Seafood or steak

silenthunterstudios

Slipjoint Addict
Joined
Feb 2, 2005
Messages
20,039
Whats your preference? Seafood or steak? I've leaned more towards seafood most of my life. Whenever I've gone to a nice place for dinner, I almost always order the crabcake, mako shark, rockfish, mahi mahi etc. In the past few years, I started ordering steak, which I have always loved but usually grilled myself at home. Now, I've started ordering seafood again.
 
I'm going with steak 90% of the time. I do however order crab cakes or lobster...with steak. :)
 
When I go out: Seafood.

At home: Steak.

No restaurant I have ever been to has been able to grill a steak like I do, so its just a waste of money to me. I live somewhat far from the ocean (a whole 4 hours!!!!) and in my small town there is a lack of good seafood for sale, so I usually will order it at a restaurant to get my fishy fix.
 
I generally order seafood when I'm out if I'm at a really nice place. I can cook a good steak at home and I never cook fish at home. Plus, my wife is allergic to shellfish so I never have that at home.

If the place isn't so nice, though, I'd go with the steak because you can always douse a so so steak with some kind of sauce, but I'd be worried about sketchy seafood.
 
I'm of the seafood out and steak at home variety.I love a good Porterhouse or Ribeye on the grill.
 
Most seafood is alright, but a GOOD steak is to die for and a GREAT steak is to kill for! With that in mind, I guess you might put me in the group favoring steak.
 
Seafood - if the place is reputable for seafood. The whole point of seafood is that the place can get it fresher than you can.

Steak, like others have said, I can cook steak better than most restaurants who think medium rare is medium. Now if I'm in a place that has a reputation for steak than I get steak but most times I'm drawn to seafood.
 
Steak, if I were on a deserted island with no indigenous four legged critters, I'd die, well maybe I'd have to learn to eat seafood without deep fryin' it.
 
Definitely gotta go seafood on this one. Nothing quite as delicious as a pile of freshly steamed manila clams. No need for any seasonings, as they're naturally salty. Growing up by the Pacific, I developed a love of seafood, from clams and crab to fish of all types, including those annoyingly bony carp. Anyone can get a good steak in the U.S., but it's so darn difficult to get seafood done right.

Living over an hour away from the ocean, I'm tempted to make a trip over to the coast to get some fresh clam chowder, served in a sourdough bread bowl with a couple splashes of Tapatio. God, I'm hungry now.
 
Seafood. I'll take Dungeness crab, salmon, & prawns over steak any-day.
 
Depends on my mood, normally.

Tonight? Provided I could get it just like I like it..... hmmm.....

Seafood.

But a steak sure would be good!
 
Out on the town I'm gettin' seafood (unless the place has great Prime).
If I have a choice at home, and I'm cookin' it, I'll take the steak please. Ribeye, rare.:thumbup::)
 
My steaks are better than most restaurants'. Steak is just too simple to make when you own a Weber grill. A bit of olive oil, salt and pepper, and then it's eight to twelve minutes on the grill. I'm fortunate to be able to get USDA Prime beef when I want it, so my steaks are wonderful at home. With my steak, I want a great Pinot Noir but I don't want to pay the 100+% markups at restaurants. I want a real Caesar Salad which most restaurants won't do because of raw egg. And before all of that, I want a perfect Martini which is hard to find at restaurants. So, steaks I usually do at home.

Some seafood you can do at home easily too. Cedar Planked Salmon, for example, is a snap on the Webber. But a lot of seafood is a lot of work to prepare. Cows are such big animals that the store breaks them down for you. But a lot of seafood is small animals and so the store just sells you the whole thing. Even chickens come plucked and emptied out at the store. If you had to pluck and clean it out yourself, you'd probably eat less chicken too. It's not that I'm opposed to butchering animals, it's just time-consuming. So, seafood that needs extensive cleaning and prep is best outsourced.

There's a lot more to do with seafood too. A steak, a spritz of olive oil and some salt and pepper. You never see steak grenobloise or steak almondin or steak pantries with a hazlenut crust. But fish? There are a lot of ways to do fish. Epicurious has over 1100 recipies for fish and only 162 for steak.

The best steak is simple. Excellent seafood is much harder. So, for my eating out dollars, it's usually seafood.
 
:DBeing born, raised and still living in a major beef producing state!!:thumbup: I vote steak now that being said there aren't many places that can outdo me at my own grill,:D in the middle of the US it is sort of a challenge to get fresh seafood and I do love "FRESH" seafood BUT steak and taters are a staple;).
 
Taking into consideration the fact that I live about as far away from an ocean as humanly possible while still being earth-bound (slight exaggeration,) I doubt I've ever had truly excellent seafood. Good, but not eye-popping. Steak gets my vote. Rich, fatty, juicy, bloody, beefy, gluttonous, murderous steak:D
 
Last edited:
Back
Top