Shallot in 110v

longbow

Basic Member
Joined
Jan 9, 1999
Messages
4,367
Rec. this knife today and basically I am underwhelmed. Knife seemed to be a bit slow on blade deployment and sometimes would hit perfect to lock up and sometimes not. So took it all apart and cleaned it out real well, used tetra to lube it and fires better now. Once I figured out how to best get it back together it was good to go.

Still though the 110v just doesn't seem to be the sharpest knife in the tool box if ya know what I mean. Blade cantle is perfect on both sides so sharpening it shouldn't be a problem either. Thought it was a bit bigger than it is too. More hand filling I was hoping. I have the full size Cyclone coming too so I can compare the two. But comparing it to the Lahar I own, truthfully to me there is no comparison frame lock or not. Lahar is to me a way way better knife. Has nothing to do with how or where they are made either. Lahar just fits me and my hand like a glove now that I have been carrying it for the better part of the week. Is starting to flip open much easier too, not uber smooth but smoother than it was for sure.

I think a big improvement with the Shallot would be a 4" blade or maybe a wider blade with the optional thum stud opening, and a grip similar in size to the JYD. If I remember correctly that was rather hand filling. Maybe it is the size thing with the Shallot. Anyways it is very well made that goes without saying and the knife is super popular it seems and Kershaw uses great steels so no bitch there. Well these are just quick observations over the course of 3 hrs. or so with it. keepem sharp

Addendum: the sharpness thing I talked about above. Well no worries. I'll be truthful most of my knives that I own feel sharper than the 110v, but I just cut up a packing slip which I know you're thinking big deal. Well this blade took about the tiniest of slivers off the sheet I have ever seen and that is without any support for the paper. Kind of hard to explain but this piece of paper was sitting under the monitor and well wrinkled so it was "soft" or pliable a better word maybe. Holding a corner of the sheet I proceeded to cut the tiniest bits of paper in very long strips off the sheet. Tried that with my 7 and Lahar and both of those knives would tend to wrinkle the sheet before cutting it, and to cut the sheet I had to hold close to the where the cutting action would start, the 110v just cut it like a nothing. A good sign I think. :D
 
Last edited:
The Shallot is a production version of the Ken Onion "Dead Sexy" custom, hence the size and shape. It will get smoother as you use it. Mine came very sharp. I will reprofile it soon to make it even sharper. I do this with all my user knives. This is a new steel for Kershaw (or perhaps anyone?) and user feedback will probably determine if they use it again. Put it through its paces and let us know how it works. A big plus is that being a limited edition and very popular it will be easy to trade or sell if you decide it does not fit you well.
 
S110V "feels" less sharp than it actually is. Comparing a Shallot to a JYDII or Lahar is kind of "apples and oranges"...the "Onion" series are all known for having slim blades and handles for ease of carry. Having carried all three plenty, I can tell you the Shallot is a "big knife" that carries like a Leek, which is why I love it dearly.

It is the perfect blend of art, function, comfort, and viable for self-defense. Win win win.

6 months ago I thought the Shallot to be a silly design. Now I have as many Shallots as I have Blurs and Leeks.
 
I'm very impressed with the S110V so far. Mine came very sharp. The grind was near perfect, alignment, lockup, all above average. That's what I've come to expect from Kershaw and I'm not disappointed.

The action was a bit tight. It worked it's way in and locks up with a strength that is easy to feel. The framelock was positioned exactly as I like it right from the box. I expect good durability and longevity.

Due to some nerve damage weakness in my right hand I did descide to put a few pieces of grip tape ( bathtub type cut to design in this case).

I like metal gripped knives when ergonomic, as this is. The tape is for insurance purposes as I can't tell how light or hard I'm gripping the handle some times.

For me my favorite blade length is between 3.5 inch, and around 3.75 inch. Perfect for me.

Some don't like a recurve style blade. I'm not one of them. I love the extra belly the design gives.

All in all I really like it, and the steel is as good as I thought it would be.....so far. I really hope they will use more of this steel in the future.

I'd be in hog heaven with a S110V blur for my collection. How about a G10 shallot/S110V sprint.

All kinds of potential here. The heat treat seems good, likewise grinds. Kudo's Thomas, and Kershaw. Joe
 
Last edited:
Rec. this knife today and basically I am underwhelmed....
Wow, that's just the opposite of my experience. I've been EDCing a 13C26 Shallot for a few months now, it's an outstanding knife, and have recently acquired ZDP-189 and S110V versions. All are flawless in fit, finish and operation, the beefed-up SpeedSafe really bangs 'em open with authority.

Give it a bit of time, I think it'll grow on you. FWIW I never cared for recurves or AO before; the Shallot has totally changed that. :)
 
Gotta tell all you fella's. The Shallot is a put together knife for sure. 110v is sharp, framelock locks up perfectly with lots of room for wear etc. etc. To me though it just doesn't stand up to the Lahar. I am tellin ya this knife(Lahar) is perfect for edc for me in everyway. Great grip ergos, it is hand filling and yet very comfortable and safe feeling in the hand. The VG10 steel has excellant heat treat and doesn't burr out when sharpening it to a razors edge. No need to strop the final edge in other words. Deployment of the blade is extremely smooth, like on ball bearings if you will. Nope so far for me the perfect Kershaw for me is the Lahar, bar none. I have had a couple of the ZT knives, skyline which I carry religously at work, Ti Bumps, Vapor(still have it after several yrs), JYD ti frame lock SG2, and a couple of others that slip my mind at the moment. None in my opinion work for me as well as the Lahar. Again my opinion and will comment on the lg Cyclone when I get it later this week or next, whenever it arrives. A frame lock Lahar would be the nuts with ti one side g10 the other. Kershaw would sell a million of them me thinks. keepem sharp
 
I agree that the Shallot seems a little small. If you head in knowing that it's not a chunky knife, it does fit the role of a slim pocket knife very well.
We need some S110V on a more substantial knife. Even the Blur would do, but I want something more along the lines of the ZT0200 or Offset.
 
Back
Top