Scout Knife Memorial GAW 2023

abbydaddy

Gold Member
Joined
Oct 14, 2014
Messages
3,243
I'm quite late with my GAW this year, but maybe I can get a new scout knife to a kid in time for their summer fun.

I typically try to do these GAWs around my brother's birthday (in January), but this year it is on the anniversary of his death. It is hard to believe that my baby brother has been gone for nine years now. He would be 29 if he were alive today.

Background About My Brother

On May 14th, 2014, my baby brother died in a car accident. He was 13 years younger than me, but we were very close. When he was a baby we shared a room, and so I woke with him and fed him and changed him as an infant (which led my dad, at one point, to mistakenly claim that August slept through the night from the beginning). For a good chunk of his early childhood it was just him, me, and my dad, so my brother had a hard time understanding that he did not have two dads. As he got older that changed, but the semi-parental character always stayed a part of our relationship. After I moved out he moved across the country to live with his mom, who he stayed with for the most part until his death. Nonetheless, he always made sure to call me at least a couple times a month until he died. He was very good about keeping in touch. Much better than I am.

He did not have an easy go of it in life, and as he got on into his teenage years he had a lot of trouble with drugs and alcohol. He had a series of stints in rehab and a school for troubled teens. After high school he continued the same trajectory, and though he enrolled in a community college he was not able to keep clean and quickly dropped out. After dropping out of college he finally seemed to get serious about his recovery. After another stint in rehab he started going to Narcotics Anonymous meetings regularly.

After years of expecting to hear that my brother had died of an overdose, he suddenly seemed to be back. His speech was clear, he was happy, he went back to school and was doing better this time. He held down a job and was active in the recovery community. He was optimistic and doing well, and I stopped expecting bad news. As it turned out he stayed clean for the rest of his life.

A little over nine years ago, my oldest daughter was born (she started Girl Scouts earlier this year!), and my brother was thrilled to be an uncle. My wife and I made plans to fly him out with her brothers so all the uncles could meet Abby together.

A month after my daughter was born, late at night, he gave a friend a ride home, and then on his own way home, lost control of his car (driving way too fast) and wrapped his car around a telephone pole. His system was clean, he wasn't drunk or high, he was just driving recklessly (much as I had done at his age). He was 20 years old.

Though his car was just ten feet off the side of the road, near a housing development, it was more than four hours before anyone stopped to check on his car. In my brother's case it probably wouldn't have made a difference if he had crashed next to an emergency room, but we'll never know for sure. I include this detail just as a reminder that we are all in this together, and you can save lives just by stopping to check. I've saved a few folks over the years by checking on wrecks, and I've known other people who were saved by a passerby stopping. It doesn't take any special knowledge or skill to call 911 for a person in trouble, but you could save their life.


But on to the giveaway.

After my brother passed, his mother sent some of his things to me that had special sentimental value. When my brother was little he was very impressed by my sword collection, so when he turned 13 I bought him a replica saber. His mother sent his sword back to me, along with his babyhood favorite stuffed Barney for my daughter (currently claimed by my youngest daughter who takes her Barney everywhere), and for my father she sent my brother's knife. My brother's knife was my dad's old Camillus Boy Scout Knife, and it was in turn my brother's adventure knife. Though my brother was not a Boy Scout, that old Boy Scout knife was special to him.

I wanted to be able to share that, or to help someone else share it. So my idea is to send a Boy Scout Knife out to someone to give to a youngster for their first knife. So if you know a kid who needs a knife (and it is okay for you to give them a knife) I invite you to nominate a kid you will give the knife to. But I also want more people to participate, so you can also enter for yourself.

Unfortunately, Camillus went bankrupt a while back, and even the new Camillus doesn't make an official Boy Scout Knife. I like to give away new official BSA licensed scout knives, but ScoutShop doesn't sell the classic pattern anymore.

Thanks to the generosity of W willintheweeds I have a NIB made in the USA Bear and Son Cub Scout Knife (he also sent me an extra for my son who will be starting scouts this year!). At first I was not sold on the Cub Scout pattern because it wasn't what I was used to, but I have to admit that the locking utility blades are really handy. My daughter has a selection of knives including an older Girl Scout Knife, but she likes the Cub Scout best. So if you are picking a knife for a younger kid, the Cub Scout is a very nice option.

I have also purchased a deluxe pattern Boy Scout knife (they have an added Philips head screwdriver and no bail). So there are good options available for the winners.

And to try to encourage more participation from the community, I also purchased a Case Mini Trapper to give away this year. I wanted more Made in USA options, and something to tempt the grown up collectors around here. And after Case reached out a few years back and donated some knives for earlier iterations of this GAW, I have no problem shelling out a little extra to offer folks a Case BSA knife. They are awfully fine, I recommend getting one for yourself if you so choose.

This year's knife offerings:

full


Also, in case anyone is interested, I'll also offer my personal old USA made Camillus BSA knife. Johnnythefox Johnnythefox sent me a UK made camp knife that has taken its place in my backpack, so I am willing to let someone else enjoy my Camillus, if they so desire.
full


This GAW has a history of inspiring generosity from the community (obviously, that is not something that I can guarantee, but with this crowd it is pretty reliable), so it is possible that new prizes might get added, but I think I am set up pretty well this year. And thanks again to W willintheweeds for his continuing generosity year after year.

Rules for this year:
  • Open to everyone
  • You can enter one time for yourself
  • You can enter a second time on behalf of someone else, preferably a child that you will give the knife to (make sure it is someone that you can give the knife to without any problems), or someone working hard at their recovery.
  • I will send the knife to anywhere in the US and Canada (And if you are a regular porch participant, I will send it internationally as well)
  • your entry will be your post in which you say "I'm in" AND tell me who you will give the knife to (whether to yourself or to someone you are nominating)
  • You don't have to tell me why you are nominating someone, but I would appreciate it if you did
  • Don't enter if there is some reason that it would be legally problematic for you to enter

I am going to let this run for a couple weeks. There usually aren't many entries, so the odds are good if you decide to enter :)

Note:

I was inspired by a [IMG alt="Charlie Mike"]https://www.bladeforums.com/data/avatars/s/112/112780.jpg?1492197467[/IMG] Charlie Mike giveaway seven (or so) years back, when he gave away a knife as a mitzvah following the passing of a friend and fellow recoverer. Since my brother was also in recovery when he passed I thought it was an extra fitting mitzvah. As I was nearing the anniversary of my brother's death, I thought this would be a fitting way to help make his memory be for a blessing. When I do this giveaway I like to mention the history of the tradition.

Sadly, Charlie Mike left us far too early after he too managed to stay sober for the rest of his life. He had just passed his five year sober mark when he died in January 2019. May his memory be for a blessing.
 
Sad but Wonderful Memorial GA, abbydaddy abbydaddy , and nice seeing you and Abby in Oregon!! I am still saving the Scout I won from you for my grandson (he's not quite ready yet!!)!!!
I'll put a nomination in this post when I find a young'un somewhere that needs one!
Not an entry for me!!
 
Wow, just wow abbydaddy abbydaddy . Your story puts things into perspective.

I would like to enter your Memorial GAW, and thank you for the opportunity to participate. The boys name he knife would be for is Jannis, 14 years old, he loves to fish and being "out and about" in general.

Enjoy each day to the fullest. Tomorrow may never come, albeit we sure hope so.

Keeping your brother and your family in my thoughts.
 
Last edited:
I would encourage everyone to enter or nominate someone as it’s probably the most meaningful GAW on the porch. I’ve been the recipient twice, both times giving the knives to a couple of young kids. One went to a co-workers son that just made Eagle Scout, the other to a young boy who lost his father. His father had been in Boy Scouts so I thought it would be a nice gesture.

No entry for me at this time but I’ll pay Attention to the responses and throw in on behalf of someone off the porch…
 
Amazing GAW abbydaddy abbydaddy and a tradition worth keeping!

Not an entry, but as a winner of the previous GAW (well, my daughter was actually), I wanted to share a pic that I took…

These were just sitting on my daughter’s bathroom sink counter and thought they made a fitting EDC. Getting used often and a go to tool for my daughter!

abbydaddy abbydaddy , thank you!

ZJwMsP5.jpg
 
Amazing GAW abbydaddy abbydaddy and a tradition worth keeping!

Not an entry, but as a winner of the previous GAW (well, my daughter was actually), I wanted to share a pic that I took…

These were just sitting on my daughter’s bathroom sink counter and thought they made a fitting EDC. Getting used often and a go to tool for my daughter!

abbydaddy abbydaddy , thank you!

ZJwMsP5.jpg
That is very nice to see! Nothing better than knowing that a knife you've gifted is being used :)
 
I'm quite late with my GAW this year, but maybe I can get a new scout knife to a kid in time for their summer fun.

I typically try to do these GAWs around my brother's birthday (in January), but this year it is on the anniversary of his death. It is hard to believe that my baby brother has been gone for nine years now. He would be 29 if he were alive today.

Background About My Brother

On May 14th, 2014, my baby brother died in a car accident. He was 13 years younger than me, but we were very close. When he was a baby we shared a room, and so I woke with him and fed him and changed him as an infant (which led my dad, at one point, to mistakenly claim that August slept through the night from the beginning). For a good chunk of his early childhood it was just him, me, and my dad, so my brother had a hard time understanding that he did not have two dads. As he got older that changed, but the semi-parental character always stayed a part of our relationship. After I moved out he moved across the country to live with his mom, who he stayed with for the most part until his death. Nonetheless, he always made sure to call me at least a couple times a month until he died. He was very good about keeping in touch. Much better than I am.

He did not have an easy go of it in life, and as he got on into his teenage years he had a lot of trouble with drugs and alcohol. He had a series of stints in rehab and a school for troubled teens. After high school he continued the same trajectory, and though he enrolled in a community college he was not able to keep clean and quickly dropped out. After dropping out of college he finally seemed to get serious about his recovery. After another stint in rehab he started going to Narcotics Anonymous meetings regularly.

After years of expecting to hear that my brother had died of an overdose, he suddenly seemed to be back. His speech was clear, he was happy, he went back to school and was doing better this time. He held down a job and was active in the recovery community. He was optimistic and doing well, and I stopped expecting bad news. As it turned out he stayed clean for the rest of his life.

A little over nine years ago, my oldest daughter was born (she started Girl Scouts earlier this year!), and my brother was thrilled to be an uncle. My wife and I made plans to fly him out with her brothers so all the uncles could meet Abby together.

A month after my daughter was born, late at night, he gave a friend a ride home, and then on his own way home, lost control of his car (driving way too fast) and wrapped his car around a telephone pole. His system was clean, he wasn't drunk or high, he was just driving recklessly (much as I had done at his age). He was 20 years old.

Though his car was just ten feet off the side of the road, near a housing development, it was more than four hours before anyone stopped to check on his car. In my brother's case it probably wouldn't have made a difference if he had crashed next to an emergency room, but we'll never know for sure. I include this detail just as a reminder that we are all in this together, and you can save lives just by stopping to check. I've saved a few folks over the years by checking on wrecks, and I've known other people who were saved by a passerby stopping. It doesn't take any special knowledge or skill to call 911 for a person in trouble, but you could save their life.


But on to the giveaway.

After my brother passed, his mother sent some of his things to me that had special sentimental value. When my brother was little he was very impressed by my sword collection, so when he turned 13 I bought him a replica saber. His mother sent his sword back to me, along with his babyhood favorite stuffed Barney for my daughter (currently claimed by my youngest daughter who takes her Barney everywhere), and for my father she sent my brother's knife. My brother's knife was my dad's old Camillus Boy Scout Knife, and it was in turn my brother's adventure knife. Though my brother was not a Boy Scout, that old Boy Scout knife was special to him.

I wanted to be able to share that, or to help someone else share it. So my idea is to send a Boy Scout Knife out to someone to give to a youngster for their first knife. So if you know a kid who needs a knife (and it is okay for you to give them a knife) I invite you to nominate a kid you will give the knife to. But I also want more people to participate, so you can also enter for yourself.

Unfortunately, Camillus went bankrupt a while back, and even the new Camillus doesn't make an official Boy Scout Knife. I like to give away new official BSA licensed scout knives, but ScoutShop doesn't sell the classic pattern anymore.

Thanks to the generosity of W willintheweeds I have a NIB made in the USA Bear and Son Cub Scout Knife (he also sent me an extra for my son who will be starting scouts this year!). At first I was not sold on the Cub Scout pattern because it wasn't what I was used to, but I have to admit that the locking utility blades are really handy. My daughter has a selection of knives including an older Girl Scout Knife, but she likes the Cub Scout best. So if you are picking a knife for a younger kid, the Cub Scout is a very nice option.

I have also purchased a deluxe pattern Boy Scout knife (they have an added Philips head screwdriver and no bail). So there are good options available for the winners.

And to try to encourage more participation from the community, I also purchased a Case Mini Trapper to give away this year. I wanted more Made in USA options, and something to tempt the grown up collectors around here. And after Case reached out a few years back and donated some knives for earlier iterations of this GAW, I have no problem shelling out a little extra to offer folks a Case BSA knife. They are awfully fine, I recommend getting one for yourself if you so choose.

This year's knife offerings:

full


Also, in case anyone is interested, I'll also offer my personal old USA made Camillus BSA knife. Johnnythefox Johnnythefox sent me a UK made camp knife that has taken its place in my backpack, so I am willing to let someone else enjoy my Camillus, if they so desire.
full


This GAW has a history of inspiring generosity from the community (obviously, that is not something that I can guarantee, but with this crowd it is pretty reliable), so it is possible that new prizes might get added, but I think I am set up pretty well this year. And thanks again to W willintheweeds for his continuing generosity year after year.

Rules for this year:
  • Open to everyone
  • You can enter one time for yourself
  • You can enter a second time on behalf of someone else, preferably a child that you will give the knife to (make sure it is someone that you can give the knife to without any problems), or someone working hard at their recovery.
  • I will send the knife to anywhere in the US and Canada (And if you are a regular porch participant, I will send it internationally as well)
  • your entry will be your post in which you say "I'm in" AND tell me who you will give the knife to (whether to yourself or to someone you are nominating)
  • You don't have to tell me why you are nominating someone, but I would appreciate it if you did
  • Don't enter if there is some reason that it would be legally problematic for you to enter

I am going to let this run for a couple weeks. There usually aren't many entries, so the odds are good if you decide to enter :)

Note:

I was inspired by a [IMG alt="Charlie Mike"]https://www.bladeforums.com/data/avatars/s/112/112780.jpg?1492197467[/IMG] Charlie Mike giveaway seven (or so) years back, when he gave away a knife as a mitzvah following the passing of a friend and fellow recoverer. Since my brother was also in recovery when he passed I thought it was an extra fitting mitzvah. As I was nearing the anniversary of my brother's death, I thought this would be a fitting way to help make his memory be for a blessing. When I do this giveaway I like to mention the history of the tradition.

Sadly, Charlie Mike left us far too early after he too managed to stay sober for the rest of his life. He had just passed his five year sober mark when he died in January 2019. May his memory be for a blessing.
Not in, just to say I admire post like this (and those who post them!). Good luck to all entrants! 👍
Scout.jpg
 
Always a sad reminder of the frailty of human life, but a great Porch tradition, and a fantastic way to honour your brother I think :)

If you remind me early next year, I'll send something over Scout related :thumbsup:

Not an entry from me, but I might nominate someone subsequently, and will edit my post :thumbsup:

Edit - I'd like to make an entry for Charlie waynorth waynorth 's youngest grandson, Declan, if that's OK? :thumbsup:

c8LSBrQ.jpg
 
Last edited:
Awesome GAW. Thanks for sharing your brother's story. I'm in for myself and one of my granddaughters. I was an Eagle Scout and she is in scouts now. Thanks again.
 
Wow, thank you for the generous giveaway, and I’m truly sorry for the loss of your brother. Words are simply insufficient. It’s not a very manly thing to admit to on an Internet forum but I actually had tears in my eyes, reading your post. I’m glad he was in a better place before the end and I can only imagine your sorrow, then and now. This is a noble way to remember him.

I’d like to enter once on my own account and once on behalf of the oldest of my boys, because he is almost to pocket knife age (6), and because I was an Eagle Scout, and my first knife was a scout pattern. They’re great knives.
 
Wow, just wow abbydaddy abbydaddy . Your story puts things into perspective.

I would like to enter your Memorial GAW, and thank you for the opportunity to participate. The boys name he knife would be for is Jannis, 14 years old, he loves to fish and being "out and about" in general.

Enjoy each day to the fullest. Tomorrow may never come, albeit we sure hope so.

Keeping your brother and your family in my thoughts.

Thanks for entering .577NE .577NE , that is one entry for the kids knife drawing.

This is incrediblely gracious of you. Posts like this are what made me a gold member and not just a long time lurker.
Ill take an entry for my little nephew. Boy isn't even 1 yet and I have a little cigar box knife collection set that a scout will fit right into.

Thank you for entering Nonless Nonless , that is one entry for the kids knife drawing.

I would like to enter for my friend’s son, who is 8 and about ready for his first camping knife!

Thanks for entering Ernie1980 Ernie1980 (I suspect we share a birth year), that is one entry for the kids knife drawing.

Awesome GAW. Thanks for sharing your brother's story. I'm in for myself and one of my granddaughters. I was an Eagle Scout and she is in scouts now. Thanks again.

Thanks for entering 1 1911bphil , that is one entry for the kids knife drawing and one for the adult knife drawing.

Wow, thank you for the generous giveaway, and I’m truly sorry for the loss of your brother. Words are simply insufficient. It’s not a very manly thing to admit to on an Internet forum but I actually had tears in my eyes, reading your post. I’m glad he was in a better place before the end and I can only imagine your sorrow, then and now. This is a noble way to remember him.

I’d like to enter once on my own account and once on behalf of the oldest of my boys, because he is almost to pocket knife age (6), and because I was an Eagle Scout, and my first knife was a scout pattern. They’re great knives.

Thanks for entering G GaiusJulius , that is one entry for the kids knife drawing and one for the adult knife drawing.

Thanks to everyone who has entered so far. I will keep this GAW open a while longer yet. As it currently stands, we have 5 entries for the kids, and 2 for the grown-ups. Those are pretty good odds, especially for the adults.

Don't be shy about entering everyone. If you've ever been curious about scout knives, consider trying one out.
 
Always a sad reminder of the frailty of human life, but a great Porch tradition, and a fantastic way to honour your brother I think :)

If you remind me early next year, I'll send something over Scout related :thumbsup:

Not an entry from me, but I might nominate someone subsequently, and will edit my post :thumbsup:

c8LSBrQ.jpg

Thank you for the offer Jack, I will be sure to take you up on it next year. And hopefully I will get my GAW underway a little earlier in the year next time.

Cheers :)
 
Sad but Wonderful Memorial GA, abbydaddy abbydaddy , and nice seeing you and Abby in Oregon!! I am still saving the Scout I won from you for my grandson (he's not quite ready yet!!)!!!
I'll put a nomination in this post when I find a young'un somewhere that needs one!
Not an entry for me!!
I have already won a knife for my oldest grandson, Duncan, almost 6 years old! But he has a younger brother, Declan, who was 2 years in April!! I'd like to enter the younger in the contest (as promised)!! If he wins, I'll hold it for him until his parents OK the gift of a knife!!
Thanks abbydaddy abbydaddy , for this poignant contest!!
 
Okay, I've let this thread moulder for long enough. I'll close it up by Thursday, and try to get the knives mailed out on Friday.

As it currently stands, I've got six entries for the kids, and three for the adults. Let me know if you or any kids you know could use a shot at a scout knife.

Be well everyone :)
 
I have already won a knife for my oldest grandson, Duncan, almost 6 years old! But he has a younger brother, Declan, who was 2 years in April!! I'd like to enter the younger in the contest (as promised)!! If he wins, I'll hold it for him until his parents OK the gift of a knife!!
Thanks abbydaddy abbydaddy , for this poignant contest!!
May I also enter for Charlie's grandson please? I'll edit my original post :thumbsup:
 
Back
Top