SOLID & RELIABLE camp or folding saw ???

I am definitely looking for a compact saw meant for backpacking.
Lots of folding pruner saw choices from the gardening or arborist worlds. IMHO look for Japanese style (cut on the pull stroke) folding saws with 8" or longer blades. Brands that enjoy good reputations are: Felco, Fiskars/Gerber, Silky, Corona, Sandvik/Bahco, Fanno, and (my two favorites) Tashiro Hardware's Folding Pocket Saw, and the Nakaya EX-240 saw (although it doesn't fold, it does come with a sheath/scabbard) from the Nokogiri.com team.

Be sure to check out the Ben Meadows website for a decently large selection of saws, some of which are folding pruners.

Here is a somewhat lengthy recent thread on saws:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=478095

A saw review from GibsonFan:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=455546

A page recommended by LongBow50...:
http://outdoors-magazine.com/s_topic.php?id_rubrique=24

... linked from this saw thread:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=376693

A thread on Japanese style saws:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=118353

My review of some saws:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=249653

Another saw thread:
http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=268425
 
Take a look at the pocket chainsaw. They weight next to nothing, take up very little room, work extremely well, and are very durable. I use and abuse mine all the time, and it is still going strong. Here is a write up I did about them a while back. Even if you want something more substantial, you can at least keep one in your kit. I have one in mine, but it likes to escape and cut up logs. :)
 
http://www.svensaw.com/
this a winner.
light weight and strong
if you can't cut it with this saw you'll need a chain saw.
i've used this baby in Y-----stone, not supposed to but hey.
cuts oak, pine, hickory, any wood
well made. well worth it.
buzz
 
Clearly it all depends on the wood you are intending on cutting. The trailblazer will eat through 6-7" logs without having to turn then over. I wouldn't want to tackle that with a folding pruning saw.

If you are just wanting a saw to facilitate getting a small fire going, then the pruning saw is ideal. I have both the trailblazer and one of those cheapo coglands. The coglands usually finds its way in my pack on a smaller trip.

If I know that fire is going to be a main feature of the trip - e.g. sitting around with my wife and kids, roasting hot dogs at night etc., then I definately bring the trailblazer and a good axe. If my intention is to clear wood, fallen trees on trails ect. then it is a gas chain saw. I usually like to keep the trailblazer in my truck for emergencies along these lines. I've had my trailblazer since about 1997. It is getting a bit dull now, but it has seen its share of heavy duty cutting, including clearing some decent sized dead trees in my dad's yard which died along with his chain saw.
 
For backpacking the sven saw is really hard to beat. It is one of the easiest (full size) saws to fold out and use. That said I want to try a pocketchainsaw.
 
Take a look at the pocket chainsaw. They weight next to nothing, take up very little room, work extremely well, and are very durable. I use and abuse mine all the time, and it is still going strong. Here is a write up I did about them a while back. Even if you want something more substantial, you can at least keep one in your kit. I have one in mine, but it likes to escape and cut up logs. :)

+1 sorta. I have 2, 1 in my bag and 1 in the glove box of the truck. They do work quite well, but to me require more effort if you have to do any amount of sawing.

I prefer my Silky, but 1 of these is always close by for when the Silky is somewhere else.

Rob
 
total 17 3/4 inch, outside teeth, 14 1/2 inch. that is for the smaller version. there is a bigger one though
 
Baron,

I think you need to provide a bit more information on what you are trying to cut.

A while back i did a "saw-off" where I was comparing a Bahco 396-HP folding saw (the same as the laplander build to cut hard/dead wood, as opposed to the 396-JT which is for soft/green wood), an Unbelievable Saw (made by Supreme Products, who also make the Pocket Chain Saw - the only difference is in the handles), an 18" Trailblazer Take-down Buck Saw, and a Sven Saw.

My favorite of the bunch, by far, was the 18" Trailblazer Take-down Buck Saw. It went through wood like butter and the round handle was VERY comfortable in use. Also, when stowed away, the round tube is "easy" on the other gear (unlike the Sven Saw). Its only disadvantage is that it does take a little time to assemble, but that goes much faster as you get used to it. I also like that there are no small loose parts that can be lost (the wingnut can't - and doesn't need to - come off the tension rod -- unlike the wingnut on the Sven Saw).

To answer the earlier question - the Buck Saw comes in two sizes - 18" and 24". The 18" one worked fine for me, though if you have the room I would guess the 24" one would cut faster with the longer stroke. I'll also mention that I was a bit worried that the teeth on the saw blade would be damaged from rubbing up against the tubes when stowed away, BUT a friend of mine who works in a metal shop assured me that the heat-treated teeth are much harder than the aluminum tubes, and would not be damaged.

The Sven Saw was my next favorite. It cuts as well as the Buck Saw, but the handle isn't as comfortable (too thin) as that of the Buck Saw, and the package when stowed away is sharp enough to damage gear (though you might be able to grind down the sharp corners without any harm). The other issue is that it is a pain to install a new blade since it uses a split rivet that has to be punched out with a tool (flattened nail), whereas the Buck Saw has a loose blade. I should mention that there is a wingnut on the Sven Saw that could easily be dropped and lost. When I took it to the Boundary Waters years back I brought along two extra nuts - just to play it safe.

The Unbelievable Saw cut incredibly well - as good or better than the above-mentioned saws since on 4-5" branches it actually cuts three sides at once. The plastic handles are great - very comfortable, and the whole thing packs as small as the Pocket Chain Saw. Note that the first page on their website suggest it comes in a large blister pack, but in reality it comes rolled up in a nice small heavy duty zip pouch. BUT when cutting horizontal wood I would have to saw from the side, and EVERY time I did that the weight of the branch would come down on the bottom part of the saw and the saw would get stuck. Every time I found myself having to break off the rest of the branch while hoping the chain saw didn't break. I tried cutting from the bottom up, but it was difficult to do. I've heard some people complain that the hook on the Pocket Chain Saw coming undone, but it seems that would be very fixable (fold it a bit more).

The Bahco 396-HP cut the slowest, partically because of the length of the blade (7.5"). It was my least preferred of the bunch, though it certainly packs the smallest and is when stowed away is rounded and very gear-friendly.

Sometime I'll need to put them on a scale and see how much each weights.

Links:
Trailblazer Take-down Buck Saw: http://www.trailblazerproducts.com/
Sven Saw: http://www.svensaw.com/
Supreme Products Chain Saws: http://www.supremeprod.com/
 
Back
Top