Preventing kiln decarb with argon

If he is using low-alloy steel he doesn't need argon. Either live with the minor decarb (which will sand/grind away easily in finishing) or use a surface protectant like Turco, Brownell's, or satainite.
 
I'm not sure why I'm being told what I need or don't need - that part is non-negotiable. Stacy, your response echoes the response you gave me some years ago when I said I needed to develop a logo etching system capable of outputting 1 knife per 60 seconds. Instead of contributing toward a solution that satisfied the criteria, you suggested that I simply lower my expectations. I went on to develop a successful system. Advice that encourages the maker to lower expectations and abandon development efforts are a disservice to the craft - worse than no advice.

I need a heat-treating solution that gives me (a) a surface hardness within 2 points of the core hardness and (b) a surface finish that is free of pitting. I've tried ATP-641 and it was a failure on requirement A.

Foil works, obviously my initial interest in argon was based on the apparently incorrect assumption that it would be cheaper/easier than foil (taking into account the time it takes to fabricate the foil pouches).
 
You need a vacuum furnace. And you need to stop asking questions in a forum where everyone is an idiot but you.

When you ask for advice and everyone gives you their best shot, maybe don't throw it all back in their faces.
 
Back
Top