Wow, what a great forum. I didn't expect to come back to see so many replies. Thanks everyone!
So far the front-runners are the Shinola + Benchmade Custom 485 Valet and the Benchmade 690. Also looking seriously at the Boker Exskelibur II.
To answer a few other questions:
- I'm really set on having wood scales or inlays, unfortunately.
- I already have an Opinel. GREAT knives, especially for the price. Unfortunately they're a bit thick for pocket carry, don't have a pocket clip, and aren't easy to open with one hand. Still, I always keep one around.
- I've never really warmed up to the "leaf-like" blade shape of many Spydercos. I have a few, and despite being some of the best slicers I've ever used, they've never really grown on me. I'd grab a Sage 4 if I found it under $100, but otherwise I just don't care for the looks of it for some reason. It's an outstanding knife, though.
- I plan on getting a Small Sebenza with inlays at some point. The biggest problem for me is I'd be afraid to lose it or accidentally bring it somewhere and have it confiscated.