Since Im done with my file knife its time to make another, in your opion what

[fencepost]

is the best steel for a hard working knife with the ability to hold a decent edge,

The knife will be used for hunting, fishing camping chopping an all around tuff knife. It will have an 8" blade

What would be the best steel?

 

[NJBillK]

1084 might work well for you. Relatively easy HT regimen with the ability to take a pretty good edge while retaining some decent toughness. Check out Aldo/NJ steel baron.

 

[Cobalt]

If you are making your own knives, I would recommend 52100.