I've used this HID light tonight. I have a deer hanging up as high as possible in the woodshed and my 2 small dogs have been out in the field barking. A few wolves have recently been seen here and there is at least 1 cougar.
This supposedly 3500 lumen HID outshines the 1200 lumen LED in brightness and distance, but not by a huge amount.
It's about 350 yards across my field to the bush on the far side. The HID beam is fixed, cannot be focused, and by 350 yards it has such a wide spread that not much can be seen at this distance. For closer in, up to about 200 yards there is enough light to see whatever is there.
The "Monster" LED flashlight seems to be less powerful at full charge than when i first got it about 1 month ago. I'm not sure if this is real or imagined on my part.
The $225 HID light is a bit of a disappointment. It certainly is not 3x as powerful as the LED as specs would suggest (3500L. vs. 1200L.). That it came with zero paperwork, zero labelling and not even a bill of sale leads me to believe that i was sent a less powerful flashlight than i paid for. I would not deal with this Florida retailer again.
roland