I haven't seen the original discussion, but an Australian knifemaker - Alistair Phillips AKA Cubane on the forums - did a strength test. I'm assuming this is kind of what you all are referring to, since he mentions that Todd Davison did a similar test.
http://www.knives.mutantdiscovery.com/destruction.html
Very impressive, I've been meaning to get another shadow pattern besides the Sodbuster Jr.
Thanks for putting that link up. I should point out though that it is testing the strength of the pivot pin in the scales (G10 or micarta) without a reinforcement not the strength of a bolstered scale versus a shadow pattern.
Alistair