Should i get a Carnivore???-and why.

F

frank aka rage

Joined
Jan 16, 2000
Messages
37
Is the carnivore fast to open, like my endura's, is the lock really strong, or just a gimmick, i know these are dumb questions, but i've never held one.

I've trusted my Axis lock, and afck's to defend my self with, will the Carnivore let me down.

Overall, how is the construction, is it strong, or weak-how big are the bolts/screws etc. Thanks

------------------
"for future shall not bring freedom..but not the sight that man sees, harvest your freedom, and make a future..for no one is here to protect your fate, and tame your dreams-freedom, it's in the air..."
 
Hi Frank!
I think at the Rekat-forum is the right plce for answers.
I like mine, but in my opinion there are some sharp angles(on the handle). It locks solid and i think with a little practice it should open fast althoug i prefer my starmate for speed-opening.
Why buy it? Because there are places where it's not wise to carry a sifu.
smile.gif

Greetings
red
 
I`ve got 2 sifu`s and I love them. And yesterday I ordered 2 carnivour`s. These knives seem to be built tougher than any of my other folding knives including BM and spyderco. They are more heavy and not quite as slick but when they are locked open they fill like a fixed blade. The only weak place that I could find was the fact that the clip screw goes only into the g10 scales. It does no go on down into the stainless steel liners. This may or may not be a problem. So far I`ve no problem with mine coming loose. But I think you will be glad you bought one. I my mind it`s the toughest defensive folders I have.

------------------

janefromnc

walker
 
Go all the way...get a SIFU
biggrin.gif


------------------
And there appeared another wonder in heaven; and behold the great red dragon having seven heads and ten horns, and seven crowns upon his heads...And His tail drew the third part of the stars of heaven, and did cast them to the earth; and the dragon stood before the woman which was ready to be delivered, for to devour her child as soon as it was born.
 
I'm going to wait for the Omnivore, I hear they eat anything.
wink.gif


------------------
"Will work 4 Knives!"
 
Used it for 2 days and returned it. Lockup is good but has lots of blade play and is very dull.
 
Why Buy a Carnivour?
Probably because it is THE strongest and toughest folder on the market to date.
Probably because it has a handle that feels like it was made for your hand and no other.

Probably because the knife is constructed in such a way as to give one the impression that the knife is BOMB-proof.

There are probably other reasons, but do you need any other reasons?
The knife was made to rock and roll, and to that end, it ROCKS!

Just as a side note, some have an action that is a bit "gritty". Check out a few and pick the best one. I understand that REKAT is working this bug out of current models, if memory serves me correctly.
I would not tradde my Carnivour for ANYTHING. I love it that much.
wink.gif


------------------
If it's stupid but works, then it isn't stupid!
 
they're junk a friend of mine bought one,it was stiff and gritty opening,you couldnt close it without using both hands to close the locking mechanism,it was very dull out of the box and the handle was very rough and uncomfortable with rough edges.if they get theyre quality control up to speed then they would have a bomb proof knife.
 
OK, Wulfgur, since you've stepped up to the plate, let me be the first to tell you that calling a REKAT "junk" after holding your friends for a few minutes is not appropriate. I'm restraining myself here, so bear with me. Gritty action? Sometimes. Easily cured. You say it was so stiff you had to use two hands to close and open it? Well damn, I got these things called "allen keys" that work miracles on them little screw-type thingys that hold the knife together. If you can honestly say that you've locked your hand into a more secure grip than the Carnivore's I'd like to know what it was. G10, Rolling Lock, 440C liners and ATS-34 blade, man, that doesn't sound like junk to me. Because it's not.
Not only does REKAT have a strong following here on BF, but Bob Taylor is a heck of a guy. Every maker can have one slip through the cracks of QC. Please think about what you're saying next time before you post.
-Paul
 
Wulfgar,
What ptpalpha says is absolutely right.
Calling a Carnivour a piece of junk is about as innaccurate a statement as I've heard in a long time. The problems you describe are easily rectified with a minimum of tools and effort. True, your friend may have gotten a sample that shouldn't have passed QC, but that happens even with the best of production knives. No one but GOD is exempt from Murphy's Law.

He should return it if the Allen Wrench adjustment doesn't work, but I think that is the problem in this instance.
I think you'll find more fans of the Carnivour here than detractors as a great knife, like the Carnivour, just does not come along every day. As a matter of fact, I don't think anyone has come up with a more tank tough knife to date.
And also, as I stated in my prior post, I understand REKAT is taking steps to alleviate the "Grittiness" problem.
Good Luck finding a better overall package than the Carnivour.
If you find something, let me know. For real. I have to see that and get one for myself!

------------------
If it's stupid but works, then it isn't stupid!
 
Frank, i like my Carnivour. There was a bit of gritiness,but it is gone now. It opens quickly and closes just as quickly without touching the blade. it is a rugged knife and fits great in my hand. I would bet its locking system is stronger than BM axis. I have a Sifu coming,but still like that carnivour. 'I just want to see a REKAT like the Carnivour lockup with a plus 5 inch blade! So many knives!
 
Paul,
i had no intention of making u have to hold yourself back,i gave my honest opinion about the example of that particular knife that i used for a couple of days.the knife is a very good design and as i said with better quality control it should be up there with reeves and spyderco etc.when u pay 100 +dollars for a knife it should come to u in working order and sharp,not the other way around.as far as the company is concerned they are doing everything they should to make it right with no questions asked,this was not meant as a personal attack toward rekat just my opinion,i'm sorry if u took offense but differing opinions are what makes bladeforums the best knife site on the net.
 
Wulfgar, very true. Differing opinions are what makes this a cool place to be. However, stating "don't buy one, they're junk" is a lot different than saying "I wouldn't buy one, the one I checked out was junk". And in all honesty I think you have to admit that (1) it appears the knife you saw was a fluke of QC (the fact that it came from REKAT anything but shaving sharp indicates this), (2) the problems you note are all easily corrected, and (3)the many, many owners of REKAT knives that continually post praises of their product would indicate that REKAT's in general are not junk, which is what your post indicated. Am I saying that your friend should keep the knife and try to correct these things himself? Absolutely not. Send it back to REKAT and let their customer service (which also gets great reviews) do their stuff.
 
You should buy a Carnivour. One of us ought to have one and i can't afford it.
biggrin.gif



------------------
-------------------------
"It is not criminals who enter schools and shoot children . . ."
--Ann Pearston, British gun control apologist and Moron
 
sdesarno, you got that right! As much as I like my REKAT, the original by Mr. Crawford is the King Mamba of Carnivores! If you can swing the Deutche marks, it's definately the way to go! (have you seen the talonite one with the desert ironwood scales? THAT's a truly great knife!)
 
I also say get the Crawford Carnivore if you have the resources. No grittiness there. Just a purpose driven, ergonomic tank of a defensive folder.
smile.gif


I also bought a REKAT Carnivore early on for a friend. It came a little gritty in the action and some sharpness on the G10. After use and cycling of the pivot, the blade opens and closes smoothly. I dremel the edges of the G10 and the grip is now very comfortable. The testament is that the REKAT is his daily carry.

I also remember reading somewhere that REKAT is working out the "grittiness" problem. That would be good. But despite that and a little work on the G10, I still highly recommend this knife to anyone who is interested in a rock solid folder, with a defensive purpose in mind.

I also gave a Pioneer clip point to my brother, the electrician. He probably uses a knife more than any average person in his work. He loves the rock solid feel of that knife.

QC issue doesn't plaque just REKAT. I find them as much in Benchmade products. Spyderco is the exception though. Spyderco rules in that department. Too bad the RL deal fell through between Spyderco and REKAT.

sing

AKTI #A000356
 
I think a Carnivore is worth getting. It is a very sturdy knife and should be able to take extreme abuse while still functioning. REKAT should, however, improve its level of finish and quality control. If they want to really compete with companies like Spyderco, Benchmade, and Kershaw, they need to make their products more visually appealing. Even if it raised their pirces by 10 or 15%, I think it would be worth it for them in the long haul. Their quality control could be better also, but the one time I had a problem the company was quite nice and quick about fixing it.
 
Paul,
Wulfgar, obviosly upset you with his comment, and I can understand that, and even though you tried to restrain yourself, you came down a little hard on the Newbie.
You posted,
"Please think about what you're saying next time before you post."
I think that's pretty good advice, for us all.

I'd be curious as to where Wulfgar's friend got this knife, from a store, Internet dealer, Ebay? Any company can have a bad one slip out the door, but I think part of the responsibilty is ours and where we buy from.
I mean if we are buying for the cheapest price possible, sooner or later you may get stuck with a second. Let the Buyer beware!
 
the knife was bought on the internet through a very reputable dealer i will not name him publicly because he did not resolve my problem but rekat is taking care of it for me.the knife was not sold as a second.if u want to know who it is email me and i will tell you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top