Spyderco Temperance & Impala review

Cliff, I didn’t measure the edge angle when I got it – it looked like it had been sharpened several times by several people during the previous pass arounds. I first sharpened it without trying to even it out completely, but I did try to smooth out the edge some when I sharpened it before sending it off. I didn’t check the angle when I finished, but usually I freehand at about 20-25 degrees included.




- Frank
 
Thanks for the info, I was mainly curious about the batoning considering the relatively low edge profile.

-Cliff
 
There was no problem with the batoning, but I did expect any since cedar is a very soft wood. I had some seasoned hard maple I could have used, but I didn’t want to risk damaging a pass around knife.





- Frank
 
Yes, have been using both for awhile now, Military is constant EDC, Temperance as well when not at work.

Short review :

I have used a lot of fixed blades in the Temperance class, it is easily the quality of the better customs I have seen in regards to cutting ability, handle ergonomics, sheath functionality and overall balance of design. The NIB edge was sharper than any custom I have seen, and exceeded even the OLFA utility blades. It was so sharp I had to change the standard way I measured sharpness to be able to record it. It resharpens easily and the edge retention is solid, no problems with corrosion even with extended kitchen work.

I have not used a lot of folders, however the Military is the equal of what I have seen, and quite frankly there is little to improve on unless the design was going to be radically altered (change the flatish handle profile to increase ergonomics which of course changes ease of carry significantly). The cutting ability is very high, close to the Temperance (edge angle was slightly higher), grip is very secure and decently comfortable for that type of folder. Lock is secure under standard testing and extended heavy use operates smoothly with and without gloves.

I had some problems sharpening it initially with waterstones (diamonds were easy), which went away after realizing the problem was mainly a lack of initial work with the setting stones, and realizing that the honing time is slightly longer than with VG-10. With this determined and slightly modifing the edge angle to match my preference for freehand (same as Temperance), ease of resharpening was not difficult, though I would not call it easy, and obtaining a high sharpness either very polished or coarse was readily possible.

More specific details will be in the various reviews, very fine knives both. With the Temperance I was very surprised by its size, I expected it to be much smaller.

-Cliff
 
The Temperance dose not shake out of the sheath, but it dose have a slight bit of rattle (the rattle was only noticeable when shaking, not in normal carrying).

This is the one of the many problems with Kydex sheaths. I bought a Temperance recently myself, and mine does not rattle in the sheath. However, I have a Spyderco Perrin Bowie which does rattle in the sheath, and I find this very annoying. Kydex may be durable, but it certainly introduces alot of problems if the fit isn't just right.
 
Hi W.T.!


Actually, I think that the pass around Temperance and my Moran Drop Point sheathes are about the best factory Kydex sheaths that I have used. The Spyderco Fred Perrin is something that I am very much interested in, but I have not had a chance to use one yet, so I can’t comment.


The Temperance sheath only rattled when I shook it hard in my hand, and even then it was very minor.


BTW, how do you like your Temperance?

How dose it compare to your Perrin?






- Frank
 
I like both of the knives, but I am not sure which one I like best. The bowie has no guard but a deep finger choil which provides a secure grip. The bowie handle is also covered with a soft and somewhat sticky rubber material. The handle of the Temperance is more secure than that of many knives, I think, but the plastic material is harder than that of the bowie. I think I would like the softer rubber of the bowie on the Temperance. It feels more sticky and therefore more secure than hard plastic.

Keep in mind that I am one who puts alot of emphasis on handle security, and the knives I like best have long, straight guards. I think most people would be completely satisfied with the handle on the Temperance.
 
Thanks for the info W.T.!

Personally, I think I like the plain Zytel Temperance grip better than the Zytel/ Kraton insert grip on the Moran.




- Frank
 
Back
Top