A2 rehardens well. Plate quenching is the way I do it now. Air quenching works, but tends to allow scale to form during cooling. I used to oil quench it to avoid the scale, but had some warping problems on larger and/or thinner blades. No problemo with the plates.
I have been forging some A2 over the last year-not an easy job. Prior to heat treating, normalize it like Mete said above and it all works fine. A2 cools out of the forge harder than a preacher's heart.