It may be softer steel, but I really like my saks, they hold and edge for quite awhile in my opinion, especially on wood etc. And they don't take much work at all to get sharp again, a couple passes on a fine ceramic rod or loaded stop and they shave again! I've carved a lot with them and made tons of fuzz sticks, cleaned fish and game with them, cut up piles of cardboard, and I like that if U do something stupid with them, (over torq a screw driver, baton a little to carelessly, yea Ive batoned a sak lol!) The steel will generally flex or bend before it snaps. No its not a super steel, but It works for me, I don't mind 5 minutes every week or two to sharpen them!