Protech is a stand up company, they fiixed it

Joined
Jul 5, 2021
Messages
3
I received a Protech TR-4.5 the other day in the factory bag, filled with metal shavings. Looking closer I saw that in the button/lock area is covered with many round, unfinished machine marks that look like the same size as the button. I also asked if it was normal for the lanyard area to be so sharp. I went to the local Protech dealer where I was told by all four employees that the visible tool marks (no special light needed) are not normal and they offered to send it back for me free of charge. Derek Lawrence of Protech responded to me with this email:

Hello Steve, so on the TR-4 there are some very fine marks that may only be visible when the knife is held in a certain light\angle. They are extremely fine machining marks, and because they are in the recess, there isn't too much we can do to remove them. We have that area of the knife blasted heavily to lessen the effect of them, but there's no finishing tool that will fit into the tight recess to totally finish that area of the knife.
On the steel pommel, those are hardened, finished, then surface ground. So the edges on it may be crisp, but they're also 90 degrees in angle. So they're safe and not thin enough to cut or damage anything. We have versions of the TR-4 and TR-5 that we ship with lanyards, and we've never had one damaged by these edges on the pommel.

-Derek Lawrence-
Customer Service & Social Media Manager Extraordinaire

This is a $500 knife, and I expected more. So your telling me that you don’t have the tools to finish your own knife? Any thoughts? I will include a picture when I figure out how. Steve
 
So why would you not let the "dealer" send it in on your behalf? Instead you decided to start an email fight with the company?

Attaching pics is about as hard as signing up.

 
I'd be interested in seeing pictures too. Why didn't you send it back like the dealer offered?
 
I did have the dealer send it in
So why would you not let the "dealer" send it in on your behalf? Instead you decided to start an email fight with the company?

Attaching pics is about as hard as signing up.

i did have the dealer send it in, nothing but negativity from you
So why would you not let the "dealer" send it in on your behalf? Instead you decided to start an email fight with the company?

Attaching pics is about as hard as signing up.

 
Sorry to hear you got a lemon so to speak Steve.

I'm guessing you didn't buy it from the local dealer or else you would have had a chance to examine it. May I ask where you bought it? It is possible it is a fake? Did you send pics to the CS Protech folks?

What you describe, shavings and unfinished machining are common in fakes/clones.
 
nothing but negativity from you
Irony

I'd really like to see some detailed pictures of what you've described here. The dozen's of Protech's I've owned/still own over the years, I've never seen nothing but excellence, from Protech.

Even with pictures, the fact that you joined BF's (literally today), just to start a "poor quality' thread, against an otherwise highly reputable, stellar company, speaks volumes.
 
I’ve owned a few Protechs. I actually had an issue with my new SNG. It had side to side blade play, button would not reset after deploying. I ended up stripping the pivot screw trying to fixed the blade play.

I sent it to Protech and it was fixed for free, no questions asked. I have the utmost confidence in this company.
 
Last edited:
Irony

I'd really like to see some detailed pictures of what you've described here. The dozen's of Protech's I've owned/still own over the years, I've never seen nothing but excellence, from Protech.

Even with pictures, the fact that you joined BF's (literally today), just to start a "poor quality' thread, against an otherwise highly reputable, stellar company, speaks volumes.

It speaks volumes!
 
I had a problem with with stripped screws on a Malibu. Had a very contentious series of emails with Protech and they finally sent me a replacement. Then the pivot screw broke. I sourced it myself. So how about taking it easier on a new member. More than likely his complaint is legit. He did not intend to hurt any old timers feelings, he just stated his case. No need to dog pile on him just because he doesn’t have a lot of posts or has a problem with one of the anointed brands. It happens.
 
I received a Protech TR-4.5 the other day in the factory bag, filled with metal shavings. Looking closer I saw that in the button/lock area is covered with many round, unfinished machine marks that look like the same size as the button. I also asked if it was normal for the lanyard area to be so sharp. I went to the local Protech dealer where I was told by all four employees that the visible tool marks (no special light needed) are not normal and they offered to send it back for me free of charge. Derek Lawrence of Protech responded to me with this email:

Hello Steve, so on the TR-4 there are some very fine marks that may only be visible when the knife is held in a certain light\angle. They are extremely fine machining marks, and because they are in the recess, there isn't too much we can do to remove them. We have that area of the knife blasted heavily to lessen the effect of them, but there's no finishing tool that will fit into the tight recess to totally finish that area of the knife.
On the steel pommel, those are hardened, finished, then surface ground. So the edges on it may be crisp, but they're also 90 degrees in angle. So they're safe and not thin enough to cut or damage anything. We have versions of the TR-4 and TR-5 that we ship with lanyards, and we've never had one damaged by these edges on the pommel.

-Derek Lawrence-
Customer Service & Social Media Manager Extraordinaire

This is a $500 knife, and I expected more. So your telling me that you don’t have the tools to finish your own knife? Any thoughts? I will include a picture when I figure out how. Steve
Not good PR to a guy who’s just become interested in your knives Derek! Extraordinaire indeed.
 
I had a problem with with stripped screws on a Malibu. Had a very contentious series of emails with Protech and they finally sent me a replacement. Then the pivot screw broke. I sourced it myself. So how about taking it easier on a new member. More than likely his complaint is legit. He did not intend to hurt any old timers feelings, he just stated his case. No need to dog pile on him just because he doesn’t have a lot of posts or has a problem with one of the anointed brands. It happens.
Not good PR to a guy who’s just become interested in your knives Derek! Extraordinaire indeed.

Meh…. They’re a good company with great customer service, I’ve used their warranty service more than once. This whole “unfinished” area of the knife sounds more like hearsay than fact. And a sharp lanyard hole? Give me a break:rolleyes:

Derek knows his way around these knives, so I have nothing but doubt about what’s being hyped up in here.
 
Are they still following that stupid policy of using two different size torx AND hex heads for body and pivot fasteners?
 
Back
Top