So what is Spyderco missing??

Joined
Jul 4, 2002
Messages
769
What in your opinion is spyderco missing from the lineup? Is it small knives? Big utility knives or what? Maybe a bigger variety in colours? Handle materials, fixed blades? Lock types?

A concern that I have is the lack of colour selection and handle materials in the line. More colours shouldn't add too much to the cost right? I mean Spyderco already purchases some FRN in blue, and red already so how much more would it cost to simply put some of that FRN to work on models such as the delica, native and Endura. A red enudra may confuse some people who have the trainer knives but why not use other colours than? The use of blue g-10 on the dodo is a good start that needs to be expanded. I do not know if Spyderco is set-up for anodization but Aluminium could be utilised to a much higher degree. Aluminium is lightweight, can be anodized with different colours and I assume easier to mill into different shapes and sizes. I like the steel handled knives that are part of the line now but the flatness of the handles leaves me wanting more. Some sculpting of the handle will add costs but it would give the knives and even more ergonomic feeling.

Onto the lock variety. There is not a whole lot I can comment on here. Spydercos usage of lockbacks, liner locks, compression lock, integral liners and the new ball bearing lock has put them in the lead in this field. The variety in this department is phenomenal an increase to the number of knives to utilise the ball bearing lock would be nice.

Fixed blades have never been a strength of spyderco. The selection that it has is good start but it suffers a bit. Spyderco should stop using FRN on any of its other fixed blade entries until the other two are discontinued. Throw some g-10 or kraton handled knives for higher end Fixed blades to round out the selection. The Lum tanto is a good knife but add another knife into the mix to make it interesting.

What I hope to see in the future from spyderco is a knife in FRN with some colour variety, a ball bearing lock, a knife similar in size to the endura, a few more g-10 knives with colours other than black, some fixed blades, any fixed blades with handles other than FRN. Adding different colours to existing lines will add a whole lot more skus into the system, something spyderco is trying to cut back on. I think taking some select knives and putting some colour to them is worth it. I dunno how well the blue delica did but I am guessing sales on that were not high enough to justify the expansion of that idea.

This thread was intended to liven things up in a rather slow period of posting. I am a huge spyderco fan so in no way am I trying to slag them.
(Putting flame retardant suit on just in case though)
 
I was thinking something like that today.

I put side by side the Tufram Civilian, Ti Herbst and Green Lum Chinese. These are WAY different from each other and all the newer models. They're just so very different from anything else I have.
Dodo next to them doesn't fit. And naturally there's a legion of black G-10, black FRN and black Micarta. But if they sell better... :) Don't know what I am getting at here, too late at night.
 
I am new to Spyderco, and even though I am sending my Chinook back for warranty work/replacement, I would love to see a larger 4.5-5.5" fixed-blade version with basically the same handle as the folder (ie, not the typical big, bolstered, round handle). Or just new handle material/topography on the Temperance with the addition of a trailing point blade option to match the varieties of the Lil T.

But I really think Spyderco's lineup is quite extensive already. If anything, I think it would be cool in the coming years if Spyderco could become the standard for manufacturing quality in production knives. I think it already is the standard for design quality and customer service. But I know I'm not the only one who has been disappointed by the execution in some cases. From what people have said about the ATR, it sounds like Spyderco may be taking a step in the right direction.
 
I'd LOVE to see (to HAVE) a Spyderco version of the Cold Steel Vaquero Grande...(VG-10 steel, dual stainless liners, Spyderedge, Spyderhole, ambidextrious pocket clip).:).
 
Spyderco lacks a no-compromise, pedal-to-the-metal self-defense folder.
If anyone thinks Spyderco presently produces such a knife, they need to take that knife, compare it to an Extrema Ratio Nemesis and rethink the issue.
I think Spyderco could produce such a knife, but it seems Spyderco either doubts the market will support such a knife, or Spyderco doesn't want a real martial reputation.

I'd really like to see an American knife manufacturer blow Extrema Ratio away.
Nothing against Extrema Ratio: just a matter of national pride.
What ever happened to Made In America?
Spyderco should have an MBC flagship model, like General Motors has the Corvette, that by virtue of a superior design outperforms MBC knives costing twice as much.
Anyway, Benchmade doesn't seem able to do it and Spyderco seems to lack the will.
Perhaps if I understood all of the market and business factors surrounding knife production I would think twice before judging Spyderco.
But then, if I really knew so much about it, I suppose I could start my own knife company. :)

I apologize for my candidness, but it seems someone has to say it.
Spyderco needs to design and produce THE REAL THING.
The new balisong seems like a step in the right direction.
However, America needs a traditional self-defense folder built like an anvil (check out John Greco's folders) with point, edge, true ambidexterity, Tommy Tomorrow steel and Made in America written all over it.
Soldiers, Airmen, Sailors and Marines about to go in Harm's Way should stand in line for this knife.
 
Well that really depends on what you think is the real thing. I don't doubt that spyderco can make a balls to the wall bombproof folder but do they really want to? It seems that most people are happy with their military or police and I know that if spyderco decides to make a super hard use knife they are going to do it right unlike some other overpriced stri... knives :D But is this going to be cost effective for spyderco and will enough people buy this knife to make it profitable.
 
Even though they have been donig a good job of it, I would like to see them make evey knife in thier lineup fully ambidextrous. Some of the knives with liner locks are understandable, but they should at least have reversable clips. I would carry Spyderco knives exclusivly if that was the case. I am a lefty by the way. Other than that, they use the best steels, innovative designs, and kick ass packaging! Nothing else here.
 
I would like to see something like the Spyderrench or the next model, perhaps geared towards survival etc,etc. It is a damn shame that spyderrench has become obsolete!
 
Originally posted by Melvin-Purvis
...to make 'waved' Spyderco's... :D

Mel

Well That is possible. Just attach plastic zap strap to any tip up spyderco's opening hole and volia! A waved spyderco.
 
More Full sized Compression locking folders, they have the ATR, but i was thinking of something more like a compression locking Military. Also everything availible with a Stainless Steel handle should be availible with an FRN handle or a G10 handle.
 
I'd like to see a large (that means 4.5" blade minimum) folder, preferably a dedicated defensive folder. Obscenely strong/reliable lock, some kind of mechanism that works as a guard (whether a flipper, or a guard at the handle), useable in forward or reverse edge-up/in and edge-down/out, performant for slicing and thrusting.

Spyderco is obviously also missing a large fixed-blade, either a dedicated fighter (Hell's Bell equivalent) or a large camp knife, or something in between (like the Trailmaster or new Fehrman/Hood knife).

Thing is, all of these things are low-volume plays.

Joe
 
Spyderco should move to adjustable pivot screws on all it's FRN knives, as opposed to the riveted pivot pins that it uses now on most FRN models. How much more could it cost?
 
Originally posted by marty123
Spyderco should move to adjustable pivot screws on all it's FRN knives, as opposed to the riveted pivot pins that it uses now on most FRN models. How much more could it cost?

I salute this idea too, congratulations :) It will also allow to change (much easier and without damaging the FRN handles) a particular blade with a custom one if you like to ;)
 
I just think they should have a needlenose spyderrench.
Extra handle colors are nice, but not really required.
 
Spyderedge throwing knives? :)

Eh, they have the dedicated defensive knife somewhat, the civilian. Its not designed as a utility knife.
 
Back
Top