The thermal mass of steel is about three times that of aluminum, so it can "soak up" three times more heat for each degree it rises.
The heat conductivity of aluminum is about three times that of steel, so it can more three times more heat in a given time.
Simple heat transfer is a function of delta T (advantage steel) and coefficient of thermal conductivity (advantage aluminum)
Thick aluminum would give a fast quench and have more heat capacity and probably have a better curve - fast to get under the nose, then slower as the plates heat up during the martensite transformation.
For an air quench steel, even though steel is three times slower than aluminum, it is orders of magnitude faster than air, so is it fine, especially if you're doing a bunch of blades and don't want excessive temperature rise of your plates.
For something like 154CM, the faster speed of aluminum would be a good idea.
I wonder if a good fit and copper plates would allow thin O1, 52100, 1084 and 5160 to plate quench?
Edit: Mike beat me to it. I write slow...