So I unearthed some old axe heads

[Square_peg]

It's cool that they both still show hardened steel after all these years. I love these.

 

[jake pogg]

It's cool that they both still show hardened steel after all these years. I love these.

Sorry about a pedantic correction-they show Welded-in,higher-carbon steel,(wether it's hardened,and if so-how much,we don't know....).

What in common speak is known as a "temper-line" often is of course the weld boundary(though a "tempered",as in a heat-treated section,can also be of a contrasting color).

Those axes Are way cool-looking,for sure.The first is certainly cleft-welded,so no problem with just sharpening and using it.The second one may be wrapped,and only those priviledged ones to see a top-view may knowl wether it has any steel left in the center,where the new cutting edge will have to be....

 

[mete]

Looking at the texture of the first one ,I wonder if it's wrought iron [or poor steel ] with proper steel insert ?

 

[FortyTwoBlades]

Looking at the texture of the first one ,I wonder if it's wrought iron [or poor steel ] with proper steel insert ?

My thoughts as well. It shows the texture/grain of wrought.

 

[Square_peg]

Sorry about a pedantic correction-they show Welded-in,higher-carbon steel,(wether it's hardened,and if so-how much,we don't know....).

It can be either a weld line or a quench line or both. We recently had a photo on here of an axe with a double line, one darker than the other. They couldn't both be the weld line. I suspect one was the weld line and the other showed the depth of quench.

 

[jake pogg]

It can be either a weld line or a quench line or both. We recently had a photo on here of an axe with a double line, one darker than the other. They couldn't both be the weld line. I suspect one was the weld line and the other showed the depth of quench.

Exactly.Out of the two,the "quench" line would be closer to the edge,and it'd be Straight(naturally,more or less, representing a level of quenching fluid).

These two axes show an unmistakable difference in material.The higher Carbon in the steel insert makes it etch darker.

Wrought Iron,(WI),is not really an exact term,metallurgy-wise for sure,but even as a trade-term,as it changed around with the times...It used to mean generally that the steel in question was obtained by means of the so-called "Puddling" process;and the carbon-content,as well as any other specifics,differed widely,to say the least...

Eventually the term WI grew to mean low-C,malleable steel of whatever level of refinement(early in the 20-th c. it was still obtainable in "refined",to "5-x refined" grades,from some producers,and i believe it was finally discontinued in the US in 1969),but still all that was applied but loosely,and the chem.composition of WI has remained fairly random.....

 

[garry3]

Looking at the texture of the first one ,I wonder if it's wrought iron [or poor steel ] with proper steel insert ?

Looks like it. Since the land was cleared 1900-1910 those axes were probably already well used or the land was cleared earlier than thought.
It's interesting.