Just got my MashedCat SAR-8 sheath from BCS this afternoon - my SAR-8 LE didn't get stuck, but it WAS hard to extract from the sheath, took some real effort, far more that my SAR-4 LE requires with its MashedCAT. When I tried my SAR-4 LE in the SAR-8 sheath, it came out a little easier than my SAR-8, but not by much. The tightness seems to be limited the the handle area - naturally, since I've heard that MashedCats don't really touch the blade areas to avoid scratches. It's probably an unfortunate combination of individual variations - a little thicker handle on the knife, a little smaller sheath opening where it grips and locks in the handle. I guess I'll have to do the tape and hairdryer thing. Good Luck!