Good advice from Mete regarding stainless.
I'd just use whatever you have on hand that you're comfortable heat treating. It's important not to over complicate your first attempt trying to setup everything perfectly. There's a high chance something is going to get screwed up on the first one, no matter how much pre-planning is put into it, and you could be already starting on number two by now.
Obviously, if you decide to keep making them you'll want to refine your materials and process. So I'm not criticizing, just encouraging you to make due with what's available to go ahead and make progress. Any steel HT'd within the proper RC range will work, and it can be round, flat, whatever.