rare but kind of valuable), early Hinderer XM-18’s and XM-24’s (20CV somewhat rare), Benchmade 710-1502 (I think that’s the number, Knifeworks M390, discontinued), etc. Point being, a small collection of knives that are worth a bit of money each, but I use them because I love them. They are tools that do the job that I need them to do and they do it very well. Each one means something to me for what they are, but the value to me is that they excel at their jobs and they serve me exceptionally well.

I guess what I am trying to say is that I have a moderately small collection, but I do not collect in the traditional sense. I maintain a small tool box of fine knives. And throughout my 40+ years of carrying knives, I have found that the most satisfaction that I get is from fine knives that serve me well and I can always depend on each one doing the job that needs to be done without question.
 
Knives are made to be used, in my mind. That doesn't mean thrashing them or not respecting some of them as lighter duty/occasional knives. However, every knife I buy gets used. The ones that dont get used are only regulated to such obscurity due to them just not fitting a role.

I've got a Svord that used today to literally dig the mud out of my boots before getting back into my truck. I used a Microtech Ultratech to open my lunch and a few boxes at work. I'm buying a CRK very soon, it will be my edc and used as such around the house and office.

Knives are tools. Enjoy them in their beautiful function.
 
I’m more an accumulator than a collector (not my term, but I like it!)

I have a couple of knives I reach to for heavy indiscriminate use, partly because they’re great for the task, partly because they’ve already been through the ringer.

I have a few that sit in their boxes in my safe. They’re not collectors pieces per se; I just haven’t gotten around to carrying them because there’s so many I like already in rotation.

The majority of my knives get carried and used for light to moderate EDC stuff. It brings me joy to have ‘em along whether or not they get used.

All that said, there’s one knife I always go back to. It picked it up early on in my addiction and since have acquired many other knives that are more expensive and maybe considered “better” or “nicer.”
I can’t really explain it, but I guess the knife is a good fit for me.

 
. Do you buy knives to collect and not use , or do you use all the knives you buy . Feeling guilty
I do not collect knives , every knife I buy I intend to use because it doesn't feel right for a quality knife meant to be used to just sit around.
They're meant to be used and It seems wrong not to.

This knife almost seemed too nice to use when I first got it, but I got over it and it's one of my most favorite slipjoints.
 
I agree guys , I don't have a large collection of pocket knives but I do rotate all for carry ,some days the knife doesn't get used and then I see my wife ordered something from Amazon , the odd thing is it makes me happy I can use my knife , go figure . Thanks for answering .

Chris
 
I’ve accumulated knives for almost 45 years and I could probably use a different knife every day without repeating.
I have about a dozen or more Buck 110’s with different scales. But usually only use several of them.
But I agree with others, you don’t bond with a knife until you use it. There’s times I’m away from home for more than a week and only take one knife with me. You really appreciate that one knife.
 
Personally I've only ever owned 4 maybe 5 knives that weren't used. They were gifts with sentimental value. I've bought several different knives over the years. Had always had around 30 to 40 knives but got sick a couple years ago and had to sell most of them. Haven't really built back up. I have have about 5 I carry right now. If I buy a knife,it gets used. Even ones I have bought to simply out in a display case end up in my pocket
 
Like I posted before , I'm fairly new to the hobby . I go back and forth on what knife to carry and even in buying I might see a knife that interests me on looks or the action it has but I keep on going back to the same little knife , the Hogue A01 Microswitch , the only thing I changed was the pocket clip. I just received the Case Kickstart Mid - Hunter , also a nice pocket knife but to me it's to pretty to carry and beat the heck out of it with regular use . Is this hobby about buying knives to just look at.

I started out years ago using a Buck , great work knife , never babied it . Still looks in great shape , this Case knife just looks like a knife to look at , I'm afraid to scratch it up . Do you buy knives to collect and not use , or do you use all the knives you buy . Feeling guilty I guess .

Chris

I don't think it has to boil down to "just to look at". I won't buy a knife I'm not willing to use. But, obviously, I don't use all of my knives. I have used them all but most get relegated to static display. See, once you really zero in on your ideal functional knives for each type of purpose (pocket EDC, kitchen, etc.) it is sort of sad. In a sense, your journey is over, or at least very focused. You've tried so many different things and really found what works for you and you realize you don't want or need anything else now. However, that's when, at least for me, the journey shifted to buying knives just to make me happy. I enjoy it. So it's about a lot more than just looking at them. It genuinely makes me happy when I decide on a new knife I want and then finally get it. Even if it is just a different version of a knife I already have, and especially if it is a different version of a knife I already love.

I have a slew of Case knives and yes they are beautiful to look at. But for me, the true beauty of Case knives, is you get a lot of looks but they are still reasonably priced so scratches and such are no biggy. Lots of folks will rail about Case and that's fine, but I love them.

I say set your journey on finding the knives that really work for you and tick those boxes. And not just in the pocket, but all of your needs. Try different things, push your boundaries some times and really experiment so you know for certain that you like what you like. For me there was a weeding down process that took years. I also always encourage people to venture into sharpening so they can maintain the items of their hobby and get the most out of them. Having a great knife is honestly not as satisfying for me, as having a knife that cuts great. :)

And after all that, you just buy things that make you happy. That's it. There needs to be no more justification than that. Life is short, have fun.

Oh yeah, a few obligatory pics...

hL0oJDq.jpg


kAiIBXd.jpg


yarIU8Q.jpg
 
Do you buy knives to collect and not use , or do you use all the knives you buy
There is a spectrum between those two extremes, and knife hobbyists land in varying spots along that spectrum. There are true collectors, who enjoy ownership and display but may only actually carry and use one or two knives. There are those who feel that every knife should be a user and they rotate through their entire collection, or perhaps at least carry every knife for a while before it gets put away and replaced by the next new knife.

Most people are somewhere in between, and carry a percentage of their collection on a regular basis. Some people may be completely opposed to the "safe queen" mentality and carry 100% of their collection regularly, but that would also imply a reasonably modest number of knives.

I fell into the "too pretty to be used" mind-set at one point, so I would end up buying another (similar) knife so I didn't mess up the first one. And so that "too pretty" knife sat (or still sits) unused in its box, and the replacement knife that maybe had a flaw or two became my daily companion.

It may be impossible to learn the lesson without going through the process, but looking back, considering that I maybe regularly carry and use about 5 pocket knives, that perhaps I should not have bought the other 150 or so along the way. :)
 
Personally, I cheat. If I like a knife, I buy two of them. One to carry and one as a back-up.
Right now I carry one of two Buck knives. The first one is a partially serrated manual folder, and the second is an automatic 112.
I like the first one because it has a pocket clip which I simply find handier. The automatic does not have a clip, and I carry it in one of Buck's leather snap sheaths. Wisconsin has permitted the legal carry for automatics for several years, but it still feels odd to carry one.
 
Back
Top