Spyderco Manix 2 XL

S

SilentJohn

Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
2,715
could i please get some opinions about the Spyderco Manix 2 XL . preferably from those who own or have used the knife

i want to buy my first spyderco and i like my knives on the bigger side. my regular EDC is a benchmade 275 adamas
 
If you want a bigger Spyderco knife, but aren't fond of their other larger offerings (e.g. Military or Police models).

This will most likely be the knife for you. Quite a comfy, ergonomic handle shape too.

It is a solidly-built knife. I wouldn't compare it to Zero Tolerance or other over-built knives though, as it is a precision slicer.
 
I understand that would you say the military is a stronger design

also how is lock compared to benchmade's axis
 
I've handled a Manix but found the locking mech much harder to work than my Axis lock knives. I much prefer the lock on my PM2.
 
what about the spyderco vallotton any thoughts on this knife

C149GP%5Blarge%5D.jpg

C149GP-2%5Blarge%5D.jpg
 
SilentJohn said:
I understand that would you say the military is a stronger design

also how is lock compared to benchmade's axis
Click to expand...

I would consider the Manix 2 XL to be the stronger design of the two because it has double liners, unlike the Military that has only one recessed liner.
 
Scurvy092 said:
the ratchet action on that knife is SERIOUSLY cool.
Click to expand...

If you are referring to the Vallotton, there is no ratchet on that knife.

The Vallotton is easily one of my favourite folders. It is overbuilt with a thick blade, coming to a tanto point. The best way to describe the Vallotton is beautifully finished and massive.
 
A.P.F. said:
If you are referring to the Vallotton, there is no ratchet on that knife.

The Vallotton is easily one of my favourite folders. It is overbuilt with a thick blade, coming to a tanto point. The best way to describe the Vallotton is beautifully finished and massive.
Click to expand...

You're right, my bad. I have it confused with the Navaja.

spyderco_amsterdammeet2011_prototype_navaja.jpg
 
I like a solidly built, and heavy, knife. The Manix 2 is both.

I highly recommend it. It's my personal favorite, but in all fairness my collection isn't that extensive, and I don't own a Para2.
 
I bought one at the outlet store a few months ago. I went with the intent of picking up a Para 2, but in comparing them side-by-side I chose the Manix 2 xl. The handle is beefy and really ergonomic, with a host of grip enhancements. The blade is long and fantastically sharp, with plenty of slicing surface. I live in Colorado and often wear gloves while handling my knives, so a big handle and spidey-hole are attractive features. It's not incredibly heavy overall, but I am surprised that the steel liners aren't milled to save a little weight.

The ball-bearing lock is terrific, not quite as easily actuated as the axis on my well-worn 940, but what is?

The only real negative I have for it is that it rides a bit high in the pocket, and the model I have has a chrome clip. I would prefer deeper carry and a more discreet black clip.

It was a tough choice with the Para 2. I will probably get one of those too in the near future, but if you're a guy who appreciates a knife that is more substantial, the Manix won't dissappoint.
 
drvoxmentat said:
It's not incredibly heavy overall, but I am surprised that the steel liners aren't milled to save a little weight.

The ball-bearing lock is terrific, not quite as easily actuated as the axis on my well-worn 940, but what is?
Click to expand...


The latest production runs DO have milled liners, and most ppl say that the CBBL will loosen a bit, as it breaks in.
I just got mine, so we'll see if mine does, but most seem to agree that it will...
 
Just got one a couple of months ago, my first Spyderco and I love it. It came sharper than any knife I've ever bought, great ergo's, and a1 materials for that price point. I can't see myself buying any folders for a long time. *edit* It does ride really high in the pocket though, the only drawback IMO.
 
I just got a used Vallotton here off the forums. It is a BEAST! I was not expecting such an over built knife in such a elegant package. Grab one while you can.. the Manix will always be around. But get a Manix at some point. I'd go with the standard as you don't get a thicker blade with the XL.. just a longer blade.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top