Sentimental Knife Scales?

Joined
Dec 13, 2025
Messages
5
Have 2 probably low quality kitchen knives, chipped, over sharpened belly I guess you’d say. Scales are now raw wood and one is even separated/broken.

Here’s the thing, my fiancé at the time and I barely bought our first house, finances, young, the usual. There was a very elderly original owner couple and the wife really didn’t want to sell. We paid full value and she passed before the closing. Her husband was extremely grandfatherly I’ll say. He had a new stackable washer/dryer installed for us plus a few other things along with a note wishing us as many years of happiness as he and his wife had. They’d lived there since they had it built in the early 50’s, about 58 years give or take.


One thing I found in the old kitchen. Two very used long kitchen knives. We’ve been married 15 ish years now and together 20ish, I’m not great with dates lol. The knives have served us well and I’ve cleaned over 100 whitetail with them plus usual kitchen chores. A few years ago she wanted a Wustohf set so Santa brought it. I still use the old knives.

I’m sure there’s not much that can be done with the blades short of having them forged into a Damascus billet. I’ve been thinking of just rescaling them and maybe an experienced hand grinding them.

Thought I’d post here for some ideas or alternatives. I like things that patina and change as they age, copper, carbon steel, a few other materials. It would be nice to get a copper liner or something that ages as we do.
 
Sorry, had them inserted and tried editing somehow breaking the direct image embedded.
Should be the other knife or both:
Neither the blades nor the handles look to be in that bad a shape. The blades could be carefully touched up with a belt sander (I know: heresy!).
It looks like the handles shrank a bit on the top and the butt; that could also be ground down pretty easily.
The wood still looks sound. In your place, given the sentimental nature of the knife, I would carefully sand it, and put on your choice of finish (my choice is CA, but not everyone likes that.
The missing cutler’s rivet is also easily replaced, though it won’t have the old look of the remaining one.
Not saying that you do, but don’t put them in the dishwasher!

Whatever you decide, post pics, please.
 
Neither the blades nor the handles look to be in that bad a shape. The blades could be carefully touched up with a belt sander (I know: heresy!).
It looks like the handles shrank a bit on the top and the butt; that could also be ground down pretty easily.
The wood still looks sound. In your place, given the sentimental nature of the knife, I would carefully sand it, and put on your choice of finish (my choice is CA, but not everyone likes that.
The missing cutler’s rivet is also easily replaced, though it won’t have the old look of the remaining one.
Not saying that you do, but don’t put them in the dishwasher!

Whatever you decide, post pics, please.
Thanks, the one had the twisted lifting scale/handle and both have big gaps at tang but could probably steam, clamp, and epoxy those.

What’s CA finish? I’ve a few custom blades and belt axes but not fluent in all the options. With wood I tend to use alcohol based dyes, hard waxes, and some oil finish maybe. CA to me is glue lol, I sort of recall they had some finish left long ago, good point on dishwasher. I hand wash and the one missing a rivet I had in a vacation rental below the main house my brother lived in the last 5 years. We never installed a dishwasher but he could bend a 22 Oz claw hammer into a knot so no telling there.

They aren’t sentimental to her either. She told me to toss the one. I guess maybe I’m a bit sentimental about all the work they’ve performed in my hands as much as their origin.
 
CA is indeed cyanoacrylate, which equals Superglue. I've been using it for years for blades that I've put handles. There are differences of opinion as to whether it's food-safe, but I'm not dead yet. Old, yes.
I didn't see that there were big gaps between the tang and the wood, but I'll take your word for that.
It all boils down to how much you are about these knives. From the pics, they appear salvageable. Depends how much work you want to put into it.
 
CA is indeed cyanoacrylate, which equals Superglue. I've been using it for years for blades that I've put handles. There are differences of opinion as to whether it's food-safe, but I'm not dead yet. Old, yes.
I didn't see that there were big gaps between the tang and the wood, but I'll take your word for that.
It all boils down to how much you are about these knives. From the pics, they appear salvageable. Depends how much work you want to put into it.
Thanks, I might try wetting the scales and clamping to see if I can force them close to the tang again. I’ll check out the CA process. On the wood working side of it I’ve always heard it’s fine. Only the fumes are really harmful to kids but once cured it’s not. Most everything is toxic these days.
 
Heck yeah, patch 'em up and give 'em another eighty years of service. Maybe fancy them up with exotic wood scales if you're so inclined. Make them special, make them *yours*.

FWIW I have one or more of that 66S Chicago slicer and they'll get decently sharp. Just keep the diamond sharpening rod handy. 😉
 
Back
Top