I have a SOG pup and had both sheaths, the one that has the clip and the new on that has the line cutter notch. I HATE THEM BOTH! The 1st is obvious, there isnt enough handle to let you get a good grip. the new one holds the knife so tight that it takes 2 hands to draw it. The belt attachment is unique and could be a good Idea but the plastic is weak and bends very easily. Now this may be ok for those who dont carry or actually use their knives but as a Soldier/Medic in the Army this sheath just sucks. I love the knife but am currently looking for a better sheath. IMHO :grumpy: