- Joined
- Feb 15, 2006
- Messages
- 345
Hey Tolly,
I have to agree with those who reccommend Ranger knives. They are the toughest knives i have ever seen. I have an RD6, RD7, RAK, Airborne Ranger Combat, and some customs including a large and small tanto, a clip-tip bowie, and a Little Bird. I have never found a knife maker who gives you so much knife for so little dough! Most of my customs are made of S7, which is one tough-ass steel -- tougher even than 5160, which is the toughest of the steels you listed. I also have a Becker BK7 and BK9 -- both are good knives, but i have seen them break. I have never seen a broken Ranger. Not to say it can't be done, just that the only way to break one is to do so deliberately. On the other hand i have heard of knives made of 0170-6C breaking during "normal" (hard) use - something that will never happen to a Ranger. I have flexed my RD6 (in 5160 steel) at least 30 degrees while prying and it returns to true every time. They are just fabulously rugged blades.
I have not had an opportunity to play with the Ontario RATs but D2 is a good edge holder with good corrosion resistence, and 1095 is a very simple steel with decent edge holding and ease of sharpening. But for toughness, neither comes close to 5160 (given proper heat treatment, obviously). I hope this is of some help...
I have to agree with those who reccommend Ranger knives. They are the toughest knives i have ever seen. I have an RD6, RD7, RAK, Airborne Ranger Combat, and some customs including a large and small tanto, a clip-tip bowie, and a Little Bird. I have never found a knife maker who gives you so much knife for so little dough! Most of my customs are made of S7, which is one tough-ass steel -- tougher even than 5160, which is the toughest of the steels you listed. I also have a Becker BK7 and BK9 -- both are good knives, but i have seen them break. I have never seen a broken Ranger. Not to say it can't be done, just that the only way to break one is to do so deliberately. On the other hand i have heard of knives made of 0170-6C breaking during "normal" (hard) use - something that will never happen to a Ranger. I have flexed my RD6 (in 5160 steel) at least 30 degrees while prying and it returns to true every time. They are just fabulously rugged blades.
I have not had an opportunity to play with the Ontario RATs but D2 is a good edge holder with good corrosion resistence, and 1095 is a very simple steel with decent edge holding and ease of sharpening. But for toughness, neither comes close to 5160 (given proper heat treatment, obviously). I hope this is of some help...