How does stainless damascus compare with S35VN with respect to edge holding, corrosion resistence, toughness, etc?
Depends on what steels were used in the damascus.........
Damasteel uses RWL34 and PMC27
Oh yes, the Heat treatment, edge geometry and microstructure of the steel may also have something to with it.
On microstructure;
I have a Zackerty Serrata (Investment cast 440C). If you mirror polish the edges the edge holding is abysmal. Profile the edge with a medium or coarse DMT and the edge holding is fantastic. It cuts like a buzzsaw, seemingly forever. The more you use it, the sharper it seems to get. How would you compare the edge holding on that to S35VN?
on edge geometry;
I got 2 spyderco mules, one in Elmax one in Cruwear. With the factory edges the Cruwear edge lasted a lot longer than the Elmax and I was a bit disappointed with the Elmax. Now I've put 19 degree angles on both, the Elmax now outcuts the Cruwear. I just need to find the optimum angle for the Cruwear before I can even start to compare edgeholding.
Do I have to explain how HT can affect performance? What type of steel contributes about 50% of how well a knife performs. Here's a choice of 5 HT regimes for Damasteel each giving vastly different results.
http://damasteel.com/?page_id=192. PS: Those HT regimes each carry different levels of corrosion resistance as well.
I'd say it's vastly more important to get the right person to do the HT (and match it to the intended use) than it is to worry about the particular steel used.