I have small-to-medium sized hands; which do you think will be the better fit?
I have similar sized hands and own the Sage 2 and 3, and think you'd be fine with the Sage 1. Also, as SwimmingBird mentioned the Chaparral is a really nice-looking knife as well, there's a thread in the Spyderco forum about it with pics. I'm going to break my knife budget for the year and get a Sage 1 or Chaparral next.