First of all, I'm not a bladesmith. But I have customized and built solid-body electric guitars for myself and friends for over 15 years. I've also cobbled together a couple of knives from kits that have served me well. I think the concepts and skills involved are parallel, although the materials and end-use are quite different.
godogs57 said:
#3) Its OK to be your own worst critic when assessing your work....take the extra time to make your knife as perfect as you can make it.
That is absolutely true! "Custom" work means going the extra mile on details, and tweaking each little dimension, option or material to suit you or your customer's needs. That's why people pay more for a custom item, and why luthiers, gunsmiths, cabinet-makers, knifemakers, etc. can earn a living.Flatten flats, roll or sharpen corners as the need dictates, remove any evidence of imperfections in materials.
Craftsmanship requires experience, skill and talent. I've built guitars that "casual" observers think are perfect, but I know where the little tiny flaws are, and I've learned from every mistake. FIT and FINISH count for a lot in any kind of serious tool/insturment. I'm not a snob for a "perfect" mirror polish, but I turn my nose up at a sloppy guard or a handle that feels off-balance.
gregrobinson said:
If you're getting tired, frustrated, or losing focus, call it a day.
This statement is equally true, if for no other reason than your own safety! I have a very noticeable scar on my left thumb that is the direct result of my own inattention. Please learn from my dumb-ass-ness!
On a simliar note, I would like to add that sometimes you have to step back and just plain STOP working on a project. It's easy to get caught up in details that might be cool, and lose sight of the overall design. Too many "bells and whistles" will only drive costs up, make the piece too specific to appeal to a general user, and might end up making a good design look like an over-wrought piece of "trendy" BS.
So, I feel that common sense and reminding yourself to stick to the basics (and execute the 'basics' as expertly as you possibly can) is a good addition to this checklist.