I went to a rabbitstick workshop at the Schiele Museum of Natural History in Gastonia, North Carolina today, made a few, brought a couple, and tried them out.
The two that look like billets are Catawba (a South Carolin tribe) style rabbitsticks, carved out of green hickory. The weight of the heavy end gives it a good spin and a hard whallop on the strike. The same goes for the one that looks like a shillelagh. It's a Rappahannock (a Virginia tribe) style rabbitstick, this one made of water oak sapling. The knob end is the root bulb. The long bladed one is an older, generic one I made from a piece of lighting-killed white oak. The little crooked one is a bit of deadfall oak that I carved out for a child some time back.
After we made our sticks, we went to try them out on stationary (a five-gallon bucket) and moving (a soccer ball) targets.
We were pathetic.
Before most of us got to the field, a guy who had gone on ahead of us flushed a rabbit crom a copse. It ran by more than a dozen guys, each carrying multiple rabbitsticks. That was the safest rabbit in the world. Not one person tried a throw (my excuse is that the group was between me and the rabbit).
We started the ball rolling and it got whacked once or twice, but most people were missing it, including me. One guy who was consistently pretty good was a NCDOA entomologist who is registered at ZS as Joezilla.
My blade rabbitstick was a piece of crap. because I haven't shaved it down thin enough to be aerodynamic, it flutters to the target ineffectually. The child's stick isn't worth more than giving a kid some throwing practice. The two Catawba ones really sailed, and the bee guy had pretty good luck with his, but I had trouble controlling mine.
I did have sucess hitting the stationary target with my Rappahannock stick. Using a straight-elbowed sidearm throw, and aiming about two yards to the right of what I really wanted to hit, I whacked the bucket a couple of times. And while it looks like a flimsy stick, from the impact on the bucket, I have no doubt it could kill small game, assuming I could control my aim.
I plan to get out and practice more. The best advice we got from the instructor (and reinforced by a recent episode of
Survivorman) is to always have your stick in your hand when you're in the bush. Because, other than a good arm, opportunity is a big factor for success. And if stealth is an issue (avoiding zombies or baddies), or if firearms aren't allowed, a rabbitstick might be your best opportunity to feed yourself.
But today, if we had had to feed ourselves with our skill, it would have been an epic fail.
Well, maybe not, if the entomologist was willing to share his rabbit with a dozen other guys.