Sawback or no sawback

Feel free to disregard every word of this, your entitled to your opinion:

I see no reason to carry on this argument it will solve nothing, and nothing will be gained if you "win" it.
Also as I feel responsible I would like to request every one to stop before a mod lays down the law.

Cheers

-niner
 
Also as I feel responsible I would like to request every one to stop before a mod lays down the law.

Cheers

-niner

Nope that would be me. not you at all...don't worry about it. I am a big boy.


And since I am out numbered ,what, three to one I give up. I guess experience has no meaning. Sorry OP...figured you would want hands on advice.

Well...off to give my advice on knife types I have no experience on... :-)
 
Nope that would be me. not you at all...don't worry about it. I am a big boy.


And since I am out numbered ,what, three to one I give up. I guess experience has no meaning. Sorry OP...figured you would want hands on advice.

Well...off to give my advice on knife types I have no experience on... :-)

I have no problem with your advice, it was solid and gained from experience and all I can do is respect that!

Also how to you feel about XM-18's? Haha hope there's no hard feelings man!

Wish ya the best!

-niner
 
Not wanting to stir up the already stirred up hornet's nest, I will not give my "no actual experience on discussed knives opinion". I will tip my hat to niner for being a total gentleman in his post. I do have life experience in that subject, and he showed real maturity in his response.

Blessings,

Omar
 
While I do qualify for a direct purchase XM-18 ,I don't own one.

No hard feelings Bro...

But now we are going off topic.
 
Ok glad there's no hard feelings! And thank you OHALLUM it means a lot.......Ironically I'm listing to a song called troublemaker:)

-niner
 
I've got no ill will or feelings toward anyone here at all. I don't think that there is anything for a mod to jump on as we all seem to be mature and civil. If I stepped on your toes with the "get over yourself" comment I apologize. Reading it back it does seem rude, thankfully you don't appear to be one of those with super thin skin. :D

For what it's worth, yes, as I implied, I (in my own threads) welcome the opinions of everyone, be they well versed in topic or not. I trust myself to determine the validity of what's said. On the other hand I write product reviews freelance so I'm fairly use to doing research on things that interest me. If I only had the word of a few forumites to go by maybe I'd feel differently.

Now that I've had my say I'm done. I know that we are supposed to be talking about the subject at hand and not each other. That's where we get in trouble and for that reason, I'm out. :p
 
I've got no ill will or feelings toward anyone here at all. I don't think that there is anything for a mod to jump on as we all seem to be mature and civil. If I stepped on your toes with the "get over yourself" comment I apologize. Reading it back it does seem rude, thankfully you don't appear to be one of those with super thin skin

Nope not at all....It's all good....
 
Just out of curiosity, what in either of those Glocks makes them appropriate camping/hiking/fishing knife to you? They look like modified bayonets, made for stabbing. We could help you do a lot better at any price point. Get you something designed for outdoor recreation.

I have expensive survival camp knives like the gerber lmfii gerber prodigy sog nw ranger ect , the reason this knife is so attractive to me is the fact that first it uses spring steel and is a unbiasedly proclaimed indestructable knife , people batoning it with a hammer throughout the side of a 2x4 , people trying
To break the tip in freezing conditions , by chiseling it through things like concrete pavement and not to mention the knife is suppositly a killer throwing knife .
 
I have expensive survival camp knives like the gerber lmfii gerber prodigy sog nw ranger ect , the reason this knife is so attractive to me is the fact that first it uses spring steel and is a unbiasedly proclaimed indestructable knife , people batoning it with a hammer throughout the side of a 2x4 , people trying
To break the tip in freezing conditions , by chiseling it through things like concrete pavement and not to mention the knife is suppositly a killer throwing knife .

Do you do a lot of that in a "... common camping , fishing hiking situation..."? :confused:
 
Last edited:
Having actually tested both versions of the Glock knives myself in cutting, sawing, digging, drilling oak, and batonning with them, maybe I can help. :)

The "spring steel" is nothing special, and it's a trifle on the soft side regarding heat treatment hardening.
It does not come particularly sharp in either configuration.
It doesn't take a razor edge, exactly, but I got a good working edge with my larger whetstone.

That softer steel will bend before it'll fracture, typically. I used a rubber mallet to hammer the tip of one into oak about half an inch & then twisted & pried it out several times. The tip bent slightly about 3/4 of an inch back, it was very easy to bend it back.

The blade configuration IS a bayonet, which makes it less efficient in processing game. It doesn't have enough belly.
It does not have enough weight to chop with.
It's cheap enough to dig a small fire hole with in hard dirt, you won't worry about scratching a pretty finish.

I drilled a few half an inch deep holes in oak, no damage to the edge.
I sawed through finger-thick oak branches, took a while. The teeth ARE too wide, and they're not configured efficiently.
They CAN saw, but not efficiently & not fast. They do work reasonably well for notching.

The Glock knives ARE NOT throwing knives. They were not intended to be, they are not especially balanced well for throwing.
Not very good for processing fish, a bit thick.
It was not designed for chiseling through concrete & will suffer notable damage if you try.

They're not junk, and they're well worth their price as a beater knife. I have five, but they're not mainliners. :)
They are not superknives.
Denis
 
Back
Top