Thanks for the bump ,I did not even know this exciting project was in the works. 52100
is the perfect steel for a bushcraft knife. It is tough ,holds a great edge and will please the very conservative bushcraft market. I almost hope you don't make a stainless one because then I would have to buy both. The real skandis are usually stainless ,it is only the UK and North American market that demands carbon.
To be precise 52100 is tool steel. It is a high carbon steel wth some of the additives found in some of the super stainless like Vanadium etc but without all the carbon. In my opinion tool steels are the best steel for knife blades
I am sure a classic bushcraft blade in 52100 would be huge especially with the Spyderco name ,rep and distribution. A more modern VG-10 and G-10 would be cool as well although it would not have the "soul" of the traditional version.
Kudos Sal on having the guts to use a steel like 52100. It is not the easiest steel to work with. I am really looking forward to the Mule team knife. As for flat versus scandi I think you kind of have to go with skandi not because it is better but because it is what people want in a bushcraft knife. I would like to see a but guard like the one on the Skookum tool.