Recommendations for Camping and Cooking Knife?

Imagine thinking that cooking with a Buck 119 leads to carpal tunnel. Wow.

I take it you don't have experience with professional cooking/restaurants. Carpal tunnel is a thing, and it's not uncommon to see people (usually new people) in one of those wrist braces. The problem is always (?) bad technique, so the person needs to learn a proper pinch grip, not to hold on too tightly, etc.

You can't do a pinch grip and succeed at prepping food with a Buck 119, though it is a great knife, so a person who's trying to cook with one *could* risk hurting their wrists. The proper hold would not allow the blade of a 119 to touch the cutting board, and even without the hilt your knuckles would hit before the blade. So with the 119 you'd have to use a different grip and different techniques. That's true of any bowie-style knife. I've had some. I've had fun with them. You could get a meal on the table with one. But you can't use "proper" knifework techniques with one, so something has to give - speed, quality, or your wrist.

Also anytime you're cooking but holding a knife like it's a hammer, or a machete, you're at that risk. Of course if you're just slowing slicing things, or don't care about making exact cuts (which is fine of course, if that's not something you care about), then the risk is lower. But if you want speed and/or precision, you have to use proper techniques like rocking instead of drawing a blade, and of course any professional cook never lets their elbow move *backward* much past their back (although that is due to the realities of working on the line).

Google can help you find videos of proper knifework for cooking or to find people who have actually worked in restaurants and know this stuff, including the fact that cooks who use poor technique do get carpal tunnel, not infrequently.

Women in particular tend not to complain about things (well... *some* things), and I've known kind of a lot of women, older women, over the years who have cooked their whole life, and I showed them a couple of knife techniques, and it improved their lives (or so they said). In particular, I know women who don't even know what a chef's knife is or why it's important. I wonder how many of them also rub their wrists or experience mild pain and no one ever notices and they don't know what to attribute it to? The occasional camp cook isn't likely to have those problems, but ask grandma if her wrist ever hurts, and then see what knife she uses and how she uses it.
 
You may need to contact a custom maker to get what you want. This is a Phillip Patton Phillip Patton that I recently found, and it is as close to a chef knife as I have in a thick, camp knife. I would have no issue using this to split wood, and the knife is certainly styled like a chefs knife. Works great in the kitchen, AEBL, thick, durable. View attachment 2464391

View attachment 2464392
 
You may need to contact a custom maker to get what you want.
Maybe, though there were several great suggestions earlier in this thread. And that knife you posted is beautiful!

I decided to play with other things for a while first. I'm working on my "trio", or maybe a couple of different trios, so not gonna jump on any one thing until a few of the smaller bits arrive and I decide how I feel about them.
 
I went through the same issue and settled on the off grid grizzly.

Otherwise there is the condor bush slicer, which I think is a bit thick. And the men with a pot knife, which is is a bit over priced.

That's fantastic. And the price is perfect. Wow! Closest to that (but way more expensive) is the Murray Carter Three Legged Dog - > https://www.cartercutlery.com/knives/knives/carter/5-08-carter-3041-three-legged-dog/

Thanks for pointing out the off-grid grizzly! - Seriously
 

Attachments

  • C3041-1-1.jpg
    C3041-1-1.jpg
    1,015.9 KB · Views: 5
That's fantastic. And the price is perfect. Wow! Closest to that (but way more expensive) is the Murray Carter Three Legged Dog - > https://www.cartercutlery.com/knives/knives/carter/5-08-carter-3041-three-legged-dog/

Thanks for pointing out the off-grid grizzly! - Seriously
It took me a few goes to find that one.

It also feels surprisingly nice in the hand. The reviews say well balance and I just sort of overlooked that as a sales pitch. But it really is.

That flat end also makes an OK spatula. If they sharpened it a bit it would have been perfect.
 
It took me a few goes to find that one.

It also feels surprisingly nice in the hand. The reviews say well balance and I just sort of overlooked that as a sales pitch. But it really is.

That flat end also makes an OK spatula. If they sharpened it a bit it would have been perfect.
You could send it to Carter to be sharpened, or the District Cutlery in DC. The both do a decent job of re-edging and making things into razors. (But of course I think it is around $30 and that is a $100 knife, so ...)
 
These people don't know how to cook. They'll talk about how "slicy" it is, like that is significant. ANY knife can slice things, that just means it's sharp.

So ... a razor-sharp wood chisel will slice onions, peppers, carrots and pepperoni better than a kinda-sharp but thin chef's knife? Really?

I take it you don't have experience with professional cooking/restaurants.

But you do?
 
Last edited:
These people don't know how to cook. They'll talk about how "slicy" it is, like that is significant. ANY knife can slice things, that just means it's sharp.
So ... a razor-sharp wood chisel will slice onions, peppers, carrots and pepperoni better than a kinda-sharp but thin chef's knife? Really?

LOL.....don't waste your breath....some people just don't want to hear it......
This Stromeng has a 5" scandi blade thats ground from 2.8mm flat stock, 115CrV3 steel, and is razor sharp. It will slice your finger easily, and it does well at carving wood. However, slicing vegetables is like splitting firewood......
evhpbTN.jpg



On the other hand, this 6" Lapinleuku from Marttiini has a 2.5mm thick 12C27 blade that is more or less a convex grind, is also razor sharp, and flies through potatoes and tomatoes as well as any "chefs knife"....
t5sT16h.jpg

But you do?
4qTi7eNm.png
 
Last edited:
I am seconding the Off Grid Grizzly V2 - I just got one. Great size and thickness for a camp knife. Tomatoes or chopping wood. It's well balanced and comfortable. On Amazon it's $87 and in stock. Worth getting.


One of the keys is that it is durable, but is thinner like a kitchen knife. Some of the other recommendations on here are over 1/8 inch, which is overly thick. Unless of course you have decided that you want a pocket axe. In which case I can't help you. ;)
This thing is priced at the cost of materials.

A more kitchen type option - but you can't chop wood with it is the classic Victorinox 8 inch chef knife. https://www.victorinox.com/us/en/Pr...wiss-Classic-Chef’s-Knife-8-inch/p/6.8063.20G
That one is a kitchen knife and $40 on Amazon. It's a classic.
 
Last edited:
Chris Reeve makes a nice Backpacker fixed blade that will do kitchen chores in the field.
The Chris Reeve Backpacker would be much nicer if it was thinner. 1/8" max on something that size. If that is not for Magnacut, then do it in 3V or even 1095. Good size and shape, hollow ground, but too thick.
 
Back
Top