Realization or Revelation?

I carried Case almost exclusively for 25yrs until I discovered the Spyderco POLICE in the late ‘90s. I still mostly carried a Case Canoe until 2009. That’s when I bought a Spyderco Rookie, shortly followed by the BM 940. That was the end of the traditional in an EDC role for me.
Had I known of a company such as GEC, I may have stayed in the traditional game a little longer.
 
I like modern folders but if I had to choose I’d give em all up for traditional folders. They have simple beauty and soul a ball bearing flipper could never have.
Not to mention all the different patterns from a by gone era. Case knives are awesome and have a masteque about them. Enjoy them! Here’s a few of my traditionals
View attachment 1041093 View attachment 1041094 View attachment 1041095 View attachment 1041098 View attachment 1041099
Beautiful!
"Simple beauty and a soul"...Yes this is more or less what I believe I'm describing today. As if all of a sudden the simple beauty and soul of these "traditionals" have been revealed to me.
 
I grew up with SAK and Case, Western, etc.. When I first held a Spyderco Standard, it was as if Heaven opened, angels were singing to me, and Jesus was there, smiling down on me.:D

I do carry a Vic MiniChamp, with a Maratac stainless peanut light on the ring, as my edc knock-about tool. I have stripped, cleaned and re-pinned my old Case, and Camillus Military Utility knives. But. For serious tasks, I always have a modern, one-hand locking folder. I've worked as an EMT, Corrections Officer, now RN, and find that a locking folder is more convenient for most tasks, as it can be "re-sheathed" without having to focus on the process, and being able to immediately drop it, if needed, without worrying about having something sharp and pointy sticking up on the ground.

YMMV...
Yes sir, the first knife I spent my own allowance on was a stainless handled Spyderco. They already hold that spot in my heart.
Undoubtedly a modern locking folder will have greater advantages over the Traditional. Today I'm seemingly caught up in the beauty of them, that i apparently didnt appreciate before.
 
If there is any trend in my knife buying and carrying, it's going to thinner knives, simpler knives, and generally smaller knives than years ago other than fixed blades. I have been carrying a Case Peanut in my watch pocket to acclimate my self to this possible change down the road. As I said before, it is really difficult for me to bounce my regular SAK from my pocket. It's an old friend of 10+ years of carry. I know that the majority of my cutting could be done with a very small knife and only carry a larger one for certain work situations which I could accomplish with a knife in my field bag that is carried inside my truck.... I already carry standard sized pliers based multitools in that bag with other tools including some knives, so it would be a minimal change there. I keep a Leatherman Ps4 Squirt on my keychain. The real issue is that I simply like knives.
 
I bought a Gerber Mk II the other day simply because deep down inside of me my inner child thought it looked really really cool lol. I think though as I've matured I haven't out grown a particular style of knife it's that my taste simply has broadened.

I have to say I am a little biased against traditional slip joints though. I think it's because I grew up with a lot of cheap slip joints as a kid. Where it took super long finger nails or a pointy stick to pry that sucker open. Seeing my friends with their super fast easy to open with one hand knives really struck a chord with me, and is what got me interested in knives as a hobby. But like anything I bet a high quality traditional slip joint is night and day better I just need to get one.
 
I've always carried a pocketknife, long before the advent of "tactical folders". Never gave it a thought about it being loose in my pocket. My first exposure to a Spydero with a clip changed my world forever - since then I cannot stand to have a knife in my pocket that isn't clipped to the opening. Just can't do it.
 
I have changed, but it was the other way around for me. I started with slip-joints, specifically 91mm SAKS, but I was issued a 111mm SAK with a one-handed opening (not one-handed closing, though) locking blade when I enlisted in the army, and really liked it. When I started working as an animal rescuer, I made a complete switch to one-handed opening and closing, locking knives, because they really made the difference in some rescues where I had only one hand available to take my knife out, do the cutting, close it and keep it again.

That said, I am somewhat traditional at heart, one reason why my Cold Steel Code 4 is always on me is because I kinda view it as a modern Buck 110. I love my Spyderco Endura 4 for the same reason. I'm really not into quick-firing flippers on bearings, drop-shutty actions that are favoured by knife enthusiasts nowadays. I like smooth, gentle thumb-stud or thumb-hole opening. I know some back-locks are difficult to close one-handed but mine are nicely broken in and they are easy.
 
1. Have you changed, if so how.
My knives have changed a lot, I'm just as good as ever.
I started carrying stockmans, sometimes two in the late 60's thru early 90's. In the 60's and 70's working a warehouse or factory floor, I could easily dull a blade or two a day, so a stockman at least allowed me to get home with one sharp blade. The only other option, was those big bulky Stanly box knives.

When I went to a machine shop it didn't take long to learn that steel had capabilities, that my knife steel lacked. I acquired a dislike for CV, 440A & 420HC, on a working knife.

Queens D2 changed everything, Over the years, I've moved from 3 blades, to two blades, to single blade knives. With the new steels I can work longer with one blade than I could with all 3 blades of a Case stockman. Two knives and two blade shapes and I don't see that changing anytime soon. These new combinations have served me better than any other. I've learned to appreciate the ease of rolling the blade open one handed. I doubt I'll ever like flipping a knife open, hate the clank sound.

2. What's the consensus on the next Case. Have a look at GEC.
3. Am I old? Yes you are old and getting older. ;)

These days my carry looks like this.
KwOlsEN.jpg

0pi9MkG.jpg
 
1. Have you changed, if so how.
My knives have changed a lot, I'm just as good as ever.
I started carrying stockmans, sometimes two in the late 60's thru early 90's. In the 60's and 70's working a warehouse or factory floor, I could easily dull a blade or two a day, so a stockman at least allowed me to get home with one sharp blade. The only other option, was those big bulky Stanly box knives.

When I went to a machine shop it didn't take long to learn that steel had capabilities, that my knife steel lacked. I acquired a dislike for CV, 440A & 420HC, on a working knife.

Queens D2 changed everything, Over the years, I've moved from 3 blades, to two blades, to single blade knives. With the new steels I can work longer with one blade than I could with all 3 blades of a Case stockman. Two knives and two blade shapes and I don't see that changing anytime soon. These new combinations have served me better than any other. I've learned to appreciate the ease of rolling the blade open one handed. I doubt I'll ever like flipping a knife open, hate the clank sound.

2. What's the consensus on the next Case. Have a look at GEC.
3. Am I old? Yes you are old and getting older. ;)

These days my carry looks like this.
KwOlsEN.jpg

0pi9MkG.jpg
First and foremost, let me express my gratitude for the fact that you quite literally replied to my 1.2.3. Questions in a 1.2.3. format, with informative insight to boot! Much appreciated.
1. I wish I was as good as ever. In addition to your attention to detail, clearly you are an optimist.
2. GEC certainly appears well represented here today. I will check them out post haste.
3. Yeah...getting older................:(
Beautiful carry, Thanks Dean
 
With GEC's, if you like the size and the feel of the knife, you'll mostly likely love their attention to detail in the manufacturing process. For me it took a bit of time before I was willing to spend the extra $ for a GEC over a Case. But today, I think they are totally worth the extra cost. They approach customs in their fit & finish. Most Case's certainly don't. However I love my little white stag Case Peanut and it is well put together; so their fit & finish varies a bit.

My first GEC was a 56 and it was one of the less expensive ones at the time. It was almost impossible to open the blade due to spring strength. I left it sit open for a couple weeks and the spring loosened up a bit. This however didn't turn me off to GEC made knives. I love the 72/73 size. My favorite was the Missouri Trapper (#42) at 4.25" closed. But I'm starting to lean more toward something at 4" or slightly less overall now like the 72/73 size. Still prefer a two blade over a single bladed one even though the single bladed ones are obviously thinner in the pocket. Have a fairly good selection of them, model wise. So, if I want to use one,I just have to grab it.

I remember at a show in their early days asking Ken Daniels why GECs' cost more than Case's. He didn't really have an answer at the time. I was an idiot asking such a question to be honest, and probably a bit of a smart ass.
 
Have fun with your new interest in Case knives. I found my way back to traditional knives after about 20 years of thumb studs and clips. Now I have a foot in both worlds. I enjoy the warmth of a natural handle material and the certain style that an old pocket knife has. I also see the utility of a one-hand folder.

Gaining an new appreciation for something is not an indication of growing old.
 
I love my GEC's, I'm partial to stag and GEC has some stunning stag. I have a 23 single blade with stag I dearly love. Also have a two blade 23 with pick bone scales that was made for Schrade (Fire and Ice), it's also flawless. I love my Case knives too, but the GEC's are just stunning. Well worth the higher price. I love carbon steel blades and the patina they take with use. I have no safe queens regardless of cost. For me the joy comes in using.
Bob
 
Have fun with your new interest in Case knives. I found my way back to traditional knives after about 20 years of thumb studs and clips. Now I have a foot in both worlds. I enjoy the warmth of a natural handle material and the certain style that an old pocket knife has. I also see the utility of a one-hand folder.

Gaining an new appreciation for something is not an indication of growing old.

Very well stated.
 
Now I have a foot in both worlds. I enjoy the warmth of a natural handle material and the certain style that an old pocket knife has. I also see the utility of a one-hand folder.

Gaining an new appreciation for something is not an indication of growing old.
As most here have stated, "I just like knives". I also like both modern and traditional knives, so I carry both, a clipped folder and a Case mini trapper (as well as a SAK on my key ring).

As far as the getting old part, I'm already there.
 
1. Have you changed, if so how.

Sure I've changed. I think most people do.
Teens and twenties: school, more school, getting started in life... I basically had no idea what I was doing or where I was going and my life wasn't really the same year to year. I experimented with a lot of different interests and was in the process of picking out which activities would a part of my life. Hiking, cycling and skiing were at the top and knives were tools in the mix.

Thirties: Coming to grips with career, mortgage and kids. Financial planning was more like survival. Lots of focus on keeping my head above water and my family but not me (as it should be). My focus on activities was a balance of trying to keep them going while piecing together gear kits on a shoe string budget. Plenty of "make do" decisions, including with knives.

Forties and fifties: Life has been more stable and predictable. My attention to most things is now on reflection and refinement. My various kits are basically sorted and as stuff needs replacing, I'm in a position to be more selective. I've also had the chance to explore and try new things without the fear of making a life long mistake. Gear comes and gear goes. Not everything that looks good on paper or that is praised by others works for me and this is across the board, not just limited to knives. I trust my own experience and my own ability to judge what works for me more than I did when I was younger.

2. What's the consensus on the next Case

This is like picking another man's shoes, drink or lover for him.

In my late 30s to 40s, I experimented a lot with different gear in different activities and have become convinced that this sort of experimentation is needed to find what sort of gear is a best fit. An example...

When I was very young, I had scout knives. This is what a knife looked like.

In high school, I fell in love with the Buck 110, but never warmed up to holster carry, so it rode along in my backpack like the brass brick that it was. So, for backpacking, I swung to the other extreme with just a Victorinox Classic in my pack. (Actually it was a series of Classics all of which busted but I digress.). Then in my twenties I tried a SOG Paratool, which looked awesome on paper but turned out to be the worst tool ever in terms of ergonomics. The I was gifted an Opinel in a bike parts trade and it ended up in my pocket and I went on a binge of trying different front pocket carries of all different sizes.

My endpoint... I like a large traditional single blade folder in my right rear pocket (I sew a seam there), a mini multi tool (Micra) in my right front pocket and a full sized multitool (not the SOG) in my day pack.

Why did I write all of that? All to say that I could no more tell you which Case to get next than you could tell me which knife would work best for me.

3. Am I old?

If being old means coming to accept who you are and what your preferences are, that's not a bad thing.
 
Sure I've changed. I think most people do.
Teens and twenties: school, more school, getting started in life... I basically had no idea what I was doing or where I was going and my life wasn't really the same year to year. I experimented with a lot of different interests and was in the process of picking out which activities would a part of my life. Hiking, cycling and skiing were at the top and knives were tools in the mix.

Thirties: Coming to grips with career, mortgage and kids. Financial planning was more like survival. Lots of focus on keeping my head above water and my family but not me (as it should be). My focus on activities was a balance of trying to keep them going while piecing together gear kits on a shoe string budget. Plenty of "make do" decisions, including with knives.

Forties and fifties: Life has been more stable and predictable. My attention to most things is now on reflection and refinement. My various kits are basically sorted and as stuff needs replacing, I'm in a position to be more selective. I've also had the chance to explore and try new things without the fear of making a life long mistake. Gear comes and gear goes. Not everything that looks good on paper or that is praised by others works for me and this is across the board, not just limited to knives. I trust my own experience and my own ability to judge what works for me more than I did when I was younger.



This is like picking another man's shoes, drink or lover for him.

In my late 30s to 40s, I experimented a lot with different gear in different activities and have become convinced that this sort of experimentation is needed to find what sort of gear is a best fit. An example...

When I was very young, I had scout knives. This is what a knife looked like.

In high school, I fell in love with the Buck 110, but never warmed up to holster carry, so it rode along in my backpack like the brass brick that it was. So, for backpacking, I swung to the other extreme with just a Victorinox Classic in my pack. (Actually it was a series of Classics all of which busted but I digress.). Then in my twenties I tried a SOG Paratool, which looked awesome on paper but turned out to be the worst tool ever in terms of ergonomics. The I was gifted an Opinel in a bike parts trade and it ended up in my pocket and I went on a binge of trying different front pocket carries of all different sizes.

My endpoint... I like a large traditional single blade folder in my right rear pocket (I sew a seam there), a mini multi tool (Micra) in my right front pocket and a full sized multitool (not the SOG) in my day pack.

Why did I write all of that? All to say that I could no more tell you which Case to get next than you could tell me which knife would work best for me.



If being old means coming to accept who you are and what your preferences are, that's not a bad thing.
Pinnah,
In posting the thread, I was certainly prompting for a reply like the one you have given. Thats what I was lookin for. And so many others, for that matter, Thank You All! Your posts were filled with wisdom, experience, and self reflection.
Perhaps it was the self reflection I was seeking yesterday. Birthdays seem to be a contemplative time for me, lost in nostalgia.
I'd like to thank you all, for what appeared to be honest opinions, and thoughtful direction.
I will take away this.
1. I will buy more Traditionals...hooked now, will keep one foot in each arena
2. Gunna look for a GEC, and there are more Case knives already on the way
3. The community here seems superb. Thanks All.
 
So I purchased MY first Case knife today. In thought of where to place this thread, I chose general discussions as opposed to a Case sub forum, as this may be more about me, than the knife. However, since this is a knife forum, I'll get the stats out of the way before I blabber.
1. Plain ol' U.S.A. CV Trapper in yellow.
2. A whopping $28 at our local family owned outfitters
So now to expand on my statement. Today I purchased my 8th Case brand knife, but as previously noted, the first for me. Over the years I'd often purchase them as gifts for Grandpas and "old fellas" alike, never once with even the slightest desire to drop one in my own pocket. I would look right over them, as if they weren't even there...until today. Now I am no greenhorn, I have carried and collected since 1986. I did not cut my teeth in the late "tacticool age", and while I collect like most here, I tend to view knives as tools. How could it be, until today, I failed to see the sheer beauty, and functionality of a slip joint pocket knife. It sits in my lap, as I type, gleaming of simplicity, strength, and finish. I've immediately succumbed to this infatuation, and shopping other Case knives now.
I suppose however my question to the blade forum community is, has your taste in knives changed, with a direct correlation to age. Today is my birthday, and I walked into a brick and mortar to purchase myself a Case. You see, I'm perhaps confounded in whether or not today was a REALIZATION that slip joint pocket knives are awesome, or a REVELATION that I am now the "old fella".
So everyone...
1. Have you changed, if so how.
2. What's the consensus on the next Case
3. Am I old?
With age/experience comes wisdom
 
Back
Top